Plot twist

Chapter 5 - THE BLUE CRAYON AND KEY 409

I stared at the small brass key in Dad’s fingers, my breath catching in my throat.

“Wait,” I said, pushing myself upright against the pillows. “Why would a safe-deposit box key with Lily’s blue crayon on it be taped to a listening device inside Preston’s flower vase?”

Dad didn't answer out loud. Instead, he held a finger to his lips, walked back over to the sink, and turned both the hot and cold faucets on full blast so the rushing water drowned out the microphone.

Then he took a tissue, wiped the brass key 409 dry, slipped it into his shirt pocket, and dropped the black plastic transmitter right back into the floral foam at the bottom of the orchid vase.

He turned off the water, walked toward the door with Jonathan, and spoke in a loud, tired voice for the benefit of the microphone.

“Well, Claire, Jonathan and I are going to head back to Charlottesville for the night so I can make Lily some supper,” Dad said clearly. “Try to get some sleep. We’ll figure out how to respond to Judge Beaumont on Monday morning.”

While speaking, Dad took Jonathan’s yellow legal pad, wrote two quick lines across the page in heavy black ink, and held it down for me to read before tearing the sheet off:

I’m checking you out AMA in 10 minutes through the service elevator. Don't speak above a whisper until we are out of the building.

I nodded once, swallowing hard, and said aloud in a shaky, defeated voice, “Okay, Dad. Tell Lily I love her and I’ll call her before bedtime.”

Dad patted my hand, picked up his brown cardigan, and walked out the door with Jonathan.

For the next eight minutes, I lay completely still in the hospital bed, staring at the white orchids by the sink, knowing Eleanor and Preston were probably sitting in Eleanor’s Mercedes in the hospital parking deck right now, listening through a receiver to hear if I was crying or calling anyone on the room phone.

Instead, I reached slowly under my hospital gown and unclipped the plastic telemetry leads from my chest one by one, sliding my feet to the edge of the mattress.

At the ninth minute, my bathroom door—which connected to the adjoining empty recovery suite next door—clicked open silently.

A middle-aged nurse with kind eyes and a wheel-chair stood in the tiled doorway, with Dad right behind her holding my clothes and a loose wool poncho he’d bought at the hospital gift shop to cover my strapped shoulder.

“Dr. Patel already signed your discharge papers at the central desk, Mrs. Whitcomb,” the nurse whispered, helping me slip into my trousers and the poncho without raising my injured arm. “Your father had the hospital administrator lock your electronic chart so the front desk still shows you admitted in Room 412 until Monday morning.”

Five minutes later, we rolled out the rear loading dock near the ambulance bay and straight into the back of Jonathan Hale’s tinted SUV.

As soon as the heavy doors locked and Jonathan merged onto Interstate 64 West toward Charlottesville, I let out the breath I felt like I’d been holding for twenty minutes.

“Dad, explain the key in the vase!” I said, turning toward the front passenger seat where he sat turned halfway around to face me. “Eleanor put the listening bug in the orchids. She obviously didn't put a safe-deposit key with blue crayon on it in there!”

Dad pulled the small brass key 409 out of his pocket and held it up under the SUV’s dome light.

Stickers of yellow medical tape still clung to the flat head of the key, smeared with bright sky-blue wax crayon—the exact shade from the sixty-four-pack box Lily kept in her desk upstairs at the house.

“Preston wasn't carrying the orchids when they walked out of the house today, Claire,” Dad said, thinking it through piece by piece like the investigator he was. “Remember what Eleanor told us? The florist delivered the flowers, or they stopped by the hospital lobby shop. Wait—no. Look at the yellow medical tape.”

“We have a roll of that exact yellow surgical tape in the hall bathroom cabinet at home from when Preston sprained his wrist playing tennis last month,” I said immediately. “And Lily was in the upstairs hallway before I fell!”

“Wait,” Jonathan said from the driver’s seat, glancing into the rearview mirror. “If Lily taped that key to the inside of the vase or into the foam—why would Lily have a safe-deposit key?”

My mind flashed back to Tuesday afternoon.

Wait. Not Tuesday. Thursday evening—last night!

“Preston’s cufflinks box!” I gasped, sitting forward until the seatbelt locked against my good shoulder. “Last night after dinner, Preston was packing an overnight bag in his dressing room for a business golf trip next week. Lily was sitting on the floor of his closet playing with his wooden valet box because she likes sorting his collar stays and old coins. Preston yelled at her—Wait! It was the only time I have ever heard Preston raise his voice at Lily!”

Dad’s eyes locked onto mine. “What did he say to her?”

“He snatched a little green velvet pouch out of her hands and told her never to touch the bottom drawer of his valet box again,” I said, the memory sharpening with every second. “Lily cried and ran into her bedroom. Ten minutes later, Preston came into our room with a bouquet of white orchids in that glass vase—he said his secretary bought them for our anniversary next week, and he set them on the dresser in the upstairs hallway!”

“And Lily, being seven years old and angry at her father for yelling at her,” Dad said, a trace of awe in his voice, “went back into his closet this morning before school, took the shiny brass key out of the green pouch to get even, colored on it, and hid it inside the flower vase on the hall dresser—right next to Eleanor’s listening bug that Eleanor had planted in the flowers to spy on your upstairs phone calls!”

I pressed my hands to my face, half laughing and half sobbing at the sheer, accidental brilliance of my seven-year-old daughter.

Eleanor had planted a bug in the hallway orchids to listen to me talking on the upstairs landline. Lily had hidden her dad’s forbidden brass key inside the exact same flower foam that morning. And when Preston grabbed the vase off the hall dresser on his way to the hospital so he wouldn't have to buy new flowers, he had unwittingly carried both his mother’s microphone and his own secret key straight into my hospital room!

“Where is box 409?” I asked, looking at the brass key in Dad’s hand.

Dad turned the key over. Stamped along the narrow neck in tiny block letters were the initials F.M.B.

“Farmers & Merchants Bank in Staunton,” Jonathan said instantly. “Just across the mountain from Charlottesville. They close at six on Fridays.”

I checked the dashboard clock. It was 5:18 PM.

“Can you even open a safe-deposit box without being on the signature card, Dad?” I asked as Jonathan pressed the accelerator, the SUV surging up the mountain pass toward Afton.

“Normally, no,” Dad said, reaching into his inside jacket pocket and pulling out a worn black leather wallet that wasn't his everyday billfold. Inside was a gold-plated federal retiree credential and a sealed warrant subpoena signed by a magistrate judge in the Western District of Virginia. “Fortunately, my old deputy director still runs the financial crimes task force in Roanoke, and Dr. Richard Whitcomb’s ten-year-old fugitive warrant was never closed.”

At 5:51 PM, nine minutes before closing, we pulled up in front of the red-brick Farmers & Merchants Bank in downtown Staunton.

While I waited in the running SUV with the doors locked, watching the street through the tinted glass, Dad and Jonathan walked inside.

Twelve minutes later, the side security door of the bank opened. Dad and Jonathan walked out rapidly, Dad carrying a long, flat tin archival envelope under his brown cardigan.

He climbed into the passenger seat, shut the door, and turned to look at me. His face was paler than I had ever seen it in my life.

May you like

“What was in box 409, Dad?” I asked, my voice trembling. “Was it the money from Richard’s clinic?”

“No, sweetheart,” Dad said, his voice shaking slightly as he laid the tin envelope on the console between us. “Box 409 wasn't opened by Preston. It was opened twelve years ago by Eleanor’s late husband, Judge Charles Whitcomb—two weeks before your mother died at UVA Hospital. And inside it are your mother’s original hospital oncology charts.”

Related Stories

Other posts