Chapter 3 - The Hidden Appraisals

The study smelled faintly of Derek’s expensive new cologne, a scent Ana now associated entirely with betrayal. She moved methodically, ignoring the boxes she was supposed to be packing, and went straight to the heavy mahogany filing cabinet in the corner.
It was locked.
Ana wasn't surprised. Derek had always been fiercely protective of his "business documents." But after twenty-two years of marriage, Ana knew his habits better than he knew himself.
She walked over to the large potted fern near the window, digging her fingers into the dry soil near the rim of the ceramic pot. Her fingers brushed against cold metal. She pulled out a small, silver key.
She unlocked the filing cabinet and pulled open the top drawer.
It was stuffed with disorganized folders—invoices, bank statements, old tax returns. She bypassed them, moving to the second drawer labeled Properties.
She pulled out a thick manila folder marked Cedar Hollow Farm.
Her hands shook slightly as she opened it.
Inside were three recent property appraisals. The farm sat on forty acres of prime real estate just outside the city limits. It had been in the Carter family for three generations.
The most recent appraisal, dated just two weeks ago, valued the property at 1.2 million dollars.
Attached to the appraisal was a signed contract with a commercial developer.
Ana read the fine print, her eyes widening in horror. Derek wasn't just selling the farmhouse to another family. He was selling the land to a corporate developer who planned to bulldoze the century-old home and build a strip mall.
He was destroying his family's legacy for a quick payout to impress a twenty-eight-year-old marketing assistant.
But as Ana flipped to the second page of the contract, something caught her eye.
The signature line for the seller required two signatures.
Derek Thomas Carter (Agent for Ruth Evelyn Carter)
And below it, a second line that made Ana’s blood run cold.
Signature of Co-Owner / Trustee.
The line was blank.
Ana frowned, her mind racing. Why did the developer require a co-owner's signature? Derek was an only child. When his father died, the deed should have passed entirely to Ruth. If Derek held power of attorney, he could sign for his mother. But who was the co-owner?
She dug deeper into the folder, pulling out a yellowed, fragile document. The original deed to the Cedar Hollow Farm, dated 1982.
She scanned the names.
Ruth Evelyn Carter.
And...
Ana gasped.
The second name on the deed wasn't Derek's father. It was a name Ana had only heard whispered in hushed, disapproving tones at family gatherings decades ago.
Elias Carter.
Derek’s uncle. The black sheep of the family who had supposedly run off to California in the late eighties after a bitter dispute with Derek's father over the farm's finances. He had never been heard from again.
But according to this deed, Elias Carter still owned half the farm.
Derek couldn't legally sell the property to the developer without Elias's signature.
Suddenly, heavy footsteps echoed in the hallway.
"Ana? You almost done in there?" Derek called out, his voice laced with impatience.
Ana quickly shoved the deed, the appraisals, and the developer contract into her purse. She slammed the filing cabinet shut, locked it, and tossed the key back into the fern just as the study door swung open.
Derek stood in the doorway, checking his watch. "Brooke just texted. She’s ten minutes away. You need to clear out."
Ana picked up a small, inconsequential box of old paperback books she had placed on the desk earlier.
"I'm leaving," Ana said, her voice perfectly calm.
She walked past him, the heavy purse swinging against her hip. She felt a dangerous, thrilling surge of adrenaline. Derek thought he held all the cards. He thought she was just the discarded, traded-in model.
He had no idea she had just walked away with the blueprint to his destruction.
As Ana loaded the box into the trunk of her car, a sleek, silver Mercedes pulled into the driveway.
A young woman stepped out. She had perfectly highlighted blonde hair, oversized designer sunglasses, and a yoga outfit that cost more than Ana’s weekly grocery budget.
Brooke.
Brooke didn't look embarrassed to see the woman whose life she had demolished. She actually offered a small, pitying smile.
"Hi, Ana," Brooke said, her voice dripping with artificial sweetness. "Do you need help with those boxes? Derek said you have a bad back."
Ana stopped. She closed her trunk slowly and turned to face the young woman.
"My back is fine, Brooke," Ana said, her voice cool and level. "And I don't need your help."
Brooke’s fake smile faltered slightly. She clearly expected Ana to cry, or scream, or flee in humiliation.
"We're just trying to be civil," Brooke said defensively, crossing her arms. "Derek and I want to move forward peacefully."
"Peacefully?" Ana asked, taking a step toward her. "You broke into a twenty-two-year marriage, slept in my bed while I was at work, and you expect peace?"
Brooke flushed, looking toward the house for Derek. "Your marriage was over long before I came along, Ana. Derek said you two haven't been happy in years."
"Derek says a lot of things," Ana replied softly. "He told me he was working late. He told his mother she was just going to assisted living temporarily. I wonder what he's telling you?"
Brooke’s eyes narrowed. "What do you mean?"
Ana smiled, a genuine, chilling expression. "Just remember, Brooke. A wife is like a car. You keep one too long, and eventually, you're just pouring money into something old. His words, not mine."
Brooke’s jaw dropped. The insult landed exactly as intended.
Before Brooke could formulate a response, Ana got into her car and drove away, leaving the younger woman staring after her in shocked silence.
As she drove toward Melissa’s house, Ana pulled out her phone and dialed a number she hadn't called since her daughter Emily started college.
May you like
"Hello?" a gruff, professional voice answered.
"Mr. Sterling," Ana said, gripping the steering wheel. "It’s Ana Carter. I need a private investigator. And I need to find a ghost."