Chapter 5 - THE SECOND LILY VANCE

For two seconds, I couldn't make a sound.
Arthur Pendelton—the quiet, white-haired man who had given Lily a wooden rocking horse for her third birthday and sent us a Christmas ham every December—was blinking frantically up at me from the cargo floor of David’s BMW, his hands zip-tied behind his back and a strip of silver duct tape across his mouth.
I lunged forward, careful not to touch the exterior paint of the SUV, and peeled the edge of the duct tape off Arthur’s mouth.
“Sarah!” Arthur gasped, his voice hoarse and raw, his glasses crooked on his bruised nose. “Get out of here! They’re just around the corner at the dock dumpsters dumping the rest of the hard drives! If she sees your sister’s car—”
“Wait—if she sees my sister’s car?” I repeated, pulling a small pair of folding scissors from my purse medical kit and sawing furiously through the heavy plastic zip-tie cutting into Arthur’s wrists. “Who is 'she'? Julianne Mercer just threw the key to this locker out the window of her car by my house twenty minutes ago!”
“Not Julianne!” Arthur choked out, rubbing his bleeding wrists as I helped him sit up on the tailgate of the BMW. “Julianne wasn't David’s mistress, Sarah—Julianne is a private licensed bail recovery and fraud investigator I hired six months ago to go undercover at David’s gym!”
The concrete floor beneath my sneakers seemed to tilt sideways.
“You hired Julianne?” I whispered, staring at him in utter shock.
“Six months ago, our firm’s internal audit flagged four million dollars missing from the St. Jude Children’s Medical Foundation endowment that David manages,” Arthur said rapidly, swinging his stiff legs off the bumper as I called Rebecca on my phone and hissed at her to pull the car up to the back gate immediately. “Someone at the firm had been creating phantom pediatric catastrophic-grant patients—children who supposedly died of rare cardiac and anaphylactic complications—and paying out massive foundation grants and corporate re-insurance claims into offshore accounts!”
I looked down at the blood-stained pediatric hospital ID bracelet taped to Arthur’s shirt—the one reading LILY M. VANCE — DOB 10/14/2018—and then at the Baltimore cardiology chart on the folding table.
“There’s another Lily Vance?” I breathed.
“No!” Arthur said, gripping my shoulder with trembling hands as we hurried out the side door of the storage unit toward the rear alley where Rebecca was pulling up in the Subaru. “Five years ago, before you and David moved to Richmond from Maryland, David created a paper twin inside the foundation’s insurance registry using your daughter’s real Social Security number, backdating her birth year by seven months so the automated mortality cross-checks wouldn't flag your living daughter’s school records! On paper, 'Lily M. Vance, born 2018' has been receiving four hundred thousand dollars a year in blind cardiac research disbursements since 2021!”
My mind reeled as Rebecca threw open the back doors of the Subaru and Arthur and I scrambled inside, ducking below the window line as Rebecca gunned the engine out the service exit onto Dock Street.
“Wait a minute,” I said, my chest heaving as Rebecca merged into the heavy morning traffic heading back toward the hospital. “If David was stealing from the medical foundation using a fake paper version of Lily, why did he poison our real seven-year-old daughter last night?”
Arthur pulled the blood-stained hospital bracelet and the ticking RSA banking token off his coat and held them in his shaking palm.
“Because on Wednesday morning, I told David that the federal charity auditors were arriving this coming Monday to do a physical, in-person verification of every living grant recipient on the Virginia ledger—and that if a recipient had died during the fiscal year, the file closed automatically without an in-person audit upon submission of a certified hospital ICU death certificate!”
I clapped my hand over my mouth, a wave of nausea so violent hitting me that I nearly blacked out right there on the backseat floor.
David hadn't poisoned Lily for a new insurance payout.
He had poisoned our real, living seven-year-old daughter so that when she died in the pediatric ICU at St. Mary’s Hospital this morning, he could take her official hospital death certificate—bearing her real Social Security number—submit it to the federal charity auditors on Monday morning, and permanently bury the four-million-dollar paper fraud before the auditors came to our house to examine a little girl who didn't have a heart defect!
Wait.
“Wait a second!” I cried, grabbing Arthur’s sleeve as a huge contradiction suddenly jumped out at me. “If David wanted Lily to die in the ICU last night so he could get her death certificate—why did Dr. Chen find out that our EpiPens were filled with saline, yet the Baltimore chart on that table said epinephrine would rupture her heart? Wait—if you inject a child in anaphylactic shock with saline instead of epinephrine, she dies in the kitchen before she ever gets to the hospital! Wait—no! Why didn't she die in the kitchen last night?”
Arthur stared at me, his bruised eyes widening behind his crooked glasses.
“What did you just say, Sarah?” Arthur asked slowly. “You used an EpiPen filled with saline last night and Lily didn't die on the way to the hospital?”
“Wait,” I breathed, pulling the plastic yellow carrier tube out of my canvas tote bag—Wait. No, Dr. Chen had kept the tampered yellow carrier tube at the hospital for the police!
I looked inside my canvas tote bag again.
Down at the very bottom of my bag, beneath my wallet and Lily’s purple hairbrush, was a second yellow plastic EpiPen carrier tube—the one that had been in Lily’s school backpack!
Wait. Last night at nine-fifteen, when Lily started gasping for air in the kitchen, I had grabbed the yellow tube from the kitchen drawer and swept her school backpack tube into my purse on the way out the door! In the dark hallway by the front door, when Lily collapsed on the rug, I hadn't used the injector from the kitchen drawer first—I had pulled the injector out of the front pocket of her school backpack, injected her thigh, and then dropped the used pen into the kitchen drawer tube in my panic!
Someone had replaced the EpiPens in our kitchen drawer with saline so Lily would die at home.
Or wait—had someone replaced the toxic, spiked injectors in our kitchen drawer with harmless saline so I wouldn't accidentally inject Lily with lethal potassium or high-dose adrenaline before she got to the hospital?!
“Arthur,” I demanded, my voice shaking, “you said earlier when I took the tape off your mouth: 'If she sees your sister’s car.' Who locked you in the trunk of David’s BMW at six-fifty-two this morning, and who is dumping hard drives at the dock right now?”
Arthur looked from me to Rebecca in the front seat, his face gray as ash.
“David didn't lock me in that trunk, Sarah,” Arthur said quietly. “David has been unconscious in the sub-basement of our accounting firm since nine o'clock last night—right after your husband’s real accomplice hit us both with a stun gun and took David’s phone and your house keys.”
My heart stopped dead in my chest.
“Who?” I whispered.
Arthur held up the blood-stained hospital ID bracelet from the storage locker—and flipped it over to show a tiny, engraved silver charm clipped to the plastic band.
May you like
It was a miniature silver scalpel charm from the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine Class of 2012.
“Dr. Elena Vance,” Arthur whispered. “David’s first wife—the pediatric anesthesiologist he told you died in a car crash in Baltimore eight years ago.”