Chapter 5 - THE TWIN WHO WAS AFRAID TO GET BETTER

"Julian had been making Elise feel responsible for what happened to Clara?"
I stared at Anna.
She nodded.
"That's what Margaret suspected."
"Did you actually hear him say anything like that?"
"No. I was dismissed the morning after the incident."
She looked uncomfortable.
"I don't want to accuse someone of something I can't prove."
That restraint made her more believable.
She could have told me anything.
I was frightened, angry, and desperate to find someone responsible for my daughters' suffering.
But Anna refused to turn suspicion into certainty.
"Why did Margaret think it?" I asked.
"Because Elise changed whenever Julian came near her."
I remembered those visits.
Julian brought the girls gifts every Christmas.
He always asked about their therapy.
He was the man who organized appointments, arranged medical transportation, and handled countless practical details while I worked.
I'd interpreted his involvement as kindness.
Now I found myself wondering what my daughters experienced when I wasn't present.
Anna continued.
"Margaret said Elise sometimes became upset after Julian spoke to her alone. She started keeping notes because she didn't understand why."
"Where are those notes?"
"I don't know. Margaret was afraid someone would throw them away."
I looked at the photograph resting on Anna's blanket.
For nearly thirty years, Margaret had been one of the people who knew our family best.
Yet she'd died carrying concerns I hadn't understood.
I thanked Anna and arranged for the hospital social worker to help her and Sofie develop a safe discharge plan.
I offered to assist with necessary expenses through the appropriate channels.
Anna looked wary.
"I don't want to owe you anything, Mr. Vance."
"You won't."
"Money has a way of becoming a leash when the person giving it owns everything."
I felt the words land.
She had good reason to be cautious.
"Then let the social worker coordinate it," I said. "You can decide what help you accept."
She studied me.
Finally, she nodded.
"Thank you."
Before leaving, I asked one more question.
"Anna, did Margaret ever tell you exactly what happened to the girls' mother?"
She looked surprised.
"Mrs. Vance?"
"Grace."
Anna shook her head.
"Only that the girls missed her terribly."
I looked down.
I'd asked because I was beginning to realize how much of my daughters' grief I'd left for other people to manage.
Grace died in a traffic accident three years earlier.
I'd thrown myself into work afterward.
Margaret stayed.
Anna came later.
And when the girls stopped walking, I tried to repair their bodies because I couldn't bear confronting how much else they'd lost.
When I returned home, Elise was in the library.
She was arranging small animal figurines on a low table.
Clara sat near the window, working on a puzzle.
Neither looked up immediately.
I sat between them.
"Girls, can we talk?"
Clara glanced at me.
"About Sofie?"
"Partly."
Elise moved a wooden horse.
"Did she go home?"
"She's being looked after. Her mother's in the hospital."
Clara frowned.
"Is her mommy going to die?"
"No, sweetheart. She's getting treatment, and we're hoping she'll recover."
Clara nodded.
Then she looked at her sister.
"Elise, tell Daddy."
Elise froze.
"Tell me what?" I asked.
"Nothing."
Clara's expression hardened.
"You promised."
Elise stared at her.
"I didn't promise."
"Yes, you did."
I raised one hand.
"Girls. Nobody's in trouble."
Elise looked down.
"That's what grown-ups say."
The sentence hurt.
I leaned forward.
"You're right to want proof. I've asked questions before and gotten upset when I didn't like the answers."
Neither daughter disagreed.
That was another painful moment.
I looked at Elise.
"I'm going to work on that. But right now, I want to understand what you've been carrying."
She slowly moved the wooden horse away from the other animals.
Then whispered, "Clara moved her feet."
"Yes."
"I didn't."
I felt my chest tighten.
"That doesn't mean you did anything wrong."
She shrugged.
"You were happy."
I looked at her.
"Elise—"
"You smiled when Clara moved."
Her voice cracked.
"You never smile like that anymore."
I couldn't speak.
She pushed the wooden horse off the table.
It landed on the carpet.
"Everybody looked at Clara."
I moved closer.
"Sweetheart, I love you just as much as I love your sister."
"I know."
But she didn't sound convinced.
Clara reached toward her.
"Elise, I didn't mean—"
"Stop."
Elise turned her wheelchair away.
I had spent two years desperately trying to help both girls walk.
Yet somehow, I'd allowed the possibility of recovery to become a competition neither child had chosen.
I knelt beside Elise.
"I was happy because Clara felt something new. But you don't have to move your legs to make me proud."
Her eyes filled.
"Really?"
"Really."
She studied my face.
"Even if I never walk?"
The question was almost unbearable.
I took her hand.
"Even then."
She began crying.
Not loudly.
Just silent tears sliding down her cheeks.
I held her until she was ready to let go.
Then I asked about the day in the sunroom.
Elise became still.
"Do you remember it?" I asked.
She nodded.
"Do you want to tell me?"
She looked toward Clara.
Then whispered, "I pushed the button."
I felt cold.
"What button?"
"The yellow one."
Clara stopped working on her puzzle.
"Elise, that's not why—"
Elise covered her ears.
"Stop!"
I waited.
She lowered her hands.
"Julian said I shouldn't have touched it."
I took a careful breath.
"What happened after you pushed it?"
"The lights were already off. I wanted the doors to open."
I felt something shift.
She hadn't caused the power failure.
She'd been trying to escape.
"Did the doors open?"
She shook her head.
"Then what?"
She looked frightened.
"Somebody got mad."
"Who?"
Elise glanced toward the library door.
Then whispered, "Julian."
I held her hand.
"What did he say?"
She stared at the carpet.
"He said I made everything worse."
Clara's eyes filled.
"That's not true."
Elise shook her head.
"Then why couldn't we walk?"
Neither of us answered immediately.
I looked at my daughters.
Two little girls who had been frightened during an accident, separated from people they trusted, and subjected to years of uncertainty.
And one had spent all that time believing she caused it.
I felt sick.
"Elise," I said gently, "you didn't cause this by trying to open a door."
Her lips trembled.
"Julian said the button was bad."
"Then the adults should have made sure it couldn't hurt anyone."
She looked at me.
For the first time, I saw a little hope in her expression.
Then Clara spoke.
"Dad, there's something in the music box."
I turned.
"What?"
"The song isn't the only thing."
She swallowed.
"Margaret told me to keep the little paper safe."
I felt my heart pound.
"What paper?"
Clara looked toward the hallway.
May you like
Then whispered:
"The one with the picture of the man who locked us inside."
Related Stories