Plot twist

Chapter 10 - THE ENVELOPE FROM PRISON

Two years passed, quiet and peaceful.

The bakery was thriving. Grace had started dating a kind local school teacher. Ellie was touring colleges. Vincent stopped by every Sunday for a fresh espresso.

It was a rainy Tuesday afternoon when the peace broke.

I was wiping down the tables near the front window when the mail carrier dropped a stack of letters on the counter.

I sorted through them. Bills, vendor invoices, a magazine for Grace.

And then, at the bottom of the stack, I saw it.

A thick, manila envelope addressed to Evelyn Turner.

The return address was State Penitentiary, Maximum Security Wing.

Connor Hale.

My blood ran cold. I stared at the stamped letters, a wave of nausea washing over me. Connor had been locked away for life. He hadn't contacted anyone in two years. Why was he writing to Evelyn now?

Grace walked out from the back office, holding a mug of tea.

"Everything okay, Ashley? You look like you've seen a ghost."

I quickly slid a newspaper over the envelope, hiding it. "Yes! Just... a big flour bill. Nothing to worry about."

I didn't want to ruin Grace's peace. I had to show this to Vincent first.

That evening, after closing the shop, I drove straight to the Caruso estate. The guards recognized me and let me through the gates immediately.

Vincent was in his study, reading. He looked up, surprised to see me.

"Ashley? What's wrong?"

I walked to his desk and placed the prison envelope in front of him.

Vincent’s jaw tightened instantly. The relaxed man from the bakery vanished, replaced by the dangerous mob boss.

"He sent this to the bakery?" Vincent asked quietly.

"Addressed to Evelyn," I confirmed. "I couldn't let Grace see it. Not after everything she's overcome."

Vincent grabbed a silver letter opener and sliced the envelope open.

He tipped it upside down.

A single, folded piece of paper fell onto the mahogany desk.

Along with a small, tarnished silver ring.

Vincent stared at the ring. The color completely drained from his face.

"Mr. Caruso?" I whispered. "What is it?"

Vincent carefully unfolded the letter. It was written in Connor's frantic handwriting.

Vincent,

You thought you won. You thought locking me in here was the end. But you didn't know David's biggest secret. I found this ring in David's safety deposit box before I gave you the key. Ask Evelyn who this ring belongs to. Ask her what really happened to her second child.

I gasped. "Second child? Evelyn only had Grace!"

Vincent picked up the tarnished silver ring. Engraved on the inside band was a tiny inscription: R.T. to E.T. 1978.

Robert Turner to Evelyn Turner.

May you like

"This is Evelyn's wedding band," Vincent realized. "She lost it thirty years ago."

Why did David have it? And what did Connor mean about a second child?

Related Stories

Other posts