Chapter 2 - The Broken Rhythm

The silence in the ballroom was absolute. Fifty-eight wealthy guests stared at Stefano Montello. The mafia boss, usually a portrait of terrifying composure, looked genuinely shocked.
“My father?” Stefano repeated, his voice dropping to a dangerous rumble. He stepped closer to Everett Sloan. “My father died thirty years ago. Why would he care about a ballroom competition in New York?”
Everett swallowed hard, adjusting his white dinner jacket with a trembling hand. The arrogant judge who had mocked us minutes earlier was suddenly sweating profusely under the gaze of Chicago’s most powerful man.
“It wasn't about the competition, Stefano,” Everett stammered, his eyes darting toward the exits. “It was about her partner. David.”
Rosalind gasped. She dropped the silver trophy.
It hit the marble floor with a sharp, ringing clang, rolling a few feet before stopping against my sensible black work shoes.
“David?” Rosalind whispered, her hands flying to her mouth. Forty-six years of buried grief flooded her eyes. “David loved me. He was going to ask me to marry him after the finals.”
“David was a thief, Rosalind,” Everett said coldly, regaining a fraction of his cruel composure. “He wasn't a professional dancer. He was a grifter. And he stole something very valuable from the Montello family syndicate. He used the dance circuit as a cover to move across state lines.”
I felt physically sick. The romantic tragedy Rosalind had carried her entire life—the missed step, the accidental fall—was a lie. It was a calculated hit.
“You’re saying my father ordered you to stop a dance competition just to catch a thief?” Stefano demanded, clearly not buying it. “My father would have just sent men to break his legs.”
“He did send men,” Everett replied. “But David was smart. He never left Rosalind’s side in public. He knew as long as he was under the spotlights, the mob wouldn't touch him. The only way to isolate him was to ensure he lost the championship. No trophy, no press tour. No press tour, he loses his protection.”
Everett looked directly at Rosalind. The cruelty in his eyes was breathtaking.
“I was the head judge,” Everett said. “Stefano’s father paid me ten thousand dollars to guarantee you didn't win. I went to David before the final dance. I told him I knew who he was hiding from. I told him if he didn't drop you on that floor and walk away, the Montello family would kill you both right there in the ballroom.”
Rosalind swayed. I caught her arm, my own anger boiling over.
“You ruined her life for money!” I yelled at Everett.
“I saved her life!” Everett shot back. “If David hadn't dropped her, Stefano’s father would have put a bullet in her head to get to him! David made his choice. He let her fall, he walked out the back door, and he disappeared.”
Rosalind’s breathing became shallow and ragged. She wasn't looking at Everett anymore. She was staring at her own hands, the hands that had clung to David’s jacket as she fell to the hardwood floor forty-six years ago.
“He didn't disappear,” Rosalind whispered, her voice cracking.
Everett frowned. “What?”
“David didn't run away,” Rosalind said, lifting her tear-streaked face. Her eyes were burning with a sudden, terrifying clarity. She reached to the clasp of her silver necklace, pulling out a small, tarnished brass key she always wore hidden beneath her collar.
“Two days before the competition, David gave me this key,” Rosalind said, holding it up. “He told me it was the key to our future. He said if anything ever happened to him, I was to go to the main terminal at Grand Central Station and open locker 402.”
Stefano’s eyes widened. “Did you open it?”
“No,” Rosalind wept. “When he dropped me, when my knee shattered... I thought he had just abandoned me because I wasn't good enough. I was too ashamed. I came back to Chicago and never looked at the key again.”
“Where is the key now?” Stefano demanded, stepping forward, his mob boss instincts entirely ignited.
“I’m holding it,” Rosalind said.
Suddenly, a loud, sharp crash echoed from the back of the ballroom.
Everyone spun around.
The heavy oak doors of the mansion had burst open. Standing in the entryway, flanked by four heavily armed men in dark suits, was a man in his early fifties. He wore a tailored grey suit and a smile that didn't reach his cold, dead eyes.
Stefano instantly drew a weapon from his tuxedo jacket, stepping in front of Rosalind and me.
“Julian,” Stefano growled.
Julian Vance. The head of the rival Chicago syndicate. A man who had been fighting a bloody, quiet war with the Montellos for five years.
“Put the gun away, Stefano,” Julian sneered, walking slowly into the room. His men raised assault rifles, aiming directly at the crowd. The wealthy guests screamed, dropping to the floor.
“You’re trespassing in my home,” Stefano warned.
“I’m not here for you,” Julian said smoothly. He didn't look at the mafia boss. He looked directly at the seventy-four-year-old dance instructor holding the tarnished brass key.
“Hello, Aunt Rosalind,” Julian smiled.
Rosalind gasped, stepping backward. “Julian?”
I stared at her, completely bewildered. “Aunt?”
“It’s a small world, Piper,” Julian laughed coldly. “My father was David. The man who dropped her.”
May you like
Julian held out his hand.
“And I’ve spent twenty years looking for the key he stole from the Montellos before they murdered him.”