Chapter 3 - The Key in the Chocolate Box

The entire ballroom seemed to hold its breath. Fifty-two pairs of eyes shifted from Anthony to me. I stood frozen in my maid's uniform, my hands gripping the edge of the silver serving cart so tightly my knuckles were white.
"You gave it to Claire?" Luca asked, his voice a mixture of shock and quiet fury. "You involved a civilian?"
"I had to!" Anthony cried, desperation coloring his voice. "She's invisible to them, Luca! They monitor my bank accounts, my phone calls, my family. But a maid who brings me coffee? They never looked twice at her. Last week, when I bought Margaret’s chocolates, I bought an extra box for the staff kitchen. I slipped the key inside."
My mind raced. Last Friday. Anthony had handed me a small, gold-wrapped box of artisan truffles, thanking me for making his espresso just right. I hadn't eaten them. They were sitting on my small kitchen counter in my studio apartment, waiting for a special occasion.
"Claire," Luca said, stepping toward me. The terrifying mafia boss vanished for a second, replaced by a man desperate to save a woman he viewed as a mother. "Is the box still at your apartment?"
"Yes," I breathed, my heart hammering against my ribs. "I haven't opened it."
Luca turned to Marco. "Get a team. We are going to Claire’s apartment. And then we are getting Margaret."
"Luca, wait!" Vincent interrupted, standing up again. "If you go in guns blazing, they will execute Margaret. The Syndicate isn't a street gang. They are professionals. They have men watching Anthony’s house. If they see you pull up, she dies."
"Then what do you suggest, Vincent?" Luca snarled, closing the distance between them. "I sit here and wait for them to mail me her wedding ring?"
"You negotiate," Vincent said smoothly, though sweat beaded on his forehead. "You send Anthony in alone. He gives them the combination from the watch. They let Margaret go. And then you deal with the fallout."
"They won't let her go without the key," Anthony wept. "And I won't let them have the ledger. It will destroy Luca."
"Then we give them a fake key," Luca decided instantly. He looked at me. "Claire, we need to get to your apartment before they realize Anthony used you as a courier."
"It’s too late," a cold, unfamiliar voice echoed from the back of the ballroom.
Everyone turned.
Standing near the service doors, flanked by two of Luca’s unconscious guards, was a man in a dark trench coat. He held a suppressed pistol aimed casually at the ceiling.
"You should really improve your perimeter security, Luca," the man smiled. "The caterers let us right through the kitchen."
Panic erupted again. Guests screamed, diving under tables. Luca immediately stepped in front of me and Anthony, shielding us with his massive frame. Marco drew his weapon, but three more armed men stepped out from the shadows of the balcony above. We were surrounded.
"Who are you?" Luca demanded, his voice dangerously calm.
"I’m the man who is going to collect Anthony’s insurance policy," the man said, walking slowly down the marble stairs. "And as for the maid’s apartment... my men are already tossing it. They found the chocolates."
My blood ran completely cold.
The man smiled, holding up a small, familiar gold box. He tossed it onto the head table.
"But unfortunately for Anthony," the man sneered, "the key wasn't inside."
He opened the box, revealing six perfectly untouched chocolate truffles. No brass key. No hidden compartment. Nothing.
Anthony gasped, staring at the box. "That’s impossible. I put it in there myself."
The man aimed his gun directly at Anthony’s chest. "You have five seconds to tell me where the real key is, old man, or I send your wife’s head in a box."
"Wait!" I screamed, stepping out from behind Luca.
The man paused, amused. "The maid speaks again."
"He didn't lie," I said, my voice shaking so badly I could barely form the words. "He put the key in a box of chocolates. But he didn't give it to me."
Anthony looked at me, confused. "Claire, I handed it to you."
"You handed me a gold box," I whispered, tears pricking my eyes. "But earlier that night... you brought Margaret a red box. You mixed them up, Mr. DeLuca. The key isn't in my apartment."
May you like
I looked at the man with the gun.
"The key is in Margaret’s hands."