Plot twist

Chapter 5 - The Rusted Safety Deposit Key

The police arrived in force, but Martin was long gone.

Paramedics bandaged Luca’s arm in the back of an ambulance while officers took our statements. Walter and Diane sat wrapped in silver thermal blankets, holding Toby between them. The little boy had fallen asleep against his grandfather's chest, the plastic-wrapped notebook safely secured in Luca's possession.

I stood by the ambulance doors, shivering in my damp uniform.

Luca walked over to me, his left arm in a thick white sling. He looked exhausted, the weight of the last hour adding ten years to his face.

"My lawyers are handling the police," Luca said quietly. "I told them Martin tried to extort the company and threatened my guests. I left out the part about my sister and the notebook. For now."

"Why?" I asked, confused. "That notebook proves he killed her."

Luca pulled the plastic-wrapped notebook from his coat pocket. He peeled back the plastic. The leather cover was brittle and cracked.

"Because I need to know what's in it before the FBI takes it as evidence," Luca said softly. "Elena didn't just die because she found missing money, Jenna. Martin is ruthless, but he doesn't kill Morettis over cash. He kills to protect his own survival. There's a secret in this book. And we need to find it before he finds us."

He looked at Walter and Diane. "I'm putting them in a secure hotel tonight with my personal security detail. Martin burned their house down. They have nothing left."

My heart broke for them. Fifty-four years of memories, turned to ash in an hour.

"What about me?" I asked, wrapping my arms around myself.

"You're coming with me," Luca said. "Martin saw you hit him with that cart. He saw you take the padlock. You aren't safe in your apartment."

An hour later, we were sitting in the penthouse suite of Luca's downtown hotel. The city sparkled below us through the floor-to-ceiling windows, oblivious to the nightmare we were living.

Luca sat at the massive oak dining table. I sat across from him with a cup of hot tea.

He opened the brittle leather notebook.

The pages were filled with delicate, looping handwriting. Elena's handwriting.

Luca read in silence for ten minutes. His jaw tightened. The muscles in his neck flexed.

Finally, he looked up. His eyes were red.

"She knew," Luca whispered.

"Knew what?" I asked softly.

"Martin wasn't just embezzling," Luca said, turning the notebook so I could see the pages. "He was running a shadow operation out of our south warehouse. He was moving stolen pharmaceuticals. The kind of drugs that hit the streets and ruin neighborhoods. My father would have killed him if he found out."

I looked at the numbers. Millions of dollars. A massive, illegal empire built right under the Moretti family's nose.

"But look at this entry," Luca pointed to the final page, dated October 13th—the day before Elena died.

The handwriting was frantic, pressed hard into the paper.

Martin caught me in the office. He knows I have the ledger. He told me if I give it to Dad, he will kill Luca. I can't let my brother die. I'm going to hide the notebook in the basement at Walter's house. Walter is the only man I trust. But I took the insurance policy. Martin's safety deposit key. I hid it in the one place Martin will never look.

Luca stared at the page. "The insurance policy."

"A safety deposit key," I repeated. "If Martin kept physical evidence of his crimes, that's where it is."

"But where did she hide it?" Luca asked in frustration, rubbing his face. "She died the next night. 'The one place Martin will never look.' Where would a nineteen-year-old girl hide a key?"

I thought about Toby. The little boy who hid his most precious item inside his toy train set.

"People hide things in plain sight," I said. "They hide things in the items they use every day. Luca... what was Elena wearing the night she died?"

Luca frowned. "A coat. She was trying to leave. Walter said she was locked in the boiler room."

"Did Martin burn the coat?" I asked.

Luca’s eyes widened. "No. The police found her coat by the river three days later. Martin planted it there to make it look like she committed suicide or ran away. The police gave it back to my father. It's... it's in the mansion. In my father's old study. In a glass display case."

We didn't wait.

We drove back to the mansion in absolute silence. The guests were long gone. The police tape was up, but Luca bypassed it, leading me up the grand staircase to his late father's study.

The room smelled of old cigars and dust. In the corner sat a glass display case holding a beautiful, albeit faded, red wool peacoat.

Luca shattered the glass with his elbow.

He pulled the coat out. We tore through the pockets. Empty.

"Check the lining," I said, grabbing the hem of the coat.

I ran my fingers along the bottom seam. Halfway across the back, I felt a hard, small lump.

"Here!" I gasped.

Luca pulled a pocketknife from his belt and sliced the red wool.

A small, heavy object fell out and clattered onto the hardwood floor.

It was a rusted safety deposit key. Stamped on the metal was a number: 402. And beneath it, a logo.

Chicago Union Station.

"It's a locker key," Luca breathed, staring at it.

Before he could pick it up, a voice echoed from the doorway of the study.

"I'll take that," Martin Vale said.

I spun around.

Martin was standing in the doorway, soaked in rain, holding his gun. But he wasn't pointing it at us.

He was pointing it at a terrified young woman with bright pink hair, whose hands were bound with zip-ties.

May you like

It was my roommate, Chloe.

"I told you I wasn't done," Martin smiled, his teeth stained with blood. "Now, kick the key over here, or your little friend's brains are going to paint this beautiful mahogany floor."

Related Stories

Other posts