Chapter 5 - THE SISTER'S SACRIFICE

The air in the sports car evaporated. I felt like I had been plunged into freezing water, my lungs seizing in a violent panic.
"Lauren?" I gasped, shaking my head frantically. "No. No, Matthew, you don't even like Lauren. She hates you."
"She hates the version of me she sees," Matthew corrected smoothly, weaving the car through the heavy Chicago traffic. "But Lauren is smart. She’s stable. She doesn't ask the kind of annoying questions you do, Natalie. For the last six months, while you were crying in the bathroom over Chloe, I was quietly paying off Lauren’s student loans. I bought the building her apartment is in through a shell company. I was preparing to move her into my new life once I dissolved our marriage."
I stared at the man sitting next to me, realizing for the first time that the true depth of his sociopathy was utterly bottomless. He hadn't just betrayed our marriage; he had systematically planned to steal my sister to secure his own twisted fantasy of a stable family, while using her as a hostage for a mob boss.
"She would never go with you," I said, my voice trembling with raw, absolute fury.
"She won't have a choice," Matthew said coldly. "Vance’s men are picking her up right now. They are bringing her to the private airfield. I’m trading her safety for my seat on that jet."
"If you give her to Vance, he’ll kill her!" I screamed, lunging across the console, grabbing his arm.
Matthew didn't flinch. He simply raised the handgun from his lap and pressed the cold barrel hard against my ribs.
"Sit back, Natalie," he ordered, his voice dangerously calm. "Or I’ll leave you bleeding on the highway and handle Lauren myself."
I slowly retreated back into my seat, tears of sheer helplessness spilling down my cheeks. He had completely trapped me. If Teresa didn't reach Lauren in time, my sister was going to die for my husband’s crimes.
We sped toward the outskirts of the city, pulling into a desolate, industrial area near the abandoned railyards.
"Where are we going?" I choked out. "This isn't the airfield."
"We aren't going to the airfield," Matthew replied, checking his rearview mirror obsessively. "I’m not an idiot, Natalie. Vance thinks he’s getting Lauren as collateral, but I know Vance. The second I hand her over, he’ll shoot me to tie up loose ends. I’m not meeting him."
I frowned, confusion fighting through the terror. "Then why did you tell Vance you cared about Lauren?"
Matthew offered a dark, triumphant smile.
"Because I needed Vance to send his best men to her apartment," Matthew explained, pulling the car into a rusted, corrugated metal warehouse. "With his top enforcers busy trying to extract your sister, Vance is sitting at his downtown penthouse practically unguarded. He’s waiting for a delivery that is never going to arrive."
He parked the car in the dark, cavernous warehouse and killed the engine.
"I’m going to kill Arthur Vance tonight," Matthew said, stating the assassination as casually as ordering dinner. "Once he’s dead, the Syndicate structure collapses. The debt dies with him. And I walk away a free, very wealthy man."
He turned to me, the gun still aimed at my chest.
"But I need you to do exactly what I say, Natalie. Because you are going to be my alibi."
"I will never help you," I spat, wishing I had the strength to tear his eyes out.
"You will," Matthew promised, leaning closer. "Because if I don't kill Vance tonight, he will eventually find Lauren. And you know what his people do to loose ends."
He was right. As long as Arthur Vance was alive, my sister was marked for death. Matthew had forced me into a sickening alliance with the devil to save the only family I had left.
"What do you need me to do?" I whispered, conceding defeat.
Matthew nodded approvingly. "We’re going to the penthouse. You are going to use your hospital keycard to bypass the service elevator security. When we get to the top floor, you will knock on Vance’s door. He trusts you. He thinks you’re just a terrified wife looking for protection."
"And when he opens the door?"
"I’ll handle the rest," Matthew said coldly.
He shoved me out of the car, forcing me to walk in front of him. We left the warehouse and hailed a cab on the main street, blending into the evening crowd as we headed back downtown toward Vance’s luxury high-rise.
The rain had intensified, soaking my clothes, matching the cold, hollow dread inside me.
We arrived at the towering glass building. Matthew kept the gun concealed in his coat pocket, pressing it against my spine as he guided me toward the private service entrance at the back of the building.
I swiped my hospital ID card—a universal pass that granted medical personnel emergency access to residential buildings in the city. The heavy steel door clicked open.
We slipped inside, stepping into the service elevator.
Matthew pressed the button for the penthouse.
"Remember, Natalie," Matthew warned as the elevator rapidly ascended. "Smile. Be the panicked, compliant wife he expects. If you hesitate, I shoot him, I shoot you, and I take my chances with the stairs."
The elevator dinged softly, opening into a lavish, dimly lit hallway. Thick Persian carpets absorbed the sound of our footsteps.
We approached the massive, double oak doors at the end of the hall.
Matthew stepped back into the shadows, gesturing for me to move forward with the barrel of his gun.
I took a deep, shuddering breath, trying to summon every ounce of courage I had left. I stepped up to the door and knocked twice, my knuckles rapping weakly against the heavy wood.
A moment later, the door swung open.
Standing in the threshold wasn't Arthur Vance.
It was Chloe.
She was wearing a silk robe, holding a glass of expensive wine, looking completely at ease in the mob boss’s penthouse.
Her smug smile vanished the instant she saw me standing in the hallway.
"Natalie?" Chloe gasped, taking a step back in shock.
But before Chloe could close the door, Matthew stepped out of the shadows, shoving me forcefully into the apartment, pressing the gun directly to Chloe’s forehead.
"Hello, Chloe," Matthew sneered, his eyes filled with absolute venom. "I see you didn't pack your bags like I told you."
Chloe froze, her wine glass slipping from her hand, shattering on the marble floor.
"Matthew, wait," Chloe stammered, raising her hands defensively. "I can explain."
"Explain what?" Matthew laughed bitterly, pushing her deeper into the opulent living room. "Explain how you’ve been sleeping with Arthur Vance this whole time? Explain how you were the one reporting my every move back to him?"
I stared at the twenty-two-year-old girl in disbelief. She wasn't just a naive mistress. She was a spy for the Syndicate.
"He offered me more money!" Chloe cried, desperation leaking into her voice. "He promised me the whole empire once he got rid of you! I had to look out for myself!"
"Well," Matthew said coldly, cocking the hammer of his gun. "Let’s see if he’s willing to protect his investment."
He grabbed Chloe by the hair, dragging her toward the heavy double doors leading to Vance’s private study.
"Marcus!" Matthew roared, kicking the study doors open. "I brought your little pet back!"
We spilled into the study.
But the room was completely empty.
The massive mahogany desk was clear. The fireplace was cold. There was no sign of Arthur Vance.
Matthew frowned, scanning the room, his grip loosening slightly on Chloe’s hair.
"Where is he?" Matthew demanded, shoving Chloe to the floor.
Chloe looked up, a cruel, victorious smile suddenly breaking through her tears.
"He’s not here, Matthew," Chloe whispered, her eyes shining with malicious delight. "Because he didn't send his men to Lauren’s apartment tonight."
Matthew froze, his gun wavering. "What do you mean?"
May you like
Chloe laughed, a chilling, terrifying sound that echoed in the empty study.
"He didn't send his men to Lauren’s apartment, Matthew," Chloe repeated softly. "He went there himself. And he’s waiting for you to call."