Chapter 7 - WHY BEATRICE WANTED CAMILA TO LOOK CONFUSED

Beatrice admitted the funeral conversation.
Not immediately.
First she called Camila unreliable.
Then Vincent played the cassette.
Only the section with Beatrice’s own voice.
Not the gunshot.
Not the damaged ending.
Her face changed.
They met in the smaller dining room.
Carmine attended in person.
No soldiers.
Nora remained because Camila asked for her.
Beatrice hated that.
Good.
Vincent placed no weapon on the table.
Also good.
“What did you tell my mother?”
Beatrice stared at Camila.
“She remembers?”
“Enough.”
“That isn’t an answer.”
Beatrice looked at her husband.
Carmine said:
“Tell them.”
She laughed bitterly.
“Everyone keeps saying that.”
Then she looked at Nora.
“You think I’m a monster.”
Nora answered:
“I think what you did in the ballroom was monstrous.”
Not the same.
Beatrice absorbed the distinction.
Then:
“At Thomas’s funeral, Camila cornered me.”
Camila frowned.
Beatrice continued.
“She asked whether Julian killed him.”
“What did you say?”
“The truth.”
Her eyes filled.
“I said I didn’t know whose hand fired.”
Vincent’s jaw tightened.
“But?”
“I knew Julian went for Carmine’s gun.”
“And you tried to stop him.”
“Yes.”
“Did you touch the gun?”
“No.”
“Did Carmine?”
“Not after he put it down.”
“Thomas?”
“No.”
“Then Julian fired.”
Beatrice shook her head.
“I saw his hand reach.”
“Beatrice.”
“I looked at Thomas.”
Her voice cracked.
“He was telling me to leave Julian alone.”
Then the shot.
When she looked back, Julian was near the table.
The gun had fallen.
Thomas was bleeding.
Julian kept saying:
I didn’t mean—
Not:
I didn’t shoot.
I didn’t mean.
Strong.
Still not complete.
“Why didn’t you tell police?”
Beatrice laughed through tears.
“Because Carmine said if Vincent learned Julian killed Thomas, every Gallow boy in New York would be dead by sunrise.”
Vincent looked away.
Again, not wrong about his younger self.
Carmine said:
“I made the choice.”
“No,” Beatrice snapped.
“We all did.”
Good.
Responsibility shared without disappearing.
Then Vincent asked:
“Why humiliate my mother?”
The room went still.
This time Beatrice’s cruelty could not hide inside history.
She looked at Camila.
Then Nora.
Then the floor.
“Because I was afraid.”
Vincent’s voice sharpened.
“Of an eighty-year-old woman?”
“Yes.”
She surprised everyone.
Months earlier, Beatrice learned the new peace agreement included Pier Fourteen.
Her lawyers warned that unresolved historical claims could complicate transfer.
Then she heard Camila had begun talking about Thomas again.
About blue books.
About Julian.
“How?”
“The old nurse.”
Vincent became still.
“The nurse I fired?”
Beatrice nodded.
“She mentioned Camila’s episodes to one of my household staff.”
“Why would your staff be talking to my mother’s nurse?”
“Because I paid her.”
Nora swore softly.
Vincent’s expression turned lethal.
Beatrice continued quickly.
“Not to hurt Camila.”
“You paid my mother’s caregiver.”
“To tell me what she remembered.”
Carmine stared at his wife.
“You never told me that.”
“No.”
“Why?”
“Because you wanted the treaty.”
“So did you.”
“Yes.”
Beatrice’s hands trembled.
“I wanted to know whether Camila could reopen everything.”
Then the night of the gala.
Beatrice’s assistant paid the nurse ten thousand dollars to leave the east wing unattended for twenty minutes.
The plan?
Camila would wander downstairs.
Guests would see her confused.
Beatrice intended nothing more than to create witnesses that Camila’s memory was unreliable.
It was cruel.
Calculated.
But not yet the wine.
“The spill was an accident,” Beatrice whispered.
Nora stared.
“And everything after?”
Beatrice closed her eyes.
“No.”
She had seen the opportunity.
Camila asking for her dead husband.
Three hundred witnesses.
Beatrice’s own decade of fear and resentment.
So she humiliated her.
Called her senile.
Ordered her toward broken glass.
“Why?”
Beatrice’s face twisted.
“Because she had spent ten years knowing something that could destroy my brother’s memory.”
Vincent almost laughed.
“Your brother stole from widows and may have killed my father.”
“I know.”
“And you wanted his memory protected from my mother?”
Beatrice looked ashamed.
“Yes.”
There.
No justification.
Only ugliness.
Then Camila spoke.
“Julian was scared.”
Everyone turned.
She looked at Beatrice.
“You told me.”
Beatrice’s eyes filled.
“Yes.”
Camila continued:
“You said Thomas frightened him.”
“Yes.”
“You said you were sorry.”
Beatrice began crying silently.
Nora watched Camila carefully.
Not pushing.
Camila touched her own chest.
“And I hated you.”
Beatrice nodded.
“You had every right.”
Camila frowned.
“No.”
The answer surprised them.
“I hated too long.”
Then her eyes clouded.
“Where’s Thomas?”
The moment passed.
Nora moved beside her.
“Upstairs, remember?”
Camila accepted that.
Vincent watched Nora guide his mother out.
His chest hurt.
Beatrice looked after them.
“I envy her.”
Vincent stared.
“Who?”
“Nora.”
“Why?”
“Your mother trusts her.”
There was no sarcasm.
Just grief.
Vincent sat.
Then Carmine turned on Beatrice.
“You paid the nurse?”
“Yes.”
“You staged Camila’s appearance?”
“Yes.”
“You risked the treaty to discredit an old woman?”
“I thought I was protecting it.”
Carmine laughed bitterly.
“Everyone in this room has apparently protected peace by lying until we had no peace left.”
That was accurate.
Then Elena entered.
She had been waiting outside with new forensic results.
“The tape restoration is progressing.”
Vincent looked up.
“Forty-eight hours.”
“Sooner.”
“How soon?”
“Tonight.”
Beatrice’s face went pale.
Elena continued.
“They isolated the voice immediately after the gunshot.”
Carmine stood.
“Whose?”
“Julian’s.”
Everyone stopped breathing.
“What does he say?”
Elena placed the preliminary transcript on the table.
Only six words.
BEA, WHY DID YOU GRAB MY ARM?
Beatrice stared.
Then shook her head.
“No.”
Vincent’s eyes narrowed.
Beatrice whispered:
“That’s not what happened.”
But the words changed everything.
If Beatrice grabbed Julian’s arm while he held the gun—
May you like
then the shot that killed Thomas might not have been the deliberate murder everyone had assumed.
And the difference between murder, panic, and a fatal struggle had been buried beneath ten years of lies.