Chapter 5 - THE HOUSE ON ELM STREET

The drive to Arthur Vance’s house was a tense, silent blur.
Tristan drove his heavy, armored SUV himself, refusing to bring a security detail. He insisted that pulling up with a fleet of black Suburbans would only spook Arthur into doing something drastic.
I sat in the passenger seat, gripping the door handle so tightly my knuckles ached.
"Turn left at the next light," I instructed quietly, navigating the dark, rain-slicked streets of the city's older, run-down suburbs.
Tristan followed my directions without a word. His face was a mask of cold, terrifying focus, illuminated only by the faint glow of the dashboard lights. The black tattoos crawling up his neck seemed to pulse with every tense movement of his jaw.
"Why did Madeline choose you to be Sophie's nanny?" Tristan suddenly asked, his voice a low rumble breaking the heavy silence.
I looked at him, surprised by the question. "I was cheap. She found me through a community board when I was desperate for work to pay for night school. She knew I wouldn't ask too many questions about why the 'widowed' mother was never home."
Tristan let out a sharp, bitter laugh. "She excels at finding people to use."
"She loves Sophie," I argued softly, feeling a strange need to defend the motherly bond, even if it was horribly twisted. "She just loves money more."
"A distinction without a difference when a child is involved," Tristan said coldly.
We pulled onto Elm Street. The neighborhood was quiet, lined with small, dilapidated houses that had clearly seen better days.
"It’s the third house on the right," I pointed. "The one with the overgrown bushes."
Tristan killed the headlights and pulled the heavy SUV to a slow, silent stop a few houses down. We sat in the dark, watching the property.
The house looked entirely abandoned. The front porch light was burnt out, the curtains were drawn tight, and there were no cars in the driveway.
"Are you sure this is it?" Tristan asked, frowning.
"I’m sure," I nodded. "But Arthur’s car is gone. He drives an old silver sedan."
"He might be out gambling," Tristan reasoned, reaching into the center console and pulling out a heavy, tactical flashlight. "Or he might have parked around back to hide his presence."
Tristan turned to me, his expression grave. "Leah, I need you to stay in the car. Lock the doors. If I’m not back in ten minutes, or if you hear anything concerning, you drive away and call Marcus. Understood?"
"I can't just wait here," I protested, my protective instincts for Sophie screaming at me to move. "If Arthur is in there..."
"If Arthur is in there, he’s not going to hesitate to use violence," Tristan interrupted firmly. "You are unarmed and untrained. I can't protect you and look for Sophie at the same time. Stay. In. The. Car."
I swallowed hard, seeing the absolute authority in his eyes. He wasn't just being a billionaire CEO; he was a man preparing for a physical fight.
"Okay," I whispered.
Tristan offered a brief, reassuring nod. He slipped out of the SUV, shutting the door silently, and melted into the shadows of the overgrown yard.
I sat in the dark, the silence pressing against my ears. Every minute felt like an hour. I watched the dark house, praying to see Tristan walk out with a little girl in his arms.
Five minutes passed. Then seven.
Suddenly, a loud, sharp crash echoed from the back of the house, like a window shattering.
I jumped, my heart hammering violently in my chest.
If you hear anything concerning, drive away.
I looked at the keys Tristan had left in the ignition. I could leave. I could call Marcus and let the professionals handle it.
But then, I heard a faint, terrified scream.
It wasn't a man’s voice. It was high, sharp, and distinctly child-like.
Sophie.
I didn't think. I threw the SUV door open and sprinted across the wet grass toward the house. I ignored the thorny bushes tearing at my clothes and ran straight for the front porch.
I grabbed the doorknob. It was locked.
I backed up and kicked the heavy wooden door with all my might, but it didn't budge.
"Sophie!" I screamed, banging my fists against the wood.
The door suddenly swung open from the inside.
But it wasn't Sophie. And it wasn't Tristan.
Standing in the doorway, illuminated by the dim light of the hallway, was Arthur Vance. He looked disheveled, wild-eyed, and terrified. He was clutching a heavy, blood-stained metal pipe in his hand.
He stared at me, sheer panic washing over his face.
"You," Arthur gasped, recognizing me from my time as the nanny.
Before I could turn and run, Arthur lunged forward, grabbing me by the hair and violently hauling me into the house.
He slammed the door shut, locking the deadbolt with a loud, terrifying click.
"Shut up!" Arthur hissed, pressing the cold, bloody metal pipe against my throat. "Not one sound, or I’ll kill you right here."
I choked back a sob, my eyes darting wildly around the dim hallway.
"Where is she?" I gagged, struggling to breathe against the pipe. "Where is Sophie?"
Arthur laughed—a frantic, hysterical sound. "She’s in the basement. Exactly where her mother left her."
May you like
He yanked me forcefully down the hallway, dragging me toward a heavy wooden door that led beneath the house.
"And your billionaire boyfriend?" Arthur sneered, throwing the basement door open. "He’s down there too. Though, I don't think he’ll be waking up anytime soon."