Plot twist

Chapter 2 - THE CHICAGO TRIP

His eyes met mine.

I saw the micro-expression flash across his features. A brief, almost imperceptible widening of his pupils. A slight parting of his lips before he quickly clamped them shut.

It was the look of a man who suddenly realized he was walking on thin ice, but wasn't sure if I could hear it cracking.

"Yeah," Ryan said, letting out a short, forced breath that was meant to sound like a chuckle. "Must be. Those Midwest red-eye flights always mess up my internal clock."

I smiled back, the expression feeling stiff on my face.

Red-eye flights.

"Well," Claire interrupted, her voice a little too bright. She walked over and set her coffee mug in the sink. "I'll let you three get to your pancakes. I have to get ready for an open house at noon anyway."

Claire was a real estate agent. Not commercial, like me. Residential. She sold expensive, staged homes to couples moving to the suburbs. She was good at it, too. She knew how to make things look perfect, even when the foundation was crumbling.

"Thanks for letting Lily sleep over, Claire," Ryan said, jingling his keys again.

"Anytime," she smiled. "She's my favorite niece."

"I'm your only niece, Auntie Claire!" Lily shouted from the mudroom, hopping on one foot as she finally got her second pink sneaker on.

We all laughed. The sound was horribly normal.

I gave Claire a quick hug. She smelled like her expensive vanilla perfume. No trace of cedar and bergamot. They were careful.

"I'll call you later," I told my sister, my voice perfectly level.

"Sounds good. Love you guys," she replied, waving as we walked out the front door.

The drive to the diner was exactly ten minutes. Ryan drove. Lily sat in the back, happily making Mr. Buttons do somersaults over the seatbelt.

I sat in the passenger seat, my hand resting casually over the pocket of my cardigan, feeling the heavy, cold metal of the platinum watch.

My mind was working rapidly.

If Ryan had been in Chicago three weeks ago, why was his watch under Claire's bed?

Could he have visited her house before he left for the airport and dropped it?

No. He had packed his bags the night before. I remembered seeing the watch on his wrist when he kissed me goodbye in our kitchen on Thursday morning. He always wore it when he traveled. He said it was his good luck charm for closing deals.

So, he either returned from Chicago, went straight to Claire's house, slept with her, lost his watch, and then came home to me...

Or he never went to Chicago at all.

"You're quiet," Ryan noted, glancing at me as we stopped at a red light.

"Just thinking about work," I lied smoothly. "That new lease agreement on the Seaport property is a mess. The client wants an out-clause after two years."

It was the perfect lie. Boring enough that Ryan wouldn't ask follow-up questions, but realistic enough to explain my distraction.

"They always do," Ryan agreed, turning his attention back to the road.

We arrived at the diner. We ordered pancakes. Lily got her chocolate chips. Ryan got his black coffee. I ordered tea, though I couldn't stomach a single sip.

I watched my husband eat. I watched him wipe a smudge of chocolate off our daughter's cheek. He was so incredibly normal.

I needed to know if he went to Chicago.

"Did you ever hear back from the hotel security?" I asked suddenly, right as Ryan was taking a bite of his eggs.

He paused, his fork hovering halfway to his mouth.

"What hotel security?" Lily asked, her mouth full of pancakes.

"The one in Chicago, honey," I said, keeping my eyes locked on Ryan. "Daddy lost his special watch there, remember?"

Ryan lowered his fork. He cleared his throat.

"Uh, no," Ryan said, looking down at his plate. "They said without camera footage from inside the room, there wasn't much they could do. The cleaning staff denied taking it. It's a dead end, Elena. I've already made peace with it."

"It's just such a shame," I sighed, stirring my untouched tea. "It was our ten-year anniversary gift."

"I know," he said softly, finally looking at me. His eyes looked genuinely sad. "I feel terrible about it. I really do."

If I hadn't had the watch in my pocket, I would have believed him. He was that good.

"Which hotel was it again?" I asked casually. "The Palmer House? Maybe I could call them. Sometimes wives get farther with management than husbands do."

Ryan shifted uncomfortably in the vinyl booth.

"No, don't do that," he said quickly. "It wasn't the Palmer. It was... the Drake. But really, Elena, let it go. It's just a watch. It's the thought that counts, right?"

"Right," I agreed softly.

The Drake.

When we got home, Ryan went out to the garage to clean his golf clubs. Lily ran up to her playroom.

I went straight to Ryan's home office.

I closed the door quietly behind me. Ryan was a meticulous record-keeper. He kept all his business expenses in a specific folder in his desk drawer so his accountant could easily access them for tax season.

I opened the bottom drawer. It wasn't locked. He had no reason to lock it. I had never snooped in his office in twelve years of marriage.

I found the folder labeled "Travel Expenses - Current Year."

My hands were shaking as I flipped through the neatly organized receipts.

January. February. March.

I reached the section for last month. The month of the Chicago trip.

There was a flight itinerary. Boston to Chicago O'Hare. Departing Thursday 8:00 AM. Returning Sunday 4:00 PM.

But as I looked closer, my blood ran cold.

The itinerary wasn't a receipt. It was a printed confirmation of a booking.

I dug deeper into the folder, looking for the hotel receipt from The Drake. Looking for dinner receipts. Looking for Uber charges in Chicago.

There was nothing.

Not a single receipt from Chicago.

But tucked in the very back of the folder, misfiled behind a stack of office supply invoices, I found a small, crumpled piece of paper.

I pulled it out and smoothed it flat on the desk.

It was a receipt for a romantic bed and breakfast.

The Harbor View Inn.

Located in Cape Cod. Less than two hours away.

The dates on the receipt were Thursday to Sunday. The exact dates Ryan was supposedly in Chicago.

And at the bottom of the receipt, under "Guest Names," it didn't say Ryan and Claire.

It said Mr. and Mrs. Ryan Sterling.

He hadn't just taken my sister on a romantic getaway while I was working. He had checked her in using my name.

Before I could process the sheer, sickening audacity of it, my phone buzzed in my pocket.

It was a text from Claire.

Hey sis! Can you check Lily’s bag? I think she accidentally took one of my bracelets when she packed up her toys this morning.

I stared at the text.

A bracelet.

My sister wasn't texting about a bracelet.

May you like

She had gone up to her bedroom after we left. She had looked under her bed.

She knew the watch was missing.

Related Stories

Other posts