Chapter 4 - THE KEY TO THE PAST

The silence that followed my question was thick and suffocating.
Nathan’s eyes were locked on the small silver key in my hand, wide with an uncharacteristic, raw terror. The arrogant CEO who had just tried to brush off a quarter-billion-dollar embezzlement was suddenly terrified of a piece of antique metal.
"Give that to me," Nathan demanded, his voice cracking, entirely stripped of its usual smooth authority.
"No," I said, stepping backward, my hand resting protectively over my stomach.
"Olivia, I am warning you," Nathan hissed, taking a frantic step toward me.
His father, Marcus, immediately grabbed Nathan’s arm, hauling him backward. "You won't touch her, Nathan. Security! Restrain him!"
The two guards, finally realizing who was signing their paychecks tomorrow, moved in. They grabbed Nathan by the arms, pinning him effectively.
"Let me go!" Nathan roared, struggling wildly. "That belongs to me!"
I stared at the silver key. The intricate, swirling pattern on the bow of the key looked vaguely familiar, but I couldn't place it.
"What does it open, Nathan?" I asked again, the dread pooling in my stomach.
"It’s just an old safety deposit box," Nathan lied, sweating profusely. "It’s nothing. Give it back."
"If it’s nothing, you wouldn't be shaking," Brielle spat, wiping her mascara-stained cheeks. She glared at the man she thought she loved. "He’s a pathological liar, Olivia. Don't believe a word he says."
I didn't need her warning. I already knew.
I looked around the ballroom. The guests were murmuring, a sea of bewildered faces watching the destruction of a titan.
"Mr. Cole," I said, turning to Nathan's father. "I need you to call the police. Right now. Tell them to send the financial crimes unit."
Marcus nodded grimly, pulling out his cell phone.
I didn't wait for the police to arrive. I knew Nathan’s lawyers would descend on this house like vultures the moment he was in handcuffs. If this key opened something important, I needed to find it before they sealed the estate.
I turned and walked out of the ballroom, ignoring the whispers and the stares.
I headed straight for Nathan’s private home office.
The heavy oak doors were locked, but I knew the passcode. I punched it in, and the door clicked open.
The office was a shrine to his ego. Leather couches, walls lined with awards, and a massive mahogany desk.
I began searching. I checked the drawers, the filing cabinets, the hidden wall safe behind the painting. The safe opened with his birthdate, but it only contained standard corporate documents and a few stacks of emergency cash. No keyhole.
I stood in the center of the room, frustrated, rubbing my aching lower back.
Where would a tech billionaire hide an antique lock?
My eyes drifted to the far corner of the room. Sitting on a pedestal was a heavy, antique wooden humidor. Nathan didn't smoke cigars. He had bought it at an auction years ago, claiming he liked the craftsmanship. I had always thought it was pretentious.
I walked over to the pedestal.
The humidor was beautifully carved from dark walnut. And right in the center of the brass latch was a small, intricate keyhole.
My heart hammered against my ribs.
I slid the silver key into the lock. It turned with a smooth, heavy click.
I lifted the lid.
Inside wasn't cigars.
It was a small, velvet-lined box containing a single, delicate item.
I reached in and pulled it out.
It was a beautiful, vintage rosary. The beads were made of polished rosewood, the crucifix crafted from tarnished silver.
I stared at it, completely bewildered. Nathan wasn't religious. He had actively mocked my family's faith when we were dating. Why would he keep an antique rosary locked in a humidor?
As I lifted the rosary, a small, folded piece of paper fluttered from beneath the velvet lining and landed on the desk.
I picked it up. The paper was old, yellowed at the edges.
I unfolded it.
It was a handwritten letter.
Nathan,
If you are reading this, it means the worst has happened, and I am gone.
I did what you asked. I moved the funds. But the guilt is eating me alive.
I cannot let her take the fall for this. I left the proof of the original transfers hidden where we first met. Please, for once in your life, do the right thing.
Forgive me.
- David.
My blood ran entirely cold.
David.
David was Nathan’s original business partner. The man who had co-founded the software company with him ten years ago. David had died in a tragic, single-car accident on a rainy highway three years ago, right around the time the company exploded in value.
Nathan had told everyone David had been drinking. It was a tragedy that had garnered Nathan immense public sympathy.
I stared at the letter.
David hadn't just died in an accident. He had been terrified. He had been moving funds for Nathan.
And then, I noticed a tiny, secondary note hastily scrawled at the very bottom of the page, written in a different, much messier handwriting.
"He didn't do the right thing, David. He cut the brakes."
I dropped the paper, a ragged gasp tearing from my throat.
Nathan hadn't just embezzled money.
He was a murderer.
May you like
Before I could process the sheer, paralyzing horror of the revelation, the heavy oak doors of the office burst open.
"I told you not to go looking, Olivia," Nathan said, stepping into the room. He had escaped the security guards. And he was holding a heavy bronze paperweight in his hand.