Plot twist

Chapter 6 - THE GHOST IN THE PHOTOGRAPH

My fingers dug into the edge of Spencer’s desk as the room spun.

Evelyn.

I hadn't spoken her name aloud in three decades. When we were teenagers, Evelyn had been the wild one, the beautiful one. She had gotten pregnant at seventeen. Our strict, unforgiving parents had sent her away to a home for unwed mothers in upstate New York. A year later, they told me she had stolen a car, crashed it into a ravine, and died.

I had mourned her every day of my life.

But the woman in this photograph was in her fifties. She was alive.

Why was Spencer investigating my dead sister? And why had Evelyn—if it was really her—sent ten thousand dollars and Chloe's buried baby bracelet to the bakery to blow up the gender reveal?

A horrifying thought struck me.

I grabbed my phone and dialed the number of my brother, David, who had been at the party earlier. He was the only one old enough to remember the details of Evelyn's "death."

He answered on the second ring. "Margaret? Is Chloe okay? What the hell happened with Spencer?"

"David, listen to me very carefully," I demanded, keeping my voice low. "Did you ever see Evelyn’s body?"

Silence on the line. Then, a heavy sigh. "Margaret... why are you asking this now?"

"Answer me, David! Did our parents lie? Is Evelyn alive?"

"Yes," David whispered. "She didn't die. She ran away after the baby was born. She made a fortune in real estate out west. Mom and Dad cut her out of the will and told everyone she was dead out of shame."

"Why didn't you ever tell me?!" I hissed.

"Because Evelyn made me promise not to! She hated our family. She wanted nothing to do with us."

"She has something to do with us now," I said, staring at the photograph. "David, what happened to Evelyn’s baby? The one she had at seventeen?"

"She gave it up," David said. "A closed adoption. Why?"

I hung up the phone.

I looked at the medical files on the USB drive again. I looked at Maya’s name as the egg donor.

Then, I looked closely at the dates in Spencer’s ledger.

Spencer hadn't met Maya randomly. He had sought her out. He had paid for a private investigator to find Maya three years ago—before he even started the affair.

Why would a millionaire trust-fund heir seek out a random, working-class woman to have an affair with, and then steal her eggs to implant in his wife?

Unless Maya wasn't random.

I zoomed in on the PI's notes about Maya in the ledger.

Subject: Maya Evans. Born: October 14th. Adopted at birth in upstate New York.

My blood ran cold.

Maya was exactly thirty-two years old.

Maya was Evelyn’s abandoned daughter. Maya was my niece. Chloe’s first cousin.

Spencer knew. He had engineered this entire twisted family tree. He had deliberately harvested the eggs of Chloe's blood relative to implant in Chloe, keeping the genetics entirely within our familyline. But why?

Suddenly, I heard a sharp shattering of glass from downstairs.

Someone had just broken the window in the kitchen.

I grabbed the heavy metal flashlight from Spencer’s desk and crept out into the hallway. The house was pitch black; the power had been cut.

I heard heavy footsteps crunching on the broken glass in the kitchen.

"Mom?" Chloe’s terrified voice called out from the guest bedroom.

"Lock the door, Chloe!" I yelled, running down the stairs, raising the flashlight like a club.

A flashlight beam hit me in the face, blinding me.

"Drop it, Margaret," Spencer's voice echoed in the dark foyer.

May you like

He stepped into the moonlight filtering through the broken window. But he wasn't alone. Two men in dark suits stood behind him, their faces impassive.

"You shouldn't have gone digging in my office," Spencer said, his eyes cold and dead. "Now, we're going to have a little family meeting. And Chloe is going to sign a piece of paper, or neither of you are leaving this house."

Related Stories

Other posts