Chapter 8 - The Trap at the Mother-in-Law's House

The phone line went dead.
I stared at the black screen of my phone, the silence in Dr. Sterling’s kitchen deafening. Brandon had Lily. The one thing I had fought so desperately to protect was now in the hands of a man willing to destroy his own family for money.
"Sarah, what happened?" Dr. Sterling asked, stepping forward, his face pale with concern.
"He has Lily," I choked out, my voice raw with terror. "He said he’ll take her out of the country if I don't bring the ledger to Patricia's house in an hour."
Dr. Sterling grabbed my shoulders. "You cannot go there. It's a trap. If you walk into that house, they will drug you, put you in a car, and you will wake up strapped to a bed in Oakwood Clinic. My brother is mobilizing the FBI right now. We need to wait for them."
"I don't have time to wait!" I yelled, pulling away from him. "He’s going to take my daughter! He already sold her out once for fifteen thousand dollars, what do you think he’ll do now?"
I grabbed the ledger, the forged insurance policy, and my car keys from the island.
"Sarah, stop!" Dr. Sterling pleaded.
I looked back at him, the fierce, undeniable instinct of a mother taking over every rational thought. "Tell your brother to send the FBI to Patricia Mitchell’s house in exactly one hour. If I am not out by then, tell them to breach the doors."
I ran out of the house and threw myself into my car.
The sun was just beginning to rise over Nashville, casting long, gray shadows across the empty streets. I drove like a madwoman, running two red lights, my hands gripping the steering wheel so tightly they ached.
Patricia lived in an upscale, gated community on the west side of the city. I had the gate code memorized from years of forced Sunday dinners.
I pulled up to the massive brick house. Brandon's car was parked in the driveway.
I took a deep breath, grabbed the heavy pepper spray from my center console, and hid it in my jacket pocket. I tucked the ledger and the documents under my arm.
I walked up to the front door and didn't even knock. I pushed it open.
"Brandon!" I screamed, walking into the grand foyer. "Where is she?!"
The house was eerily quiet.
"Right here, Sarah," a calm voice answered from the formal living room.
I stepped into the room.
Patricia was sitting elegantly in an armchair, sipping a cup of coffee as if this were a casual morning visit. Brandon stood by the fireplace, looking anxious but triumphant.
And sitting on the velvet sofa, looking absolutely terrified and clutching her stuffed rabbit, was Lily.
"Mom!" Lily cried, trying to stand up.
Brandon immediately put a heavy hand on her shoulder, forcing her back down. "Stay put, Lily. Your mother and I need to have a grown-up conversation."
"Take your hands off her," I snarled, stepping toward him.
Patricia raised a hand. "Let's not make this ugly, Sarah. You brought the documents. Hand them over, and we can resolve this peacefully."
"Peacefully?" I laughed, a bitter, hollow sound. "You framed me for domestic assault. You forged a life insurance policy. You’ve been hiding your own daughter in a psychiatric ward for seven years. There is no peace here, Patricia."
Brandon’s eyes widened. He looked at his mother in panic. "She knows about Chloe?"
Patricia didn't flinch. She maintained her cold, aristocratic composure. "It doesn't matter what she thinks she knows, Brandon. The only thing that matters is that she is currently a wanted fugitive experiencing a psychotic break."
She pointed to the ledger in my hands. "Give me the book, Sarah."
"Let Lily walk out that front door right now, and you can have it," I demanded.
"That's not how negotiations work, sweetheart," Brandon sneered, taking a step toward me.
"Stop!" a new voice shouted from the hallway.
We all turned.
Standing in the doorway of the living room was Nicole.
She looked exhausted, her blonde hair messy, still wearing the gray hoodie from the diner. But her hands weren't empty. She was holding a heavy brass candlestick she must have picked up from the hallway table.
"Nicole?" Brandon gasped, completely bewildered. "What the hell are you doing here?"
"I followed Sarah from the diner," Nicole said, her voice shaking but determined. "I heard you on the phone with your mother earlier. I know you were planning to take the money and leave me with nothing."
Patricia rolled her eyes. "Oh, wonderful. The mistress has arrived to demand her cut."
"I don't want your money!" Nicole yelled, pointing the heavy candlestick at Brandon. "I want to know if it's true! Did you lock your own sister in a mental hospital because you got her pregnant?"
Brandon’s face went chalk-white. He looked at his mother, terrified.
Lily let out a horrified gasp from the sofa, staring at her father as if he were a monster.
"Nicole, you don't know what you're talking about," Brandon stammered, stepping away from Lily. "She's lying! Sarah made that up to ruin me!"
"I didn't make it up, Brandon," I said coldly. "And neither did the medical records at Oakwood Clinic. Jane Doe. Admitted seven years ago. Heavily sedated on your mother's dime."
Patricia stood up, finally losing her pristine composure. Her face twisted into a mask of pure, ugly rage.
"She was ruining everything!" Patricia screamed, pointing a trembling finger at me. "Brandon was going to be a regional director! He was going to provide for this family! Chloe was a weak, stupid girl who wanted to ruin his life with a scandal! I did what I had to do to protect my son!"
The confession hung in the air, heavy and damning.
"You're a monster," Nicole whispered, horrified.
"I'm a mother," Patricia spat. She looked at Brandon. "Take the ledger from her. Now."
Brandon lunged at me.
I didn't hesitate. I pulled the pepper spray from my pocket and unleashed a heavy, concentrated stream directly into his eyes.
Brandon roared in agony, clutching his face and stumbling backward into the coffee table, crashing to the floor in a heap of broken glass.
"Lily, run!" I screamed.
Lily bolted from the sofa, grabbing my hand as we sprinted toward the front door.
Patricia shrieked, grabbing the heavy brass fire poker from the hearth. She swung wildly, but Nicole stepped in front of her, shoving Patricia hard into the wall with the candlestick.
"Go, Sarah!" Nicole yelled, struggling with the older woman.
I dragged Lily through the foyer, throwing the front door open.
We spilled out onto the front porch, gasping for air.
And directly in front of us, blocking the driveway, were three black SUVs.
May you like
Federal agents in tactical gear poured out of the vehicles, weapons drawn, swarming the lawn.
Dr. Sterling’s brother had delivered.