Plot twist

Chapter 5 - The Ghost In The Yankees Shirt

Daniel pushed himself off the table, holding his hands out toward our daughter like a beggar.

“Beth, honey, it’s me,” he wept. “It’s Dad.”

Beth looked at him. Her face was a mask of absolute, chilling composure. She looked so much like me in that moment, but with a hardness I had never possessed.

“My dad died twelve years ago,” Beth said, her voice echoing in the silent room. She reached up to her neck and unclasped the silver locket she had worn every single day since she was fourteen. The locket Daniel had given her.

She tossed it onto the floor. It skittered across the polished wood and stopped at Daniel’s expensive leather shoes.

“Beth, please, you don't understand—” Daniel begged.

“I understand that you watched me cry at a closed casket,” Beth interrupted, her voice finally cracking with a lifetime of suppressed rage. “I understand that I spent ten years in therapy thinking I wasn't enough to keep you alive. Don't call me honey. You don't know me.”

Evelyn let out a sharp, irritated sigh, keeping her gun trained on Luca. “This is very touching, but I don't care about your family drama. Give me the ledger, girl.”

“No,” Beth said firmly.

Evelyn cocked the gun. “I will shoot your mother in the head.”

“If you shoot my mother, Mr. Moretti’s snipers will drop you before her body hits the floor,” Beth replied smoothly.

I stared at my daughter in shock.

Evelyn glanced nervously toward the high, velvet-draped windows of the private dining room. Moretti gave Beth a small, approving nod.

“How do you know about Leo’s files, Beth?” Moretti asked quietly.

Beth clutched the heavy leather ledger to her chest. “Six months ago, a man was brought into my ER. Multiple gunshot wounds. He was delirious. He grabbed my arm and kept apologizing to a man named Leo. He said Silas ordered the fire.”

Silas. Evelyn’s father. Luca’s uncle.

“I started digging,” Beth continued, her eyes never leaving Moretti. “I went back to our old apartment in Brooklyn. The one Mom and I had to abandon because we couldn't pay the rent after the fire. I bribed the super to let me in. I pried up the loose floorboards in Dad’s old office.”

Daniel went paler than a sheet. “You found the safe box.”

“I found the safe box,” Beth confirmed, her voice dripping with disgust. “I found the original loan shark threats. But I also found Leo Moretti’s real ledger. The one he gave you to hide before he was killed.”

Evelyn’s gun wavered. “That’s impossible. We burned that warehouse to the ground to destroy that ledger.”

“You burned a decoy,” Beth said. “Leo knew Silas was coming for him. He hid the real evidence of Silas’s embezzlement in our apartment. He gave it to a desperate gambler he thought he could trust.”

Beth looked at Daniel.

“You knew,” I whispered, the final piece of my husband’s horrific cowardice falling into place. “You knew Silas killed Leo. And instead of going to the police, you took the money and ran, leaving Silas in power.”

Daniel wept into his hands.

Evelyn realized the gravity of what Beth held. If that ledger went to the mafia commission, her father was a dead man.

She turned the gun directly toward Beth’s chest.

“Give it to me!” Evelyn screamed.

Before anyone could move, the fire alarms in the restaurant shrieked to life.

A deafening explosion rocked the building, throwing all of us to the floor. The crystal chandelier above the table tore free from the ceiling, crashing down in a shower of glass and darkness.

May you like

And through the thick, sudden smoke, I heard a man's voice over the restaurant's PA system.

“Lock the doors. Burn them all.”

Related Stories

Other posts