Plot twist

Chapter 2 - The Song of Our Secrets

The rain against the stone terrace suddenly felt colder, sharper. Andrew’s words hung in the damp air, echoing the sweet, haunting melody still spilling from the ballroom behind us.

The song she and Daniel had always dreamed of dancing to.

I stared at Andrew. He wasn't smiling anymore. He was watching me with a quiet, uncomfortable intensity, clearly realizing he had stepped onto dangerous ground.

"She told you that?" I whispered, my voice sounding completely hollow, stripped of all the warmth and security I had woken up with that morning.

Andrew rubbed the back of his neck, looking regretful. "Evelyn, I... I’m sorry. I thought you knew. Natalie said Daniel composed it for her years ago, before they broke up, but he never finished it. She said he finally gave her the completed sheet music as a wedding gift."

The air left my lungs entirely.

Daniel hadn't just given my mother's dying gift to his ex-girlfriend. He had stolen the credit for it. He had taken the agonizing, pain-filled hours my mother spent hunched over her piano, coughing and exhausted, and claimed them as his own romantic gesture. He had painted over my grief with his own narcissism.

"It wasn't his," I stated, my voice dropping to a harsh, trembling pitch. "He didn't write it. My mother wrote it for me while she was dying of cancer."

Andrew’s eyes widened in genuine horror. The color drained from his face. "Oh my god. Evelyn... I had no idea."

He looked back through the glass doors, watching his fiancée laughing and dancing in the center of the room to stolen music. The disgust in his eyes was immediate and visceral.

"I need to leave," I gasped, the physical need to escape the mansion overwhelming everything else.

"Let me help you," Andrew offered quickly, stepping forward.

"No," I said, backing away, putting my hands up. "Just... don't tell them I know. Please. I need to think."

I didn't wait for him to agree. I turned and practically ran down the terrace steps, ignoring the rain soaking my thin evening dress. I bypassed the main entrance, cutting across the wet grass of the gardens toward the valet parking. I didn't care about ruining my heels or my hair. I only cared about putting distance between myself and the man I married.

I gave the valet my ticket, my hands shaking so violently I dropped it twice. When my modest sedan pulled up, I threw myself into the driver's seat, locked the doors, and cranked the heat, shivering uncontrollably.

I drove aimlessly for twenty minutes before pulling into the empty parking lot of a 24-hour pharmacy. I parked under a flickering streetlight and finally allowed myself to shatter.

I sobbed until my ribs ached, gripping the steering wheel. He gave her my mother’s song. He told her it was theirs.

How long had he been lying? What else was a lie?

My phone buzzed in my purse.

Daniel.

I stared at the screen, watching his name flash. I didn't answer. It buzzed again. And again. Then a text message popped up.

Eve, please. It was a misunderstanding. She pressured me for something sentimental. It meant nothing. Come back inside.

I stared at the message. It meant nothing.

He had taken my mother’s soul and handed it to another woman, and he called it a misunderstanding.

I wiped my face roughly with the back of my hand. The sadness was slowly, deliberately burning away, replaced by a cold, unfamiliar clarity. I started the car and drove back to our quiet neighborhood outside Philadelphia, back to the house that suddenly didn't feel like home anymore.

I walked through the front door, the silence greeting me like a physical blow. I didn't turn on the lights. I walked straight to our bedroom and opened the small, locked drawer in my nightstand where I kept my most precious belongings.

I pulled out the manila folder that held the original, handwritten sheet music my mother had given me.

I opened it.

My breath hitched.

The folder wasn't empty, but it didn't hold the thick, textured paper of my mother’s original composition. It held crisp, white, high-quality photocopies.

He hadn't just shared the music. He had taken the originals to a print shop, copied them, and placed the copies back in my drawer, assuming I wouldn't notice the difference in the paper or the ink. He had been planning this.

I sat on the edge of the bed, staring at the fake pages.

Why would he do this? Why would he risk our marriage over a piece of music?

I stood up and walked into Daniel’s home office. I rarely came in here; he was fiercely protective of his workspace, claiming his property management documents contained sensitive client information.

I opened his laptop. He had changed his password three months ago, right around the time Natalie moved back. I tried his usual combinations, but none worked.

Then, an idea struck me. I thought of the song. I thought of the title my mother had given it.

I typed: LightsComeHome.

Incorrect Password.

I tried again, modifying it based on what Andrew had told me. I thought about the lie Daniel had told Natalie.

I typed: OurSong2018.

The screen unlocked.

My stomach churned violently.

I clicked on his email application. I didn't search for Natalie’s name; that was too obvious. I searched for attachments.

I scrolled through months of mundane work emails until I found a thread from four months ago—shortly before Natalie announced her engagement to Andrew. The subject line was simply: The Blueprint.

I clicked on it.

It wasn't a property blueprint. It was a PDF document containing the digitized sheet music of my mother’s song.

But it was the message attached to the PDF that made my blood run cold.

Here it is, Nat. Just like I promised. Once the trust clears after the wedding, we’ll secure the California property. Keep Andrew distracted until the ink is dry. He suspects nothing.

I stared at the screen, rereading the words until they blurred.

Once the trust clears after the wedding.

Natalie was marrying Andrew Mitchell. Andrew Mitchell wasn't just a successful architect; he was the sole heir to the Mitchell family fortune, one of the oldest and wealthiest families in Philadelphia.

They weren't just having an affair. They were orchestrating a massive, calculated financial scam.

Daniel and Natalie were planning to use her marriage to Andrew to access his family’s trust, siphon the money into a property in California, and run away together. The song—my mother’s song—was just a twisted, romanticized part of their sick, delusional plan.

I heard the front door open downstairs, followed by the heavy, hurried footsteps of my husband.

"Evelyn?" Daniel called out, his voice echoing up the stairs, laced with panic.

I quickly forwarded the email thread to my personal account and deleted the sent message. I closed the laptop, returning it exactly as I had found it.

I walked out of the office and stood at the top of the stairs, looking down at the man I thought I knew. He looked disheveled, his tie loosened, rain still clinging to his jacket.

"Evelyn," he breathed a sigh of relief, taking a step up. "Thank God you're home. We need to talk. I can explain everything."

May you like

I looked at him, my heart turning completely to stone.

"There's nothing to explain, Daniel," I said softly, gripping the banister to stop my hands from shaking. "I know exactly what you've done."

Related Stories

Other posts