Chapter 4

I locked the car doors instantly, my eyes darting frantically around the dark street. Someone had been in my car.
I grabbed the drawing. It was on thick construction paper, folded haphazardly in half. I smoothed it out under the dim dome light. It was a crude crayon sketch of three stick figures standing in front of a blue house. A tall man, a woman with blonde hair, and a small boy.
In the corner, written in shaky, oversized letters, was the name: Leo.
My lungs seized. Caitlyn had blonde hair. Blake was tall.
I flipped the paper over. Stamped on the back was a logo: Arlington Day School.
Blake hadn't just put this in my car. He had dropped it earlier, maybe weeks ago, and it had slipped under the seat. When I threw my suitcase in earlier tonight, I must have knocked it loose. It wasn't a threat; it was a ghost of his double life bubbling to the surface.
I put the car in drive and hit the gas.
The drive to Arlington took forty minutes. The suburb was quiet, lined with manicured lawns and massive, sprawling homes that cost triple what Blake and I had paid for our modest three-bedroom. I pulled up to the gated community of Oakwood Estates.
I punched in the code from the back of the receipt: #4492.
The iron gates swung open with a heavy mechanical hum. I drove slowly, checking the house numbers against the pharmacy address. Finally, I found it. 1422 Elmwood Drive.
It was the blue house from the drawing.
There were no cars in the driveway. The house was completely dark. I parked on the street, grabbed my flashlight, and walked up the long stone path. My hands were shaking, but the anger burning in my chest kept me moving.
I reached the front porch. The door had a heavy smart lock, but below it was a standard deadbolt. I reached into my purse and pulled out my old master key ring from my days in property management. I still kept it because it had my gym membership tag on it. Most builders used the same five standard Kwikset locks for new developments.
I slid the third key in. It didn't turn.
I tried the fourth. Nothing.
I slid the fifth key in, jiggled it slightly, and turned.
Click.
The lock gave way. I pushed the door open, stepping into a cavernous, perfectly decorated foyer. The air smelled like expensive vanilla candles and citrus floor cleaner. I clicked my flashlight on, sweeping the beam across the walls.
Framed photos lined the hallway. I stepped closer to one. It was Caitlyn, looking radiant, holding a baby. Beside her stood Blake, beaming with a pride I had never seen on his face.
The date etched into the bottom of the silver frame read: Six years ago.
My breath caught in my throat. Six years ago. Blake and I had been married for four years. We dated for three.
He didn't meet Caitlyn two years ago. He knew her before he even met me.
I walked into the living room, feeling like a ghost haunting someone else's life. Toys were scattered across a Persian rug. A red winter coat hung over the back of the sofa. I walked over and checked the pockets. Nothing but a used tissue and a tube of lipstick.
But beneath the coat, resting on the coffee table, was a heavy leather-bound photo album.
I opened it. Page after page of vacations, birthdays, Christmases. Blake carving a turkey. Blake teaching a little boy to ride a bike. Blake kissing Caitlyn on a beach in Florida.
While I had been sitting at home, abandoning my painting, abandoning my career to be a "good wife," Blake had been living an entirely separate, fully funded life in the suburbs.
A sudden, sharp realization hit me. How was he affording this? Blake made good money, but not two-houses-in-Arlington money.
"Are you the decorator?"
I dropped the flashlight. It clattered against the hardwood floor, sending a chaotic beam of light spinning across the ceiling.
I spun around.
Standing at the bottom of the carpeted stairs, rubbing his eyes and holding a bright yellow toy truck, was a little boy. He was maybe four or five years old, wearing dinosaur pajamas. He had Blake’s messy brown hair and Caitlyn’s bright blue eyes.
"Leo?" I whispered, my voice trembling.
He nodded slowly. "Mommy said the decorator lady was coming to fix the curtains. But it's dark outside."
Before I could form a single word, the sound of tires screeching echoed from the driveway. Headlights swept through the living room windows, blinding me for a second. Car doors slammed.
"Leo, get away from her!" a woman’s voice screamed.
The front door flew open, and Caitlyn rushed in, her Thanksgiving dress torn at the hem, her makeup smeared down her face. She sprinted across the room, scooped Leo into her arms, and backed away from me, her eyes wide with absolute, unadulterated terror.
May you like
She wasn't looking at me like a rival. She was looking at me like a monster.
"Please," Caitlyn begged, her voice shaking violently. "Blake said you were unstable, but I didn't think you'd actually come for him. Please, Lauren. Keep the money. Just don't hurt my son."