Chapter 5 - The Devil on the Porch

The pounding on the door was relentless, rattling the glass in the living room windows.
"Molly, I know you’re in there! I need that drive!" Ben’s voice was muffled through the heavy wood, frantic and completely unhinged.
I stared at my mother, terror freezing the blood in my veins. "How did he find us so fast?"
"He didn't find us, he just assumed this was the only place you'd go," my mother whispered, closing the laptop quickly and pulling the flash drive from the port. She shoved it into her bra. "Stay away from the windows."
"I’m calling the police," I said, pulling my phone from my pocket with trembling fingers.
"Don't!" Ben screamed from the porch, pressing his face against the small pane of glass near the door handle. He could see me in the hallway. "Molly, please! If you call the cops, they’ll confiscate the drive! If they see what’s on it, we lose everything! I lose the company!"
"You already lost the company, Ben!" I shouted back, stepping just out of his line of sight. "We read the files! You’re fifty million dollars in debt! You’re a fraud!"
The pounding stopped.
A heavy, suffocating silence fell over the porch.
When Ben spoke again, the desperation was gone. The voice that filtered through the door was cold, calculating, and terrifyingly calm. It was the voice of a man who realized the mask had completely fallen off.
"So you know," Ben said smoothly. "You know about Paige."
"You set her up," I accused, tears burning my eyes. The sheer cruelty of his manipulation was staggering. "You made her sign the loans. You made her the guarantor."
"She signed them willingly," Ben countered, his tone dripping with arrogant dismissal. "She wanted the lifestyle, Molly. She wanted the dinners, the trips, the illusion of power. She was practically begging to be a part of it. I just gave her what she asked for."
"You lied to her!" I yelled. "You told her you loved her!"
"I told her what she needed to hear to keep the cash flow moving," Ben laughed, a dry, bitter sound. "You think you’re the only victim here, Molly? I’ve been drowning for three years! My investors were threatening to kill me! I needed a silent partner with clean credit to absorb the risk. Paige was perfectly naive and perfectly greedy."
He leaned heavily against the front door.
"But you can fix this, Molly," Ben pleaded, his voice shifting back to manipulative warmth. "Give me the drive. I have a buyer lined up for the main hotel property. The deal closes on Monday. If I get that money, I can pay off the fraudulent loans before the auditors notice. Paige walks away free. We all walk away free."
"You want me to help you cover up a federal crime?" I asked in disbelief.
"I want you to save your sister!" Ben fired back. "If you hand that drive to the police, Paige goes to prison for wire fraud, embezzlement, and tax evasion! She signed the papers, Molly! Ignorance is not a defense in federal court! You give that drive to the cops, you are sending your own sister to a cage for twenty years!"
My breath caught in my throat.
He was right.
If I turned him in, I turned Paige in. Ben had perfectly engineered a hostage situation using my own blood. I could ruin him, but the collateral damage would destroy the sister who had raised me, the sister who had bought me shoes, the sister who had betrayed me.
"Molly," Ben said softly through the door, sensing my hesitation. "I know you hate me. But do you hate Paige enough to destroy her life?"
I looked at my mother. She was pale, clutching her chest, staring at the front door as if a monster were standing on the other side. Because one was.
"I’m giving you five minutes, Molly," Ben warned, his voice hardening into a lethal threat. "Open the door and give me the drive. If you don't, I call the bank in the morning and default on the loans immediately. The feds will arrest Paige before lunch."
He stepped off the porch, walking back to his car idling in the street. He leaned against the hood, crossing his arms, watching the house. He was waiting.
"Mom," I whispered, panic clawing at my chest. "He’s right. If we go to the police, Paige goes to prison. She signed the papers."
"Paige made her bed," my mother said fiercely, her eyes blazing with a hard, uncompromising truth. "She slept with your husband. She helped him throw you out of your own home. She deserves to face the consequences."
"But twenty years in federal prison?" I cried, tears spilling over. "Mom, she’s an idiot, she’s vain, but she’s not a criminal mastermind! He manipulated her! I can't be the one who sends her away!"
"If you give him that drive," my mother reasoned, gripping my shoulders, "he destroys the only evidence that proves he orchestrated the fraud. He walks away clean, Paige is still legally on the hook for the debt, and he holds it over her head forever. Giving him the drive doesn't save Paige. It just makes her his slave."
I stared at her, the terrifying logic settling over me. Ben wouldn't pay off the loans. He would use the money to escape, leaving Paige to take the fall when the creditors eventually came knocking.
I looked out the living room window. Ben was still leaning against his car in the rain, looking at his watch.
I had to make a choice. Save my sister by destroying the evidence, or destroy my husband and risk taking my sister down with him.
Suddenly, a pair of headlights swept down the dark street.
A taxi pulled up sharply to the curb, stopping right behind Ben’s sleek sedan.
The back door flew open.
Paige stumbled out of the cab. She looked completely disheveled, her expensive clothes soaked by the rain, her mascara running in dark streaks down her face. She was sobbing hysterically, clutching her purse to her chest.
Ben stood up, staring at her in shock. "Paige? What are you doing here?"
Paige didn't look at him. She ran past him, sprinting up the walkway toward our mother’s front porch.
"Mom! Molly! Please!" Paige screamed, pounding her fists against the heavy wooden door. "Please, let me in! I’m so sorry! I’m so sorry!"
I hesitated, looking at my mother.
"Open it," my mother said quietly, stepping back.
I unlocked the deadbolt and pulled the door open.
Paige practically fell into the hallway, collapsing onto her knees on the hardwood floor. She grabbed my legs, weeping openly, entirely stripped of the arrogant, confident facade she had worn for six months.
"Molly, please forgive me," Paige sobbed, burying her face in her hands. "He lied to me. He used me. You were right."
I looked down at the sister who had betrayed me. I wanted to feel angry. I wanted to feel vindicated. But looking at her broken form on the floor, I only felt a profound, exhausting sadness.
"I know, Paige," I said softly, stepping back to let her stand up. "We found the flash drive. We know about the fraudulent loans."
Paige froze, looking up at me with wide, terrified eyes. "You know?"
"We know he made you the legal guarantor for fifty million dollars of stolen money," my mother said coldly. "He set you up to take the fall."
Paige stared at us, her breath coming in ragged gasps. Then, she slowly stood up, wiping the tears from her face. Her expression shifted from terrified panic to something strange. Something guarded.
"He didn't set me up," Paige said, her voice suddenly devoid of the hysterical sobbing she had just performed.
I frowned, confused by the sudden change in her demeanor. "What do you mean?"
Paige looked out the window at Ben, who was watching the house closely from the street. She didn't look angry at him. She gave him a tiny, almost imperceptible nod.
May you like
She turned back to me, the arrogant smirk slowly returning to her tear-stained face.
"I didn't sign those loans because he tricked me, Molly," Paige smiled, a cold, chilling expression. "I signed them because we planned this together. I just needed him to think I was a victim so he wouldn't realize I skimmed ten million off the top before the accounts went dry."