Chapter 2 - THE MAN AT THE GATE DIDN’T WANT ELEANOR’S MONEY. HE WANTED HIS SON
Nobody moved.
For several seconds, the only sound in Eleanor’s dining room was the faint crackle of the fire behind us.
Grant still stood beside his chair.
Elise had gone completely still.
Cody was quietly pushing a green bean around his plate, too young to understand why every adult in the room had suddenly stopped breathing.
My daughters understood enough.
Paige looked directly at Elise.
Lila looked at Grant.
Wren looked at me.
Margaret Wells remained near the dining-room door, the white envelope trembling slightly in her hand.
Grant spoke first.
“What man?”
Margaret swallowed.
“His name is Adam Reeves.”
Elise closed her eyes.
There.
Not confusion.
Recognition.
Grant saw it too.
His voice changed.
“You know him.”
Elise immediately reached for Cody.
“We should go.”
“No.”
Grant stepped between her and the doorway.
Not aggressively.
But firmly.
“You’re not walking out until you tell me who Adam Reeves is.”
Cody looked frightened.
“Mommy?”
That stopped everyone.
I stood.
“Grant.”
He looked at me.
“Not in front of him.”
Grant’s jaw tightened.
Then he looked at Cody.
For the first time that evening, the adults remembered there was a four-year-old child at the center of all this.
I crouched beside him.
“Hey, Cody.”
He looked at me cautiously.
“Would you like to go see the toy room again?”
Eleanor immediately said:
“He can stay.”
I turned toward her.
“No.”
Something in my voice made her stop.
I looked at Wren.
“Sweetheart, would you mind taking Cody with Margaret for a few minutes?”
Wren blinked.
She had been treated like background since we arrived.
Now she sat straighter.
“Okay.”
I looked at Cody.
“Wren knows where Grandma Eleanor keeps the train set.”
Wren corrected me.
“It’s missing three pieces.”
Cody finally smiled.
“I have trains.”
“Cool.”
She slid out of her chair.
Cody looked at Elise.
“Mommy?”
Elise’s face was tight.
Then she nodded.
“Go with them.”
Wren took Cody’s hand.
Margaret led them out.
Lila hesitated.
Then followed.
Paige stayed.
Sixteen.
Old enough to decide she wanted the truth.
Eleanor started to object.
I cut her off.
“Paige stays if she wants.”
My mother-in-law stared at me.
Then at my daughter.
For once, she said nothing.
Grant turned toward Elise.
“Who is Adam Reeves?”
Elise looked toward the windows.
“He’s someone I used to date.”
Grant’s face drained.
“When?”
She said nothing.
“Elise.”
“Before you.”
“That’s not an answer.”
Paige looked down.
I hated that she was hearing this.
But Grant had already made our children part of the fallout when he brought a supposed son into their lives before establishing the truth properly.
Elise finally whispered:
“We were together for almost two years.”
“How close to Cody’s conception?”
Silence.
That was the answer.
Grant stepped backward.
“Oh my God.”
Eleanor immediately intervened.
“Relationships overlap. That proves nothing.”
I looked at her.
Nobody else did.
Her desperation was almost frightening.
She had known Cody for less than a day and had already attached her identity to the idea of him carrying the Holloway bloodline.
Grant looked at Margaret’s envelope.
“What is that?”
She handed it to him.
Inside were three copies of gate-security incident logs.
Adam Reeves.
Three dates.
Three times.
Each entry said nearly the same thing.
REQUESTING CONTACT WITH ELISE MERCER / GRANT HOLLOWAY REGARDING PATERNITY OF CODY MERCER.
On the third visit, Adam had left a letter.
Grant opened it.
I watched him read.
Then his hands started shaking.
“What?”
I asked.
He handed the letter to me.
Mr. Holloway,
My name is Adam Reeves.
I understand Elise has told you that you are Cody’s father.
I am asking you not to make any permanent legal or financial decisions until a properly witnessed DNA test is completed.
Elise and I were still seeing each other during the period Cody was conceived.
When she became pregnant, she originally told me there was a strong possibility the baby was mine.
Three months later, she changed her story and told me the dates proved otherwise.
I believed her.
Last year I saw photographs of Cody through a mutual friend.
I contacted Elise again and requested testing.
She refused.
I do not want money from your family.
I do not want publicity.
If Cody is not my son, I will accept that.
If he is, I have a right to know him and he has a right to know me.
I am willing to use any accredited laboratory selected by independent counsel and pay my share of the cost.
Please do not rely on a test I had no opportunity to verify.
Adam Reeves.
I finished reading.
Then looked at Elise.
“You knew he was asking for a test.”
She looked at me with tears in her eyes.
“Yes.”
Grant’s voice was barely controlled.
“And you said nothing.”
“I thought he was trying to cause trouble.”
“He says you told him Cody might be his.”
“That was before I knew the dates.”
“What dates?”
“My doctor—”
“Which doctor?”
She stopped.
Grant laughed once.
There was nothing amused about it.
“Is there anything you told me that doesn’t come with another missing page?”
Elise started crying.
“I didn’t fake being pregnant.”
“No one said you did.”
“I didn’t invent Cody.”
“No.”
“I honestly believed—”
“Did you honestly believe I was the only possible father?”
Silence.
There.
Grant sat down.
Paige looked at him.
For one painful second, my daughter seemed almost sorry for her father.
Then her eyes moved toward the empty place where Cody had been sitting.
I knew what she was thinking.
The same thing I was.
Whatever happened next, Cody’s world was about to change again.
I looked at the original DNA report.
“Grant.”
He did not answer.
“Call the laboratory.”
His eyes lifted.
“What?”
“Now.”
Eleanor frowned.
“At dinner?”
“Yes.”
I pulled my phone out.
“Use the number from their official website, not anything Elise gave you.”
Elise’s face changed.
Grant saw.
“What?”
She immediately shook her head.
“Nothing.”
“Why did your face change?”
“It didn’t.”
Paige said quietly:
“It did.”
Everyone looked at her.
She folded her arms.
“Sorry.”
Then, after a beat:
“Not sorry.”
I almost smiled.
Grant searched the laboratory name.
North River Genetic Diagnostics.
The website looked real.
Professional.
Multiple locations.
He called the main customer-service line.
After navigating a menu, he gave his name, date of birth, and test date.
The woman on the phone asked him to repeat the information.
Then:
“I’m sorry, sir. I’m not finding a case under that name.”
Grant froze.
Elise’s breathing changed.
He put the call on speaker.
“The test was done two months ago.”
“Was it perhaps completed under a legal case number?”
“No.”
“Do you have a report number?”
He read the number from the page.
Typing.
Silence.
Then the woman said:
“Mr. Holloway, that report number format is not one we use.”
Nobody moved.
Grant looked at Elise.
The customer-service representative continued:
“Can you tell me where your sample was collected?”
“My office.”
“By one of our technicians?”
“That’s what I was told.”
“Do you remember the technician’s name?”
“No.”
Another pause.
“Sir, our chain-of-custody paternity tests are collected at approved partner sites or through specifically documented mobile collections. There would be a case in our system before anyone visited.”
Grant went white.
“What are you saying?”
“I’m saying I cannot verify that North River Genetic Diagnostics issued the report you’re describing.”
Eleanor whispered:
“No.”
The woman continued professionally.
“If you believe someone is using our branding on an unauthorized report, please email a copy to our compliance department.”
Grant ended the call.
He stared at the paper.
Then at Elise.
“You forged this?”
“No.”
Her answer came too fast.
“I did not forge anything.”
“Then who did?”
“I used a private service.”
“What private service?”
“A man named Simon handled it.”
“Simon who?”
“I don’t know his last name.”
Grant stood.
“You gave some man you barely know my DNA?”
“I didn’t touch your sample.”
“He came to my office.”
“I arranged the appointment.”
“How?”
“Through someone who helps with private medical testing.”
Paige whispered:
“This is insane.”
Correct.
Eleanor still seemed unwilling to accept what was happening.
“The boy looks like Grant.”
I turned.
“He has blond hair and blue eyes, Eleanor.”
“So do millions of children.”
“He has Holloway eyes.”
“What does that even mean?”
Her face hardened.
“Mallory.”
“No.”
I pointed toward the doorway Cody had left through.
“You were going to rewrite your estate tomorrow because a four-year-old had the eyes you wanted him to have.”
Silence.
“And you removed photographs of three grandchildren you’ve known their entire lives before verifying the one piece of evidence you said made him family.”
Eleanor’s eyes filled.
Paige looked away.
Grant suddenly sat again.
His anger had become something worse.
Fear.
“Mallory.”
I looked.
“What?”
“I need a real test.”
“Yes.”
“Will you help me arrange it?”
That question surprised me.
Not because I had special access.
Because for the first time in six months, he was asking instead of deciding.
I thought.
Then nodded.
“One condition.”
“What?”
“Independent counsel selects the laboratory.”
“Everyone is identified in person.”
“Chain of custody.”
“And Adam is tested too.”
Elise immediately stood.
“No.”
Everyone turned.
She clutched the back of the chair.
“You don’t get to force Adam into this.”
Grant stared at her.
“He asked for it.”
“He doesn’t understand what he’s doing.”
“Apparently he understands more than I did.”
Elise’s mouth closed.
Then Paige spoke.
“Why are you scared?”
Elise looked at her.
My daughter’s voice remained quiet.
“If you really think Dad is Cody’s father, then the new test proves you right.”
Simple.
Children cut through adult architecture better than lawyers.
Elise sat.
Tears began falling.
“I was scared Adam would take him.”
There.
Not:
The test will prove Grant is the father.
I was scared Adam would take him.
Grant closed his eyes.
That sentence changed everything.
Eleanor lowered herself into her chair.
For the first time since Cody arrived, she did not look like a grandmother protecting an heir.
She looked like an old woman realizing she had built an entire future on something she had never verified.
The next morning, her estate attorney was supposed to arrive at ten.
At 8:14, she called and canceled.
Not postponed.
Canceled.
Then Grant arranged the legitimate tests.
North River itself.
Their downtown Cincinnati partner clinic.
Adam agreed immediately.
Elise resisted for six hours.
Then her lawyer apparently explained the practical reality.
If she refused, Adam could petition the court himself.
She consented.
The test was scheduled for Monday.
Grant.
Cody.
Adam.
Three verified samples.
No substitutions.
No private technician.
No assumptions.
And until the results arrived, Eleanor’s silver frame remained empty in the front hallway.
She did not put my daughters’ photograph back.
Not yet.
She also removed Cody’s.
For reasons she called neutrality.
Paige called it cowardice.
I said nothing.
Because by then, a more important question had replaced inheritance.
Who was Cody’s father?
May you like
And what terrified me was no longer the possibility that Grant was.
It was the growing certainty that he wasn’t.
Related Stories
