Plot twist

Chapter 4 - THE SIGNATURE

Judge Barrett unfolded the letter inside the envelope.

The courtroom was completely silent. Even the court reporter had stopped typing, waiting for the judge to speak.

"This is a letter to Daisy," the judge said, scanning the single page of elegant handwriting. "It says she misses her very much, and that she hopes Daisy is doing well in first grade."

The judge looked directly at Gabriel.

"It is signed, 'Love always, Mommy. Sarah Collins.'"

Gabriel stared at the table, his face pale and sweating. "Sarah Collins is a delusional woman who gave up her parental rights years ago," he muttered. "She sends those letters to harass me. I told Penelope she was dead to spare her the drama."

"You took me to a grave!" Penelope shouted, the betrayal twisting her stomach into knots. "You showed me a headstone with her name on it!"

"It was her grandmother's grave!" Gabriel snapped back. "They share the same name! I just didn't correct you when you assumed it was hers! You're so naive, Penelope!"

"Mr. Albright, you are testing my patience," Judge Barrett warned harshly.

She turned her attention back to the letter, flipping it over.

"There's something else inside the envelope," the judge noted.

She reached inside and pulled out a smaller, folded piece of thick paper. She opened it.

The judge's brow furrowed in confusion.

"It’s a cashier’s check," Judge Barrett said. "Made out to the Albright Family Trust. In the amount of ten thousand dollars."

Gabriel’s head snapped up.

"That... that's a mistake," he stammered quickly.

"A mistake?" the judge asked, reading the memo line. "The memo clearly says, 'October Payment.' It appears Ms. Collins has been sending you a significant amount of money."

"She owes me!" Gabriel argued frantically. "Child support! She surrendered custody and agreed to pay support!"

Penelope stared at him in utter disbelief.

Ten thousand dollars a month.

Gabriel had always claimed his high income came from his consulting business. He had bragged about his successful investments. But for five years, while Penelope was raising Daisy, Gabriel had been cashing massive checks from a woman he claimed was dead.

"Your Honor," Penelope’s attorney finally spoke up, stepping forward. "If my client’s husband has been receiving ten thousand dollars a month in undisclosed income, he has committed severe financial fraud during discovery."

"I am well aware of that, counselor," the judge replied coldly.

Gabriel’s lawyer leaned over and whispered fiercely in Gabriel's ear. Gabriel aggressively shook his head.

"Your Honor," Gabriel's lawyer said, standing up. "My client maintains that this money was part of a private, sealed custody agreement with Ms. Collins. It is not a marital asset, and therefore not subject to division."

"I don't care about the money," Penelope interrupted. She didn't care about the checks or the fraud.

She looked at the little girl clutching her stuffed rabbit.

"I care about why a mother would pay ten thousand dollars a month and never try to see her child," Penelope said, looking directly at Gabriel. "What did you do to her, Gabriel?"

Gabriel glared at her with pure hatred. "She gave her up! She didn't want her!"

Daisy sniffled loudly.

"That's a lie," Daisy whispered.

Everyone looked at the six-year-old.

Daisy unzipped the smaller pocket of her blue backpack.

"Mommy said she tried to come see me on my birthday," Daisy said, her voice shaking but clear. "But Daddy told her if she ever came back... he would show the police the paper she signed."

"Daisy, shut your mouth!" Gabriel roared, lunging forward.

The bailiff was there in a flash, slamming his hand onto Gabriel's shoulder and shoving him hard back into his chair.

"One more outburst, Mr. Albright, and you will be placed in handcuffs," the judge warned, her voice deadly calm.

She turned to Daisy. "What paper, sweetheart?"

Daisy reached into the small pocket and pulled out a folded, faded piece of notebook paper.

"This one," Daisy said. "I found it in Daddy's desk when I was looking for crayons. I hid it with my letters."

The bailiff retrieved the folded paper from Daisy and handed it to the judge.

Judge Barrett unfolded it.

She read it in silence.

As she read, the color slowly drained from the judge's face.

She looked up at Gabriel, then down at the paper, her eyes wide with genuine shock.

"Mr. Albright," Judge Barrett said, her voice dropping to a terrifyingly quiet register. "Did you force Sarah Collins to sign a confession stating she was responsible for the fire that burned down your previous home?"

Gabriel stopped breathing.

Penelope grabbed her stomach, a sharp pain radiating through her back.

Three years before Penelope met him, Gabriel's house had burned to the ground. He had told her it was faulty wiring. He had received a massive insurance payout, which he used to start his consulting business.

"She... she was careless with a candle," Gabriel stammered, sweating profusely. "She signed it voluntarily!"

"This isn't a confession to an accident," the judge said, holding the paper up. "This is a confession to arson. You used this to blackmail her, didn't you? You told her if she didn't give you full custody and pay you ten thousand dollars a month, you would turn this over to the police and send her to prison."

Gabriel didn't answer. He couldn't.

He was trapped.

"Bailiff," Judge Barrett ordered. "Call the local precinct. Have two officers dispatched to this courtroom immediately. Mr. Albright is not leaving this building."

May you like

Gabriel panicked.

He shoved his lawyer aside, knocking the chair over, and bolted for the heavy wooden doors at the back of the courtroom.

Related Stories

Other posts