Plot twist

Chapter 8 - THE SECOND BODY

The phone nearly slipped from my hand.

Did you ever wonder what happened to her father?

The words stared back at me, a digital taunt that sent a fresh wave of terror coursing through my veins.

Evelyn was in federal custody. Hannah was likely being arrested right now. So who the hell had sent this email?

I re-read the message.

Claire’s father. Thomas Miller. Detective Cole had told me he was committed to a psychiatric facility two years ago after suffering a breakdown following his daughter's disappearance.

I grabbed my coat and slipped quietly out of the hotel suite, ensuring the door was securely locked behind me. I couldn't leave Lily alone for long, but I needed to make a phone call without waking her.

I walked into the quiet, carpeted hallway and dialed Detective Cole’s number.

"Evans, it’s 6:00 AM," Cole answered, her voice thick with exhaustion. "We just hauled your sister in. She’s singing like a canary. Evelyn had her by the throat financially."

"Cole, I need you to check on Thomas Miller," I demanded, ignoring the update on Hannah. "The father of the girl Evelyn murdered."

There was a heavy pause on the line. "David, I told you. Thomas Miller is in the state psychiatric hospital. He’s been there for two years."

"Have you physically verified that?" I pressed, pacing the hallway. "Have you seen him? Spoken to him?"

"No, but his medical records—"

"Check them again," I interrupted, a sickening feeling twisting in my gut. "I just received an anonymous email. It implied Thomas Miller isn't where we think he is."

Cole didn't argue. I heard the frantic clicking of a keyboard over the phone.

"Okay, pulling up his file," Cole muttered. "Thomas Miller. Admitted to Pineview Psychiatric Care Facility on October 12th, three years ago. Diagnosed with severe schizophrenia and trauma-induced psychosis. Paid for by a private anonymous trust."

"An anonymous trust," I repeated. "Evelyn."

"Wait," Cole said, her typing suddenly stopping. "This doesn't make sense."

"What is it?"

"The records show he was discharged six months ago," Cole said, her voice rising in alarm. "Released into the custody of a primary caregiver."

"Who?" I demanded, though I already knew the answer.

"Meredith Blake," Cole read aloud. "Evelyn's alias."

My blood ran cold. Evelyn hadn't just murdered his daughter and stolen his house. She had gained legal guardianship over a mentally broken man and pulled him out of a secure facility.

"Why would she do that?" I asked, struggling to understand the sociopathic logic.

"Control," Cole theorized grimly. "She liked playing god. Maybe she kept him as a pet. Or maybe she needed a scapegoat if the police ever found Claire's body."

"Where is he now?" I asked.

"I don't know," Cole admitted. "If he was discharged six months ago, he could be anywhere. But if Evelyn was keeping him hidden..."

"The storage unit," I realized, the memory flashing back. "The unit registered in my name. The one where you found Claire's bracelet and the shovel."

"We cleared that unit yesterday, David," Cole said. "It was empty except for the evidence box."

"Did you check the adjacent units?" I pushed. "Evelyn was meticulous. She wouldn't keep a hostage in the same unit where she kept murder weapons."

"I'm dispatching a team back to the storage facility right now," Cole said, her tone shifting back to command mode. "Stay at the hotel, David. Protect your daughter."

She hung up before I could argue.

I walked back into the hotel suite. Lily was still fast asleep, clutching her stuffed rabbit. She looked so peaceful, completely unaware of the monsters circling our lives.

I sat back down in the armchair, my mind racing. Evelyn was a mastermind of manipulation. She had orchestrated my marriage, murdered my wife, abducted a child, and blackmailed my sister.

But who sent the email?

If Evelyn was in jail, she couldn't have sent it. And Hannah was in police custody.

Unless Evelyn had a failsafe. A delayed email scheduled to send automatically if she didn't log in to cancel it. A final, cruel game designed to torture me from behind bars.

Two hours passed in agonizing silence. Lily woke up around 8:00 AM, rubbing her eyes and asking for pancakes. I ordered room service, trying to maintain a facade of normalcy for her sake, though my stomach was tied in knots.

At 9:15 AM, my phone rang. Detective Cole.

"We found him," Cole said immediately, her voice devoid of any professional detachment. She sounded shaken.

"Is he alive?" I asked, gripping the edge of the hotel desk.

"No, David," Cole said softly. "He's been dead for at least five months."

I closed my eyes, letting out a slow, ragged breath. Evelyn had murdered him, too.

"Where did you find him?" I asked.

"In the storage unit directly across from the one registered in your name," Cole explained. "It was rented under the name Sarah Evans."

My dead wife's name. Evelyn had used Sarah's identity to rent the unit where she hid a body. It was a sick, twisted joke.

"But that's not the worst part, David," Cole continued, her voice trembling slightly. "The cause of death wasn't murder. It was a self-inflicted gunshot wound."

I frowned, confused. "He killed himself?"

"We found a suicide note in his pocket," Cole said. "It was typed, but it was signed by Thomas Miller. In it, he confesses to murdering his daughter, Claire. He says the guilt drove him mad, and he couldn't live with it anymore."

The brilliance of Evelyn's plan hit me like a physical blow.

She hadn't just murdered Claire. She had manipulated a grieving, mentally unstable father into believing he was responsible for his own daughter's death. She had tortured him with lies until he broke completely, forced him to write a confession, and then provided him with the weapon to end his own life.

With Thomas Miller dead and a written confession in police custody, the investigation into Claire's death would be closed. Evelyn would walk away completely clean.

"It's a forgery," I said adamantly. "Evelyn forced him to write it."

"We know that, David," Cole assured me. "The timeline doesn't fit. Thomas was in the psychiatric facility when Claire was buried in your backyard. He couldn't have done it. But Evelyn’s defense attorneys are going to use that note to create reasonable doubt. They'll argue Thomas killed Claire, buried her in your yard to frame you, and then killed himself out of guilt."

"And the jury might believe it," I muttered, terrified by the prospect of Evelyn beating the charges.

"There's more," Cole said, hesitating for a moment. "David, the gun Thomas used to kill himself... we ran the serial number."

"And?"

"It's registered to you, David. It's the handgun you reported stolen from your home safe a year ago."

My blood ran cold. Evelyn had stolen my gun before we even met, during the time she had paid off my nanny and had access to my house. She had used my weapon to facilitate a suicide, tying me directly to the crime scene.

"She framed me for everything," I whispered, the sheer scale of her malevolence overwhelming me. "She set it up so if she ever got caught, the evidence would point to me."

"We have Hannah's confession, and we have Evelyn's journals," Cole said firmly. "We aren't going to arrest you, David. We know you're innocent. But this case just became a logistical nightmare for the prosecutors."

I hung up the phone and looked over at Lily, who was happily eating a chocolate chip pancake on the hotel bed.

Evelyn was behind bars, but she was still pulling the strings. She had built a fortress of lies and misdirection designed to protect herself and destroy me.

I needed to find the one piece of evidence she hadn't accounted for. The one mistake she must have made.

I thought back to the hidden cameras. The one in Lily's room. The one in my office.

She locks me up when you leave, Daddy.

Lily had known about the laundry room. She had known about the closet.

I walked over to the bed and sat down next to my daughter.

"Lily, sweetie," I asked gently, stroking her hair. "When the monster locked you in the laundry room... did she ever say anything to you? Did she talk on the phone?"

Lily paused, chewing her pancake thoughtfully. "Sometimes she talked to the magic box."

I frowned. "The magic box? What magic box?"

"The one in the wall," Lily said simply. "She would push buttons and talk to it. She told the box she was going to be a mommy forever."

A magic box in the wall.

A smart home hub. Or a hidden safe.

"Where is the magic box, Lily?" I asked, my heart beginning to race.

"In your office, Daddy," Lily pointed toward the hotel window. "Behind the big picture of you and Mommy."

I stared at my four-year-old daughter.

May you like

Evelyn hadn't just planted a camera in my office. She had installed something else behind the portrait of Sarah and me. Something I had never noticed.

"Finish your pancakes, ladybug," I said, a fierce, determined energy flooding my veins. "We have to go home."

Related Stories

Other posts