Chapter 5 - The Lighter On The Patio

I stared at the silver Zippo lighter resting in my palm. The initials M.C. were engraved elegantly on the front, a gift I had given Matthew on our first anniversary.
The world tilted on its axis.
"Matthew?" I breathed, unable to process the words coming out of my father's mouth. "Dad, that doesn't make any sense. Matthew was at the police station with me. He was just as shocked as I was."
My father let out a dry, humorless laugh. He looked back out at the foggy yard, his hands trembling slightly as they gripped the arms of the patio chair.
"He's a good actor, Jenna," my father said bitterly. "He always was. He came here an hour after you left the station. He had two men with him. Men I didn't recognize."
"What did they do?" I asked, my voice rising in panic.
"They tore the house apart," Dad said, gesturing toward the open backdoor. "They were looking for your mother's passports. When they couldn't find them, Matthew grabbed your mother. He dragged her out the front door right in front of me."
"Why didn't you call the police?!" I screamed, standing up.
"Because he held a gun to her head!" my father shouted back, tears finally breaking through his stoic facade. "He told me if I dialed 911, he would put a bullet in her brain on the front lawn. He told me to stick to the story. Ryan and your mother ran away together. You found out and hired someone to kill them. That's the story, Jenna."
I stumbled backward, hitting the brick wall of the house.
My husband. The man who had driven forty minutes to bring me coffee, the man who had cried at our wedding, had orchestrated a violent kidnapping and framed me for murder.
But why? Why go through all of this?
"The money," I realized aloud. "It was never Ryan stealing the business money. It was Matthew."
"Ryan is dead, Jenna," my father said flatly.
I froze. "What?"
"Before Matthew left," Dad whispered, his eyes dropping to the cold patio stones. "He tossed that lighter to me. He said he used it to burn Ryan's body in the woods near the county line, after they dumped his truck with the blood in it."
A wave of pure nausea washed over me. I turned to the side and retched into the flowerbed, my stomach heaving as the horrific reality settled in.
Matthew had murdered his best friend. He had framed Ryan for the embezzlement, framed my mother for running away with him, and framed me for hiring a hitman to kill them both.
He was tying up every loose end and pinning the entire operation on the people closest to him.
"But why?" I choked out, wiping my mouth with the back of my sleeve. "Why would Matthew do this?"
My father looked at me, a profound sadness in his eyes.
"Because your mother found out about the offshore accounts three weeks ago," Dad said. "She found out Matthew wasn't just losing contracts. He was actively laundering money for a cartel out of Atlanta."
The breath left my lungs.
"A cartel?"
"Yes," Dad nodded heavily. "Matthew's business was a front. He was cleaning their dirty money through fake electrical contracts. When your mother found out, she confronted him. But she didn't go to the police, Jenna."
My father swallowed hard, clearly ashamed of the words he was about to speak.
"She blackmailed him. She demanded fifty thousand dollars in cash to keep her mouth shut."
I remembered the jewelry box full of banded hundred-dollar bills in Ryan's storage unit.
"She put the cash in her jewelry box," I whispered.
"Yes," Dad confirmed. "But Matthew isn't the kind of man you blackmail. He realized she was a liability. He realized Ryan, who did the books, was getting suspicious too. So he planned this entire theatrical production tonight."
It was brilliant in its absolute sociopathy.
Matthew knew about my affair with Ryan. He probably knew about it from day one. He used my infidelity as the perfect smokescreen. He caught us in bed in front of our entire family, creating the perfect motive for a crime of passion.
A humiliated wife snaps. She hires a hitman to kill her cheating best friend and her traitorous mother, taking the stolen money for herself.
It was the perfect frame job.
"We have to go to the police, Dad," I said, stepping toward him, grabbing his arm. "We have the Zippo lighter. We have the storage unit full of evidence proving Ryan was blackmailing Matthew's parents. We can prove Matthew is lying."
My father shook his head, pulling his arm away.
"No, Jenna. We can't."
"What are you talking about?" I demanded, frustration boiling over into rage. "He has Mom!"
"If we go to the police, Matthew will kill her," Dad said, his voice dropping to a terrified whisper. "He told me he wouldn't hurt her if I kept you quiet until the offshore transfers cleared on Monday morning. After that, he said he'd let her go."
"He's lying, Dad!" I screamed. "He already killed Ryan! He's not going to leave a witness alive! If we don't act now, Mom is dead!"
My father stared at me, paralyzed by fear. He wasn't going to help me. He was too broken.
I grabbed the Zippo lighter from his lap.
"Stay here," I said coldly. "If he calls, tell him I'm cooperating. Tell him I'm terrified."
I turned and ran through the trashed house, out the front door, and back into my car.
I slammed the door shut and locked it, my chest heaving as I gripped the steering wheel. I needed to think. I couldn't go to the local police; if Matthew had cartel connections, he likely had cops on his payroll too. Detective Reynolds seemed honest, but I couldn't take the risk.
I needed federal help.
I pulled out my phone and searched for the nearest FBI field office. There was one twenty miles away in downtown Charlotte.
I put the car in drive and sped out of the neighborhood.
The sun was just beginning to rise, casting long, gray shadows across the wet asphalt.
I drove for fifteen minutes, meticulously checking my rearview mirror, paranoid that Matthew's men were following me.
But the road was clear.
I reached the highway on-ramp and merged onto the interstate.
Suddenly, my phone buzzed on the passenger seat.
It was an unknown number.
I hesitated, then hit accept, putting it on speakerphone.
"Hello?" I asked, my voice tight.
"Jenna," a smooth, calm voice replied.
It was Matthew.
"Where is she, Matt?" I demanded, my hands gripping the steering wheel so hard my knuckles popped.
"Your mother is resting," Matthew said pleasantly. "She was quite hysterical earlier, but she's calmed down now."
"If you hurt her, I swear to God—"
"You're not going to swear to anyone, Jenna," Matthew interrupted, his tone shifting from pleasant to lethal. "Because you're currently driving a stolen car."
I frowned, glancing at the dashboard. "This is my car."
"No, it's not," Matthew corrected. "Your car was reported stolen by me two hours ago. Along with the eighty-six thousand dollars in cash I claimed was in the trunk."
My stomach dropped.
"I'm looking at your GPS tracker right now, sweetie," Matthew continued, his voice dripping with arrogance. "You're heading toward the city. Probably to the FBI building, right? Smart girl. But you're not going to make it."
May you like
"You can't stop me, Matt," I said, pressing the accelerator down harder.
"I don't have to," Matthew laughed softly. "I just had to make a phone call. Check your rearview mirror, Jenna. And tell the state troopers I said hello."