Plot twist

Chapter 7 - The Second DNA Test

The heavy metal safety deposit box sat on the leather seat of the town car like a live grenade.

Grant stared at it, the unknown number’s text message burning in his mind. Look at the medical records.

"Back to the estate, Owen," Grant ordered, his voice hollow.

He didn't open the medical file during the drive. He couldn't. His hands were shaking too badly. The revelation that Eleanor hadn't just faked their daughter's death out of selfishness, but supposedly out of fear, completely upended his understanding of the woman he had married.

He had never struck Eleanor. He had never threatened her. He was demanding, yes. Workaholic, absolutely. But a murderer?

When they arrived at Whitmore House, the police cruisers were gone. The estate was eerily quiet, the grand facade hiding the rot that had festered beneath it for three decades.

Grant carried the metal box straight into his library and locked the heavy oak doors behind him.

He sat at his mahogany desk and finally reached into the box, pulling out the thick stack of yellowing medical files.

They were original documents from St. Jude's Medical Center. Birth certificates, blood typing, footprints.

But tucked in the very middle of the stack was a sterile, white envelope bearing the logo of a private, high-end genetics laboratory in Switzerland.

Grant frowned. The date on the envelope was three months before Eleanor gave birth.

He broke the seal and pulled out the crisp, official document.

It was a prenatal paternity test. Conducted via amniocentesis.

Grant scanned the clinical jargon until his eyes locked onto the final conclusion printed in bold, black ink.

Probability of Paternity (Grant Whitmore): 0.00%

The air vanished from the library.

Grant gripped the edge of the desk so hard the wood groaned in protest.

0.00%.

Grace wasn't his daughter.

Eleanor had been having an affair. She had gotten pregnant by another man.

The horrifying brilliance of Eleanor's plan suddenly snapped into crystal-clear focus. She hadn't faked the baby's death because she didn't want to be a mother. She faked the death because she knew Grant would eventually realize the child wasn't his.

If Grant discovered the affair and the illegitimate child, he wouldn't have just divorced her. With his wealth and power, he would have destroyed her entirely. He would have left her with nothing, ruined her reputation, and ensured she never saw a dime of the Whitmore fortune.

Eleanor paid Sarah Miller fifty thousand dollars to swap the baby not to escape motherhood, but to escape the consequences of her own infidelity.

"My god," Grant whispered into the empty room, tears of absolute devastation spilling down his cheeks.

He had spent twenty-six years grieving a daughter that had never belonged to him in the first place. He had spent the last twenty-four hours desperately chasing a ghost, hoping for a miracle, only to uncover the ultimate betrayal.

But if Grant wasn't the father, who was?

He flipped to the second page of the genetics report.

Eleanor hadn't just tested Grant's DNA against the baby. She had tested the biological father's DNA as well, likely to confirm her suspicions before executing the swap.

Probability of Paternity (Arthur Shaw): 99.9%

Grant stopped breathing.

Arthur Shaw.

His sister Vivian's husband.

Eleanor had been sleeping with her own brother-in-law.

The pieces fell together with sickening, catastrophic precision. Vivian hadn't called the police this morning because she felt guilty. Vivian had called the police because she found out Grace was alive, and she needed to ensure the scandal erupted before Grant could figure out the truth on his own.

Vivian knew.

Grant stood up, the chair crashing backward onto the floor.

He stormed out of the library and marched up the grand staircase to the east wing guest suites, where Vivian had retreated after the police left.

He didn't knock. He kicked the heavy wooden door open with such force the handle embedded itself in the drywall.

Vivian shrieked, dropping a crystal glass of wine onto the plush carpet. She was frantically packing a designer suitcase on the bed.

"You knew!" Grant roared, advancing on her like a predator.

Vivian scrambled backward, her aristocratic mask entirely shattered, revealing the terrified, pathetic woman underneath.

"Grant, please!" Vivian cried, holding up her hands.

"Arthur is the father!" Grant screamed, grabbing her by the shoulders and slamming her hard against the closet door. "My wife was sleeping with your husband, and you knew about it!"

"I didn't know until she was already dying!" Vivian sobbed hysterically, completely breaking down. "I swear to God, Grant! Eleanor confessed it to me on her deathbed! She told me Arthur was the father, and she told me Sarah Miller had kept the baby!"

"So you poisoned Sarah Miller to protect Arthur?!" Grant demanded, shaking her violently.

"No!" Vivian wailed. "Eleanor poisoned Sarah! Sarah was blackmailing her, threatening to expose the affair to you! Eleanor killed her to protect the secret!"

Grant stepped back, disgusted, dropping his hands from her shoulders.

"If you knew all this," Grant said, his voice dropping to a lethal, terrifying calm, "why did you call the police this morning? Why expose the incubator?"

Vivian sank to the floor, weeping into her hands.

"Because Arthur has been secretly funding Grace for the last twelve years," Vivian confessed, the truth finally spilling out like toxic sludge.

Grant frowned. "Arthur knew Grace was alive?"

"Arthur is the one who found her after Sarah died," Vivian sobbed. "He’s been paying her rent anonymously. He’s been watching her. And when you came home yesterday ranting about the sapphire necklace... Arthur panicked. He knew you would dig until you found the truth."

Vivian looked up at him, her eyes wide with terror.

"Arthur told me he was going to hire men to make sure you had a 'fatal accident' before you could find Grace and run the DNA test," Vivian whimpered. "I called the police this morning and told them about the wall to create a massive scandal, hoping the police presence would keep you safe at the house!"

Before Grant could process the fact that his own brother-in-law had just put a hit out on him, his cell phone rang loudly in his pocket.

It wasn't a text message this time. It was a phone call.

He pulled it out. The caller ID read Arthur Shaw.

Grant stared at the screen, then answered it, putting it on speakerphone for Vivian to hear.

"Hello, Arthur," Grant said smoothly.

"Grant," Arthur's voice replied, sounding unnervingly calm. "I assume Vivian has told you everything by now."

"She has," Grant confirmed.

"Good. It saves time," Arthur said. "I also assume you've read the letter Sarah Miller left in the safety deposit box?"

"I have."

"Excellent," Arthur chuckled, a cold, arrogant sound. "Sarah was always so incredibly useful. Even from beyond the grave."

May you like

"What do you want, Arthur?"

"I want my daughter," Arthur said, the humor vanishing from his voice entirely. "And since Grace is currently sitting in the passenger seat of my car, holding a gun to my head because she thinks you're coming to kill her... I suggest you meet me at the old shipyard. Alone."

Related Stories

Other posts