Chapter 5 - The Blue Pills in the Cabinet

The journal slipped from my fingers, landing on the plush hotel carpet with a soft thud.
Doubled the dosage.
My heart hammered a frantic, terrifying rhythm against my ribs. I had been swallowing those pills every morning like an obedient, trusting wife. Over the last month, I had been feeling increasingly dizzy, my heart racing at odd hours, my nose bleeding in the shower. Luke had kissed my forehead and told me it was just stress.
He was slowly poisoning me to collect a life insurance payout before the divorce went through. The affair, the public shaming—it was all a massive, theatrical distraction to establish a narrative.
A disgraced, depressed wife takes her own life out of shame after being caught cheating.
It was the perfect murder.
“What did you read?” Marlene demanded, taking a step toward me, her eyes narrowing.
“Nothing,” I lied, my voice shaking so badly I could barely form the word.
I didn't wait for her to question me further. I spun around and bolted out of the hotel room, sprinting down the hallway and slamming my hand against the elevator button.
I had to get to the house. I had to get those pills before Luke threw them away. Without the pills, I had no proof. It would be my word—the word of a publicly disgraced cheater—against a decorated firefighter.
I drove back to our house like a woman possessed, breaking every speed limit.
When I turned onto our quiet, tree-lined street, I killed my headlights.
A sleek white van was parked in my driveway. The logo on the side read: Precision Locksmiths.
Luke was already changing the locks.
I parked two houses down, slipping out of my car and creeping through the shadows of the neighboring yards. The rain had started again, cold and biting, masking the sound of my footsteps in the wet grass.
I crept around to the back of our house, crouching near the basement window. We had a small, rusted window well hidden behind the hydrangeas that Luke had complained about fixing for three years.
I prayed he hadn't fixed it today.
I pulled hard on the rusted metal frame. With a horrible, scraping groan, the window popped open.
I squeezed through the narrow opening, dropping into the pitch-black basement, landing hard on my shoulder.
I bit my lip to stifle a scream.
Above me, I heard the heavy thud of footsteps walking across the kitchen floor.
I crept silently up the basement stairs, cracking the door just an inch to peer into the kitchen.
Luke was standing at the counter. But he wasn't alone.
Sitting on a barstool, nursing a beer, was my older brother, Eli.
“I appreciate you coming over, man,” Luke said, his voice thick with a fake, sorrowful exhaustion. “I just... I can't be alone tonight. After what she did.”
Eli shook his head, looking completely disgusted. “I’m done with her, Luke. I swear to God. Dad is absolutely devastated. We all thought she was an angel, and she’s pulling this trash in your own bed.”
Tears burned my eyes. My own brother was sitting in my kitchen, comforting the man who was actively trying to murder me.
“I need a favor, Eli,” Luke said, pulling a thick, white envelope from his jacket pocket and sliding it across the counter.
“What’s this?” Eli asked.
“That’s ten thousand dollars in cash,” Luke said smoothly. “I need you to take Brooke’s car tomorrow and sell it to a scrap yard I know out in Tacoma. No questions asked. I don't want anything of hers left on this property.”
Eli hesitated, staring at the envelope.
My brother’s business had gone bankrupt six months ago. He was drowning in debt. I knew how badly he needed that money.
Eli reached out and took the envelope. “Consider it done. Thanks, man. You’ve been more of a brother to me than she ever was.”
I pressed my hand over my mouth to quiet the sob ripping through my throat.
“You’re family, Eli,” Luke smiled warmly. “Always.”
I couldn't stay and listen to anymore. I slipped away from the door and crept silently up the back staircase toward our master bathroom.
The house was dark. I reached the bathroom and opened the medicine cabinet.
My heart dropped into my stomach.
The orange prescription bottle that usually held the blue pills was completely gone. The shelf was empty.
I frantically tore through the drawers, tossing makeup and toothpaste onto the floor. Nothing. He had already scrubbed the evidence.
Suddenly, the floorboard creaked in the hallway directly behind me.
I froze, terrified to breathe.
“Looking for these?”
I slowly turned around.
May you like
Luke was standing in the doorway of the bathroom. In his hand, he held a small, clear plastic bag filled with the lethal blue pills.
In his other hand, he held a heavy, iron fireplace poker.