Plot twist

Chapter 2 - THE THIRD NOTE WAS WRONG

The third note was wrong.

Not badly wrong.

Just a faint, uneven sound that most people in the theater would never have noticed.

But Sofia Marchetti knew that sound.

She had heard it thousands of times.

In her childhood bedroom.

In empty rehearsal halls.

And once, on the morning of her wedding, when her hands had trembled so badly she could barely hold the bow.

Now, sitting alone in the twelfth row of a private concert hall, Sofia slowly lifted one hand from her pregnant stomach.

She leaned forward.

Onstage, a beautiful young woman was playing a violin beneath a single golden spotlight.

The instrument had dark reddish wood.

A slightly worn chin rest.

And a small scratch near the lower edge.

Sofia knew that scratch.

She had made it herself when she was seventeen.

Her throat tightened.

Because the violin belonged to her.

And the woman playing it was her husband's mistress.

For several seconds, Sofia forgot to breathe.

Then she looked toward the front row.

Her husband was sitting there.

Lorenzo Marchetti.

Thirty-two years old.

Tall, heavily muscular, with black tattoos covering both powerful arms beneath his tailored jacket.

One of the most feared mafia bosses in Chicago.

And the man who had promised Sofia, three years earlier, that he would never ask her to give up the only thing she had loved before him.

Music.

He was watching the violinist with a smile Sofia hadn't seen directed toward her in months.

A small smile.

Proud.

Almost tender.

Then the woman finished playing.

The audience applauded.

Lorenzo stood first.

And Sofia felt something inside her go very still.

***

Before she became Mrs. Marchetti, Sofia Bellini had been a violinist.

Not famous.

Not wealthy.

But good enough to play with a small chamber orchestra while studying at the conservatory.

She was twenty-four when she met Lorenzo.

He attended a private performance at a theater owned by one of his business associates.

Sofia remembered noticing him because everyone else seemed afraid to sit near him.

He sat alone.

His black tattoos disappeared beneath his shirt sleeves.

He looked completely out of place among the elderly couples and music teachers.

After the performance, he waited beside the stage door.

“You were incredible,” he told her.

Sofia laughed.

“You looked bored during the second movement.”

He smiled.

“I didn't understand the second movement.”

“Then why did you come?”

Lorenzo hesitated.

“Because my mother used to listen to this kind of music.”

Something softened in his expression.

“She died when I was nineteen.”

Sofia stopped smiling.

“I'm sorry.”

He shrugged.

But she could tell the subject hurt him.

So she asked whether he wanted to hear the piece again.

Without the orchestra.

Just the violin.

He nodded.

She played for him in the empty theater.

When she finished, Lorenzo was crying.

He looked embarrassed.

Sofia pretended not to notice.

That was how they began.

Three years later, they were married.

When Sofia discovered she was pregnant, Lorenzo bought a beautiful mansion overlooking the lake.

He filled the nursery with expensive furniture.

Hired additional household staff.

And promised their daughter would never want for anything.

Sofia was happy.

But she missed performing.

At twenty-eight weeks pregnant, she had stopped traveling with the orchestra.

She still practiced at home.

Usually in the mornings, when the house was quiet.

Her violin rested in its old brown case beside the music-room window.

It had belonged to her mother.

A woman who had worked double shifts at a bakery to pay for Sofia's lessons.

The violin wasn't particularly valuable.

Lorenzo once offered to replace it with an instrument worth more than their first apartment.

Sofia refused.

“My mother bought this when I was fourteen.”

He laughed.

“Baby, I can get you something better.”

She shook her head.

“You can buy a more expensive violin. You can't buy me another mother.”

Lorenzo kissed her forehead.

And never mentioned replacing it again.

At least, not to Sofia.

***

The first time the violin disappeared, she assumed the housekeeper had moved it.

She was six months pregnant.

Her ankles had started swelling by evening.

And she'd been spending more time resting than practicing.

One Tuesday morning, she walked into the music room.

The case was gone.

She checked the cabinet.

The bench.

The storage closet.

Nothing.

She asked the housekeeper, Nina, whether she'd seen it.

The young woman shook her head.

“No, ma'am.”

Sofia frowned.

“That's strange.”

Nina hesitated.

Then said something Sofia would remember later.

“Mr. Marchetti was in here on Sunday.”

Sofia looked up.

“Was he?”

“Yes, ma'am. He asked me to open the cabinet.”

Sofia smiled faintly.

“Perhaps he moved it somewhere safe.”

She called Lorenzo.

He answered after several rings.

“Everything okay?”

“Yes. Have you seen my violin?”

A pause.

Then:

“I had it put away.”

Sofia frowned.

“Where?”

“Somewhere it won't get damaged.”

“I was going to practice.”

“Sweetheart, you need to rest.”

She looked toward the empty corner.

“Lorenzo, playing doesn't hurt me.”

He sighed.

“Can we talk about this later? I'm busy.”

The call ended.

Sofia stood in the music room for several minutes.

Then returned upstairs.

She was annoyed.

But she wasn't frightened.

Not yet.

A week later, she asked again.

Lorenzo told her the instrument was being cleaned.

Two weeks after that, he said the repairman was waiting for a replacement part.

By then, Sofia had begun to suspect he was lying.

But she didn't understand why.

Until the concert.

***

The invitation came from her old music teacher.

Mrs. Alden.

A seventy-year-old woman who had taught Sofia since she was sixteen.

She called on Thursday afternoon.

“Sofia, darling, are you coming tomorrow?”

Sofia was sitting beside the nursery window.

“Coming where?”

“The private recital.”

Sofia hesitated.

“I didn't know there was one.”

Mrs. Alden sounded surprised.

“Your husband's foundation is sponsoring a young violinist. I assumed you'd be attending.”

Sofia looked toward the hallway.

Lorenzo hadn't mentioned it.

“Who is performing?”

“A young woman named Gianna Ricci.”

The name was unfamiliar.

But something about it troubled Sofia.

She had heard Lorenzo say it once.

Late at night.

When he thought she was asleep.

Sofia asked where the concert would be held.

Mrs. Alden told her.

Then added:

“You should come, sweetheart. I think hearing live music again would be good for you.”

Sofia smiled.

“I'd love to.”

She didn't tell Lorenzo.

Not because she wanted to catch him doing something wrong.

Because she was tired of asking permission to enjoy something that had been part of her life long before she married him.

Friday evening, she arrived shortly before the performance began.

A young usher helped her find a seat.

She settled carefully into the chair.

Rested one hand beneath her stomach.

And waited for the music.

Then Gianna walked onto the stage.

Sofia recognized her.

Not immediately.

But after a few seconds.

She'd seen the young woman leaving Lorenzo's office one evening.

Gianna was twenty-five.

Beautiful.

With dark hair and a confident smile.

Lorenzo had introduced her as someone helping arrange private entertainment for his charity events.

Sofia hadn't questioned it.

Now Gianna stood beneath the spotlight.

Holding Sofia's violin.

The first note was beautiful.

The second was clear.

The third carried that familiar uneven sound.

And Sofia knew.

There was no possibility of mistake.

It was her mother's violin.

The one she'd been told was being repaired.

The one Lorenzo had apparently placed in another woman's hands.

Sofia sat motionless through the entire performance.

At one point, her daughter kicked.

She placed a hand against her stomach.

And whispered:

“It's okay, sweetheart.”

She wasn't sure whether she was comforting the baby.

Or herself.

***

After the applause ended, Sofia remained seated.

The audience began leaving.

She watched Lorenzo approach the stage.

Gianna stepped down to meet him.

He touched her cheek.

Quickly.

Almost casually.

Then she leaned forward and kissed him.

Not on the cheek.

On the mouth.

Sofia looked away.

She had suspected the affair for weeks.

The late evenings.

The unexplained trips.

The unfamiliar perfume on his shirts.

But suspicion had allowed her to keep hoping.

Hope was harder now.

She waited until the theater was nearly empty.

Then stood.

Slowly.

Her back ached.

The baby shifted beneath her ribs.

She walked toward the stage.

Lorenzo saw her first.

His smile disappeared.

“Sofia?”

Gianna turned.

For several seconds, nobody moved.

Then Lorenzo approached.

“Baby, what are you doing here?”

Sofia looked past him.

At the violin resting inside its open case.

“I came to hear the music.”

He glanced toward Gianna.

Then back at his wife.

“You should've told me.”

Sofia nodded.

“Yes.”

He seemed relieved that she wasn't angry.

Then she asked:

“Why does she have my mother's violin?”

Lorenzo stopped.

Gianna looked at him.

“Your mother's?”

Sofia watched the young woman's face.

The surprise appeared genuine.

Lorenzo rubbed a hand across his jaw.

“Sofia, it's just an instrument.”

For a moment, she thought she'd misheard him.

“Just an instrument?”

“I thought it should be used instead of sitting in a case.”

Sofia looked at the violin.

The worn wood.

The tiny scratch.

The faded lining of the old brown case.

Then she turned back to her husband.

“Did you give it to her?”

Lorenzo hesitated.

“I loaned it to her.”

Gianna stepped forward.

“No.”

Both looked at her.

She swallowed.

“You told me it was a gift.”

Sofia felt her chest tighten.

Lorenzo closed his eyes.

“Gianna.”

The young woman looked confused.

“You said you bought it from a private collector.”

Sofia stared at him.

He said nothing.

Gianna continued.

“You told me nobody else had ever played it.”

The silence grew unbearable.

Sofia remembered being fourteen.

Her mother standing in their little kitchen.

Opening a battered brown case on the table.

She had saved for nearly two years to buy that violin.

Sofia had cried when she saw it.

Her mother laughed.

“Don't cry, sweetheart. Play something.”

Now, fourteen years later, another woman had been told the instrument was hers.

By the man Sofia had trusted with everything.

“Lorenzo,” Sofia whispered, “why?”

He stepped closer.

“Baby, I was going to tell you.”

“When?”

He looked away.

She waited.

Then he said:

“Gianna had an important performance. She needed a better instrument.”

Sofia stared at him.

“She needed mine?”

“It wasn't being used.”

The words were quiet.

Almost reasonable.

And that made them worse.

Sofia looked at her stomach.

Then back at him.

“I stopped performing because I'm carrying our daughter. I didn't stop being a musician.”

Lorenzo's expression changed.

“Sofia, I didn't mean—”

“You didn't ask.”

He swallowed.

“You didn't even tell me.”

Gianna slowly lowered herself onto a nearby chair.

She looked sick.

“I didn't know, Sofia.”

Sofia turned toward her.

“Did you know he was married?”

Gianna hesitated.

Then nodded.

“Yes.”

“Did you know I was pregnant?”

Another nod.

“Yes.”

Sofia took a breath.

“Then you knew enough to understand that this would hurt me.”

Gianna lowered her head.

Tears slipped down her cheeks.

“I know.”

Sofia looked away.

She wasn't ready to forgive either of them.

But she was tired of standing there while Lorenzo tried to explain why taking something that belonged to her had somehow been reasonable.

She walked toward the stage.

Lorenzo followed.

“Baby, I'll buy you another violin.”

Sofia stopped.

There it was.

The answer he'd offered years earlier.

As though every loss had a price.

She turned around.

“You still don't understand what you took.”

His expression tightened.

“I said I was sorry.”

She nodded.

“I heard you.”

Then she approached the open case.

Her fingers touched the worn wood.

She carefully lifted the instrument.

Rested it beneath her chin.

For several seconds, she stood completely still.

Then she played.

Only a few notes.

A melody her mother used to hum while closing the bakery at night.

The sound filled the empty theater.

Soft.

Imperfect.

Familiar.

On the third note, the violin made its little uneven sound.

Sofia smiled through tears.

There it was.

The same flaw she'd known since childhood.

The sound of home.

When she finished, she lowered the instrument.

Lorenzo was crying.

She noticed.

But this time, she didn't walk over to comfort him.

Gianna stood nearby.

Silent.

Sofia placed the violin carefully back inside its case.

Closed the lid.

Then turned toward her husband.

“I'm taking this home.”

Lorenzo nodded immediately.

“Of course.”

She looked at him for a long moment.

“Not to your house.”

His face changed.

“Sofia?”

She rested one hand against her stomach.

“I'm going to stay with my aunt for a while.”

He stepped forward.

“Please. We can work through this.”

Sofia's eyes filled again.

“Maybe.”

He reached for her hand.

She didn't take it.

“But you don't get to decide that tonight.”

For the first time since she'd met him, Lorenzo looked genuinely uncertain.

Not angry.

Not commanding.

Just frightened.

Sofia picked up the violin case.

It was lighter than she'd remembered.

Or perhaps she'd spent so many months carrying other things that she'd forgotten what it felt like to hold something that belonged entirely to her.

She walked toward the aisle.

Then stopped.

“Lorenzo.”

He looked up immediately.

She swallowed.

“When our daughter is old enough to love something as much as I love music, promise me you'll never make her feel that it stops belonging to her just because she needs to put it down for a while.”

Lorenzo covered his mouth.

He couldn't answer.

Sofia waited.

Then nodded once.

And walked away.

At the theater doors, Mrs. Alden was waiting.

Her old teacher had heard the final few notes.

She looked at the violin case.

Then at Sofia's face.

“Oh, sweetheart.”

Sofia started crying.

Mrs. Alden wrapped her arms around her.

For a moment, Sofia was fourteen again.

Standing in a rehearsal room.

Terrified she'd played something wrong.

Waiting for someone to tell her she could try again.

Her teacher gently touched her shoulder.

“Are you coming back to play after the baby?”

Sofia looked down at the case.

Then rested her free hand against her stomach.

For months, she'd imagined returning to the stage.

But she'd never spoken about it aloud.

Not to Lorenzo.

Not to anyone.

Now she looked toward the empty theater behind her.

Where the man she loved was standing with the woman he'd chosen to share his secrets.

And answered quietly:

“Yes.”

A pause.

May you like

Then:

“But next time, I want to be the one deciding when the music starts.”

Related Stories

Other posts