Plot twist

Chapter 4 - THE LIE HE COULDN'T EXPLAIN

“Never supposed to know?”

I repeated Damian's words because I couldn't believe I'd heard them correctly.

He looked at me.

“Nicole, that came out wrong.”

Caroline laughed sharply.

“How exactly was it supposed to come out?”

Evelyn stood between us, her face almost colorless.

“Take us inside,” she said.

Damian hesitated.

“I thought you wanted to leave.”

“I do. But I'm not leaving without understanding what you've done.”

She walked past him.

Nobody tried to stop her.

We followed her into the house.

I had walked through that beautiful entrance barely three hours earlier, imagining I might someday belong there.

Now I felt sick looking at the marble floors.

Evelyn led us into the dining room.

She didn't sit at the head of the table.

Instead, she chose an ordinary chair beside Caroline.

Then she pointed to the other side.

“Sit down, Damian.”

He obeyed.

I remained near the doorway.

Evelyn looked at me.

“You can stay. Apparently, your name is part of this.”

I sat.

Damian loosened his collar.

“The property was supposed to be temporary collateral.”

Evelyn stared at him.

“For what?”

“A business obligation.”

“What business?”

He looked at Caroline.

“It's complicated.”

Evelyn's voice became very quiet.

“My mother worked double shifts at a hospital to pay for that house.”

Damian lowered his eyes.

“She raised us there after our father left. She fixed the plumbing herself when she couldn't afford a contractor.”

Caroline wiped her face.

“And Evelyn spent every Christmas Eve there until she married you.”

Damian said nothing.

Evelyn leaned forward.

“Don't tell me her home is complicated.”

He swallowed.

“A shipment went missing. Someone I trusted created a problem. I needed to guarantee repayment.”

I had known Damian was involved in organized crime.

I'd simply refused to think about what that meant.

Now I was watching his wife pay for it with her mother's memories.

“Who arranged the paperwork?” Caroline asked.

“Dominic Cole.”

I recognized the name.

Dominic was Damian's business manager and one of the few men who could interrupt him without being punished for it.

“Did Dominic have permission to use my house?” Evelyn asked.

Damian hesitated.

“I authorized a temporary agreement.”

“And my signature?”

“I didn't sign your name.”

“That wasn't my question.”

His jaw tightened.

“I was told everything could be handled without bothering you.”

Evelyn looked almost amused.

“Without bothering me?”

Then she laughed.

It was an exhausted, terrible sound.

“You've spent months telling me not to worry about stress because of the baby. Was that your excuse for keeping me ignorant?”

“I wanted to protect you.”

“From what?”

He didn't answer.

She pointed toward the ceiling.

“From knowing another woman was hiding in my daughter's nursery?”

I lowered my eyes.

Damian looked at me.

“Nicole, you need to understand that the property arrangement was separate from us.”

“Was it?”

He stared.

I continued.

“You asked for my license. You had me sign papers at dinner.”

Evelyn turned toward me.

“When?”

“About two months ago.”

Damian rubbed his forehead.

“It was supposed to be an ordinary rental arrangement.”

“Then why is my name on her mother's house?”

His expression changed.

“Dominic handled it.”

Caroline leaned forward.

“Did Dominic also choose Nicole as your girlfriend?”

The room went silent.

It was such a strange question that I almost laughed.

But Damian didn't.

He looked at Caroline.

“Watch what you're suggesting.”

She sat back.

“I haven't suggested anything. I asked.”

Evelyn had been studying his face.

Now she looked at me.

“How did you meet him?”

“At a restaurant in Manhattan.”

“Which restaurant?”

“Bellamy's.”

Damian pushed his chair back.

“This is becoming ridiculous.”

Evelyn didn't look at him.

“Who introduced you?”

“Nobody. He came in while I was working.”

I'd been helping with reservations that evening because the restaurant was short-staffed.

Damian had stayed after closing.

He'd made me laugh.

He'd asked about my life.

I'd felt seen.

Caroline exchanged a glance with Evelyn.

“What?” I asked.

Evelyn spoke slowly.

“Bellamy's belongs to one of Damian's companies.”

I looked at him.

He didn't deny it.

He'd told me he was simply a regular customer.

That he'd wandered in because he liked the atmosphere.

I remembered how charming that had seemed.

“Did you already know who I was?” I asked.

“Nicole—”

“Before we met.”

He stood.

“I'm not doing this tonight.”

Evelyn stood too.

“You don't get to choose when the truth becomes inconvenient.”

He looked at his pregnant wife.

Something in his expression softened.

“Evie, you need rest.”

“Stop using my pregnancy to end conversations.”

He lowered his head.

For a moment, I saw the man who had smiled when his daughter kicked.

Then he looked away again.

Evelyn gathered the papers.

“I want everything stopped.”

“I'll speak to Dominic.”

“No,” she said. “I want you to stop it.”

Damian remained silent.

Caroline noticed.

“Can you?”

He reached for the back of his chair.

His fingers tightened around the wood.

“I need time.”

“How much?” Evelyn asked.

He looked toward the clock.

Almost two in the morning.

Then he finally answered.

May you like

“By Monday morning, that house may not belong to you anymore.”

---

Related Stories

Other posts