Plot twist

Chapter 3 - THE NAME ERASED FROM THE PROGRAM

“You were there?”

Adrien asked.

Bellini nodded.

Elena forgot the violin was still in her hands.

The old investor looked toward the doorway.

“Perhaps your guests should go.”

Nobody objected.

The business dinner that had supposedly determined the future of Adrien’s European expansion ended twenty-three minutes later.

No agreements signed.

No final toast.

No discussion of ports.

Elena remained near the fireplace while coats were collected.

She felt strangely responsible.

Then reminded herself she had not created whatever truth Bellini had carried into the house.

She had only played forty-seven measures.

When the last guest left, Adrien turned toward Bellini.

“Talk.”

Bellini almost smiled.

“You sound exactly like Dominic.”

Adrien’s face changed.

Dominic Vale.

His father.

Dead six years.

“You knew my mother’s composition?”

“Yes.”

“Why didn’t you tell me?”

“Because until tonight I believed the original manuscript had been destroyed.”

Elena looked at him.

“My father never had an original.”

Bellini’s eyes moved to her.

“Are you certain?”

“Yes.”

“He taught it from memory?”

“Yes.”

That surprised him.

Bellini sat.

Elena remained standing.

Adrien noticed.

“Sit.”

She looked at him.

His jaw tightened.

Then he corrected himself.

“Please.”

Better.

Elena sat.

Bellini began.

Lucia Vale had been a serious violinist before marrying Dominic.

Not a wealthy woman amusing herself with music.

A conservatory graduate.

A composer.

A performer.

Carlo Moretti had been her accompanist first, then copyist and arranger.

“They worked together for almost fourteen years.”

Bellini said.

Elena stared.

“My father never talked about her.”

“He wouldn’t.”

“Why?”

Bellini looked at Adrien.

“Dominic made sure of that.”

Lucia continued composing after marriage, but Dominic disliked public performance.

Not because he hated music.

Because the Vale family was entering politics, shipping, and finance.

He wanted a wife whose public image supported his.

Lucia could chair foundations.

Host benefits.

Play privately.

But touring?

Rehearsing late with musicians?

Newspapers photographing her with men Dominic did not control?

No.

“He didn’t physically lock her in a room.”

Bellini said.

“He simply made every independent choice expensive.”

Elena thought about her father’s sentence.

Interrupted by power.

Adrien’s face remained unreadable.

“What did Carlo do?”

“Helped her work.”

Secretly at times.

Openly at others.

Carlo copied scores.

Adjusted difficult passages.

Arranged pieces for chamber ensembles.

He never claimed Lucia’s authorship.

“But some published programs listed him.”

Bellini continued.

“As arranger.”

“Not the programs in our archive.”

Adrien said.

“No.”

Bellini reached into his coat.

He carried no magical evidence.

Only a phone.

He opened an old scanned program from his private collection.

LUCIANA VALE — THREE MINIATURES FOR VIOLIN

Below:

Arrangements prepared with Carlo Moretti.

Elena covered her mouth.

Her father’s name.

Printed.

Legitimate.

Adrien stared.

“What year?”

“Twenty-two years ago.”

Two years before Lucia died.

Then Bellini showed another.

Same works.

Later reprint.

Carlo’s name gone.

“Who changed it?”

Adrien asked.

“Vale Arts Foundation.”

Bellini looked ashamed.

“I noticed.”

“And said nothing.”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“My firm was negotiating with Dominic.”

Bellini did not pretend nobility.

“European shipping access. Hundreds of millions at stake. Carlo was a music arranger I barely knew. Dominic was a business partner.”

Elena laughed quietly.

“So everyone had a practical reason.”

Bellini accepted the blow.

“Yes.”

Then Adrien looked at Elena.

“The song.”

She swallowed.

“My father called it After Rain.”

Bellini’s eyes widened.

“That was Lucia’s working title.”

Adrien stood.

“How did he know?”

Elena remembered something.

A black folder.

Her father’s handwriting.

A single sentence from years ago.

“Wait.”

She reached for her purse.

Nothing.

Her phone was upstairs with her uniform.

“I have a photograph at home.”

“Of what?”

“My father’s old music cabinet.”

Adrien frowned.

“You photographed it?”

“When my mother got sick.”

There it was.

The reason the memories hurt.

Rosa Moretti had developed ovarian cancer five years earlier.

Treatment consumed every reserve the family had.

Elena quit the chamber orchestra where she had been freelancing.

Then sold her violin.

“What photograph?”

Bellini asked.

“My father’s cabinet before I emptied the apartment.”

Her voice became quieter.

“There was a program pinned inside the door.”

Elena had taken a picture because she could not keep everything.

Adrien asked:

“Where is the violin now?”

She looked at him.

“That wasn’t part of the audition.”

He almost reacted.

Then remembered.

“The twelve thousand.”

“Yes.”

“It’s for the violin.”

Elena looked down.

“The dealer who bought it from me called last week. He’s retiring. Someone offered to buy it before his inventory goes to auction.”

“You want it back.”

“Yes.”

“How much did you sell it for?”

“Nine thousand.”

“And now twelve.”

“Yes.”

Adrien’s expression tightened.

“I’ll pay—”

“No.”

The answer was immediate.

“I performed for twelve thousand dollars. You owe me twelve thousand dollars.”

“Elena—”

“If you give me anything beyond what I earned, I won’t take it.”

Bellini looked between them.

Adrien became very quiet.

Then:

“Fine.”

She had never heard a billionaire sound so irritated by being prevented from giving someone money.

Bellini almost smiled.

Adrien did not.

“What happened to your mother?”

“She died three years ago.”

The room softened.

Adrien’s voice lowered.

“I’m sorry.”

“Thank you.”

Nothing more.

Then Bellini looked at the violin she had borrowed for the night.

“Carlo’s daughter became a maid.”

Elena’s shoulders stiffened.

“Carlo’s daughter needed health insurance.”

Bellini looked ashamed.

“Forgive me.”

“I’m tired of people being surprised that talent doesn’t pay hospital bills.”

No one answered.

Then Adrien crossed to a cabinet.

He removed an old leather portfolio.

Inside were family photographs, programs, newspaper clippings.

He had never looked through most of them.

He found one after ten minutes.

Lucia standing backstage.

Carlo beside her.

Bellini younger.

All three laughing.

On the back, Lucia had written in blue ink:

Vittorio complains. Carlo fixes everything. I take the applause. Perfect arrangement.

Elena laughed unexpectedly.

“That sounds like my father.”

Then Adrien noticed something beneath it.

Another line.

Smaller.

C—if Dominic ever touches After Rain, keep page eight away from him.

Bellini stopped breathing.

Adrien looked up.

“What is page eight?”

Bellini did not answer.

Elena stared at the handwriting of a dead woman she had never known.

Then Bellini whispered:

“Carlo didn’t steal Lucia’s score.”

May you like

His face had gone gray.

“He was hiding the only page that proved why she stopped writing it.”

Related Stories

Other posts