Chapter 5 - THE LIE

The silence in the study was deafening. The only sound was the rain lashing against the floor-to-ceiling windows.
I stared at the paper. Gabriel stared at Lily.
"No," Gabriel breathed, his voice tearing at the edges. "No, this is a lie. This is one of his games."
"Daddy?" Lily asked, her little brow furrowed. "Why are you crying?"
Gabriel dropped the paper, rushed forward, and buried his face in Lily’s neck, pulling her from my arms. "I'm not, sweetie. Daddy's just... tired."
I picked up the paper. It looked authentic. The clinic logo, the stamps, the signatures. It was dated three weeks ago.
"Mr. Varrick," I said carefully. "If Arthur orchestrated everything else—the theft, the framing of Rosa, the murder—why wouldn't he forge this too? Evelyn was his inside woman. She could fabricate a lab report in her sleep."
Gabriel looked up, his eyes bloodshot. "Why? Why do this?"
"Because he needs a trump card," a new voice said.
We turned. Rosa was standing in the doorway of the study. She had changed out of her uniform and was wearing a simple, dignified wool sweater. Her eyes were fierce.
"Rosa," Gabriel said, standing up.
She walked into the room, ignoring the shattered wood of the desk. "Mr. Varrick. Twenty-two years I have watched this family. I watched your father build it, and I watched Arthur try to tear it down because he was jealous of you. He doesn't want Lily because he loves her. He wants her because of the Varrick Trust."
Gabriel blinked. "The Trust."
"Amelia's family trust," Rosa said. "It bypasses you. It goes directly to her biological child upon her eighteenth birthday. If Arthur can prove he is the biological father, he can petition for custody. He gets control of the trust."
I felt nauseous. The eighty million he stole wasn't the endgame. It was severance pay in case he couldn't get the real prize: Amelia's billion-dollar inheritance.
"I won't let him," Gabriel snarled. "I'll bury him in court."
"You have to find him first," I said. "And if he gets out of the country..."
"He won't," Gabriel said, his voice hardening into steel. "Marcus!"
The security chief appeared instantly. "Sir."
"Get the helicopter ready. We are going to Teterboro. If the police won't pull him off that plane, I will do it myself."
Gabriel turned to me. "Stay here. Lock the doors. Keep security on the penthouse floor. Do not let anyone in."
"I won't," I promised.
Gabriel kissed Lily’s forehead and sprinted out with Marcus.
The penthouse suddenly felt massive and terrifyingly empty. I locked the front doors, engaging the deadbolts and the security system. Rosa took Lily to the kitchen to warm up some milk.
I paced the living room, trying to make sense of the chaos. My phone buzzed again.
It was a text from an unknown number.
Check the nursery closet. Behind the dollhouse.
My blood ran cold. The text had come from Arthur's number.
He was supposed to be at the airport. How did he know about the nursery closet?
I grabbed a heavy bronze candlestick from the dining table and crept down the hallway toward Lily’s room. The door was ajar.
I pushed it open. The room was empty. The lights were off.
I walked toward the massive walk-in closet. The antique wooden dollhouse sat in the corner. I pushed it aside.
Behind it, carefully carved into the drywall, was a small, hollowed-out square.
I reached inside. My fingers brushed against something hard.
I pulled it out. It was a digital audio recorder.
I pressed play.
There was a hiss of static, and then Amelia’s voice filled the quiet room. She sounded weak, terrified.
"Gabriel, if you find this, it means I'm gone. The DNA test Arthur left you is a fake. I have the real one hidden. But you have to know the truth. The person poisoning me... it isn't Arthur."
The recording clicked off.
Suddenly, the lights in the nursery flicked on.
I spun around, dropping the candlestick.
May you like
Standing in the doorway, holding a silenced pistol aimed directly at my chest, was Celeste.
"Hello, Claire," she smiled. "I didn't leave the building after all."