Plot twist
The Man With The Scar / Chapter 3 / 11

Chapter 4 - The Brother's Betrayal

The glowing screen of the laptop blurred as tears of pure, agonizing disbelief stung my eyes.

Recipient: Leo Carter.

My older brother. The man who had walked me down the aisle when our father couldn't. The man who had hugged Nathan at our wedding and welcomed him to the family.

"Your brother is a hitman?" Madison asked, her voice a horrified squeak, backing away from the computer.

"No," I choked out, shaking my head frantically. "Leo is an independent contractor. He does high-end security and private investigations. He’s not a killer."

But the evidence was right in front of me. Fifty thousand dollars. The bloody watch. The dead foreman.

"Nathan must have lied to him," I reasoned desperately, trying to assemble the shattered pieces of my reality. "He must have told Leo the foreman was blackmailing him, maybe threatening the company or... or threatening me. Leo would do anything to protect me."

"He killed a man, Emma," Madison pointed out brutally. "Even if Nathan lied, your brother pulled the trigger."

I stared at the screen, the nausea returning with a vengeance. If I went to the police with this evidence, I wasn't just destroying my husband. I was sending my only living relative to prison for murder.

Nathan had built the perfect trap. He had weaponized my own family to secure his secrets, ensuring I could never expose him without destroying the people I loved.

"What are we going to do?" Madison whimpered, clutching her suitcase handle.

I wiped my eyes, a cold, hard resolve settling deep in my chest.

"We need the rest of the proof," I stated, pulling my phone from my pocket. "The wire transfer isn't enough. We need the original documents regarding Arthur’s death. The falsified autopsy report. The payoff receipts."

"Where would he keep that?" Madison asked.

"He keeps everything important in the wall safe in his private study," I replied, moving toward the door. "I need you to cause a distraction, Madison. Keep him out of the study for ten minutes."

Madison balked, shaking her head violently. "Are you insane? He’ll kill me!"

"He’ll kill us both if we don't get that evidence!" I hissed, grabbing her arm. "He thinks you’re a terrified, compliant little mistress. Play the part. Go downstairs, cry, beg for his forgiveness. Tell him you want to stay. Just keep him in the living room."

Madison stared at me, terrified, but she recognized the absolute necessity of the plan. She nodded slowly, taking a deep, shuddering breath.

"Ten minutes, Emma," she whispered.

I waited by the top of the stairs as Madison descended. I heard her footsteps on the hardwood, followed by the low, murmuring sound of her voice as she approached Nathan in the living room.

I heard Nathan’s voice, sharp and dismissive at first, then softening slightly as she likely threw herself at his mercy.

I didn't wait to hear the rest. I sprinted silently down the hallway to Nathan’s study.

The room was dark, smelling of rich leather and expensive scotch. I moved quickly to the large, abstract painting on the far wall and swung it aside, revealing the digital keypad of the wall safe.

I knew the combination. He had never changed it since the day we moved in. It was the date of our wedding. A sick, twisted irony.

I punched in the numbers.

The heavy steel door popped open with a soft click.

I reached inside, bypassing the stacks of emergency cash and velvet jewelry boxes, searching for the thick leather portfolio I knew he kept hidden in the back.

My fingers brushed against it. I pulled it out and rushed to the desk, turning on a small reading lamp.

I unzipped the portfolio.

It was full of documents. The original coroner's report for Arthur, heavily redacted with black marker. The bank statements showing massive, untraceable withdrawals on the days following his father’s death.

And tucked in the very back was a small, sealed envelope.

I ripped it open.

Inside was a single, folded sheet of paper. It looked like a contract.

I scanned the document, my eyes widening in absolute horror.

It wasn't a contract regarding the construction company or the foreman.

It was a highly detailed, legally binding surrogacy and non-disclosure agreement.

Client: Nathan Harrison.Surrogate: Emma Harrison.

I stopped breathing.

The contract explicitly stated that upon the successful birth of a male heir, the surrogate (me) would be compensated with a one-time payment of five million dollars and required to permanently surrender all parental rights and sever all contact with the child.

Attached to the contract was a medical report from a private fertility clinic.

The report detailed a specialized, highly aggressive IVF procedure.

I hadn't just gotten pregnant naturally, as Nathan had claimed. The frequent "vitamin injections" he insisted I take, administered by his private concierge doctor, were hormone treatments.

He had secretly initiated an IVF protocol without my knowledge, harvesting my eggs during a routine, heavily sedated "minor surgical procedure" he claimed was necessary for an ovarian cyst a year ago.

But the most terrifying detail was at the bottom of the medical report.

Donor Sperm: Arthur Harrison.

I dropped the paper, stumbling backward, hitting the bookshelf with a loud thud.

He hadn't used his own DNA. He had used his father’s frozen samples, secured years before Arthur died.

Nathan didn't want a son. He wanted a genetic replica of the man he murdered, an heir that legally bypassed Nathan entirely in the family trust, ensuring Nathan controlled the money as a proxy rather than an inheritor facing intense scrutiny from the board.

I was carrying my dead father-in-law's child.

Suddenly, the heavy oak door of the study swung open.

I spun around, terrified.

It wasn't Nathan.

Standing in the doorway, holding a silenced handgun and looking perfectly calm, was my brother, Leo.

"Leo," I gasped, tears of relief flooding my eyes. "Thank God you’re here. We have to go to the police. Nathan framed you for the foreman’s murder."

Leo didn't lower the gun. He didn't run to hug me.

May you like

He simply stepped into the study and closed the door behind him.

"He didn't frame me, Emma," Leo said softly, his voice devoid of the warm, brotherly affection I had known my entire life. "I’m the one who suggested it."

Related Stories

Other posts