Plot twist

Chapter 4 - THE LIE MARCO TOLD FOR SIX YEARS

Dominic did not shout.

That terrified Marco more.

They stood inside Sister Teresa’s office.

The nun had taken Mia to lunch.

The social worker waited outside.

Dominic closed the door.

Then turned.

“Say it again.”

Marco swallowed.

“I spoke to Elena.”

“Last night.”

“Yes.”

“She is alive.”

“Yes.”

“Where?”

“I don’t know exactly.”

Dominic walked toward him.

Marco did not move.

“How long have you known?”

“Known she was alive?”

Dominic’s voice remained calm.

“Yes.”

Marco looked down.

“Six years.”

Dominic hit him.

One punch.

Hard enough to send Marco backward into the wall.

Then Dominic stopped.

His fist stayed clenched.

He looked at it.

Then at Marco.

Twenty years of old reflex.

One second.

One hit.

Shame followed immediately.

Sister Teresa opened the door.

“What happened?”

Dominic stepped away.

“I struck him.”

The blunt admission surprised everyone.

Marco touched his lip.

Blood.

“I’m fine.”

Sister Teresa looked at Dominic.

“You leave if that happens again.”

Nobody spoke to Dominic Moretti like that.

He nodded.

“Understood.”

Then he sat.

Not because he was calm.

Because he was afraid of what standing might make easier.

“Tell me everything.”

Marco did.

Six years earlier, Elena came to him with a ledger.

Payments routed through Calder Freight before Salvatore Moretti’s murder.

She believed someone inside the Moretti organization had assisted the men responsible.

Dominic had been preparing retaliation against three suspects.

Marco feared the ledger might change the target list.

So he promised Elena he would investigate first.

That part was true.

Then Victor Rossini found out.

Victor cornered Elena.

Threatened her.

But also showed her real intelligence indicating Dominic’s enemies had begun watching her.

“Was the danger real?”

Dominic asked.

“Yes.”

“Did you verify?”

“After she left.”

“After.”

“Yes.”

Marco took the word.

Elena told Marco she was pregnant the morning she disappeared.

Not before.

Marco did not know how far along.

She refused to tell him where she was going.

She asked only one thing.

“Do not tell Dominic until I am somewhere safe.”

Dominic stared.

“That promise lasted six years?”

“No.”

Marco closed his eyes.

“Three days.”

“What happened?”

“I went to tell you.”

He had reached Dominic’s office.

Victor was already there.

He showed Marco photographs.

Two men linked to Rafael Ross following Elena’s old apartment.

A report indicating someone had asked which hospitals Moretti women used.

Victor argued that telling Dominic would cause exactly what Elena feared.

Dominic would search openly.

Enemies would follow.

“So I waited.”

Marco said.

“Then?”

“Elena called.”

“From where?”

“New Jersey.”

“She had given birth?”

“No.”

“She said she was leaving the city.”

“She made me promise again.”

Dominic’s voice sharpened.

“You let her decide whether I knew I had a child?”

“I didn’t know there would be one.”

“You knew she was pregnant.”

“Yes.”

“Mine?”

“She said yes.”

The room went silent.

There.

No need to pretend.

“What happened to Mia?”

“I didn’t know.”

Marco said.

That part was true.

Elena disappeared completely after that call.

Marco kept one emergency number.

The one he called last night.

She never used it.

He tried twice during Dominic’s first year searching.

No answer.

Later the line disconnected.

“I thought she had moved overseas.”

“Did you ever tell me she was pregnant?”

“No.”

“Why?”

“Because by then you were burning Brooklyn apart looking for her.”

Dominic’s jaw tightened.

Not literally.

But close.

He had interrogated people.

Threatened old associates.

Forced access to travel records.

Fired anyone he thought might have helped Elena leave.

One innocent driver had been beaten by Moretti men after a false rumor.

Dominic later paid his medical bills.

Never apologized personally.

“I saw what the search was becoming.”

Marco said.

“I thought telling you about a pregnancy would make it worse.”

“So you chose for me.”

“Yes.”

The answer landed.

Then Marco told him Elena’s version from the previous night.

She had left Mia at St. Cecilia five years earlier under the name Anna Rossi.

Sister Teresa’s date matched.

But one thing remained impossible.

Mia appeared about three when abandoned.

If born after Elena left Dominic, she should have been an infant.

Dominic noticed immediately.

“So Mia was already alive when Elena disappeared.”

Marco looked confused.

“That doesn’t make sense.”

“No.”

Dominic stood.

Then stopped himself before pacing became aggression.

Sister Teresa returned.

“I may be able to explain.”

Both men turned.

The original medical intake estimate had been wrong.

Mia arrived feverish.

Severely underweight.

Small for age.

Anna said the child was three.

Nobody had documents.

The pediatrician estimated between two and four.

Years later, a dentist believed Mia might be younger than her school age by as much as eighteen months.

“We kept the assigned date.”

Sister Teresa said.

“Changing it without evidence would have created more problems.”

Dominic calculated.

If Mia had been around eighteen months when abandoned five years earlier—

she could now be six and a half.

Born months after Elena disappeared.

Possible.

Mia believed she was eight because the adults around her had given her that identity.

No one had lied maliciously.

They had worked with what they had.

Dominic looked toward the courtyard.

“Does she have any medical records from before St. Cecilia?”

“No.”

“Birth certificate?”

“No.”

“DNA?”

Sister Teresa’s expression hardened.

“Do not turn that child into a sample because you are impatient.”

Dominic looked at her.

Then nodded.

“What is the legal process?”

That surprised Marco.

Sister Teresa explained.

If Dominic believed he might be Mia’s biological father, child-welfare authorities needed to be involved.

The photograph and Elena’s statement mattered.

Paternity could eventually be established lawfully if necessary.

But Mia was not leaving that afternoon.

Not because Dominic Moretti pointed at her.

Not because he had money.

Good.

Dominic respected the answer.

Then the office phone rang.

Sister Teresa answered.

Her face changed.

“Who?”

A pause.

Then she looked at Dominic.

“It’s a man asking whether Mia Moretti is still in our care.”

Dominic stood.

Nobody at St. Cecilia had ever called her Mia Moretti.

Not once.

May you like

Sister Teresa covered the receiver.

“He says his name is Victor Rossini.”

Related Stories

Other posts