Plot twist

Chapter 5 - The Unlikely Alliance

The silence in the vault room was deafening, broken only by the ragged, shallow sound of my own breathing.

He is setting Amber up to take the fall for your murder.

I stared at the ten-million-dollar life insurance policy. Robert hadn't just been having a midlife crisis. He hadn't just been greedy. He had meticulously, sociopathically orchestrated a plan to clear his massive debts by staging my accidental death, funneling the money through his naive mistress, and leaving her holding the bag when the police inevitably investigated.

He would play the grieving widower, completely insulated from the crime.

"We have to go to the police," Daniel said, his voice hard as stone, reaching for the documents. "Right now, Marianne. This is conspiracy to commit murder. They’ll arrest him today."

"No," I said, slamming my hand down on the papers, stopping him.

Daniel looked at me, bewildered. "Marianne, he is planning to kill you. We have the proof."

"If we go to the police now, it’s his word against these papers," I argued, my mind racing with a cold, terrifying clarity. "He’ll hire the best defense attorneys in Chicago. He’ll claim Amber forged the documents. He’ll claim she was an obsessed stalker trying to frame him because he tried to end the affair. With her notary stamp on the forged deed, they might actually believe him. He’ll walk on bail, and I will spend the rest of my life looking over my shoulder."

"Then what do we do?" Daniel demanded, pacing the small room.

I looked at the forged notary stamp bearing Amber’s name. The twenty-three-year-old girl who had rung a silver bell in my face to mock my tears. She thought she was winning a prize. She had no idea she was being groomed for a prison sentence.

"We talk to Amber," I stated firmly.

Daniel stared at me as if I had lost my mind. "You want to team up with the mistress?"

"I want to show the mistress exactly what her 'boyfriend' has planned for her future," I corrected him, gathering the documents and shoving them into my large tote bag. "If we want to destroy Robert permanently, we need Amber to turn state's evidence. We need her to wear a wire."

We left the bank and drove to a small, unassuming diner on the outskirts of the city. I purchased a cheap burner phone with cash and dialed the number I had memorized from Robert’s phone bills months ago.

Amber answered on the third ring. Her voice was cautious, defensive.

"Hello?"

"Amber, it’s Marianne," I said, keeping my tone entirely flat.

"I have nothing to say to you," Amber snapped, attempting to sound tough. "Robert told me you’re trying to freeze his assets. You’re crazy, Marianne. Just let him go."

"I am letting him go, Amber," I replied smoothly. "But before I do, I think you should see the ten-million-dollar life insurance policy he took out on me, listing your LLC as the primary beneficiary."

The line went dead silent.

"What are you talking about?" Amber whispered, the false bravado vanishing instantly.

"Meet me at the Starlight Diner on 4th Street in twenty minutes," I instructed. "Come alone. If you tell Robert, you will spend the next twenty years in a federal penitentiary for real estate fraud and conspiracy to commit murder. Your choice."

I hung up.

Twenty-five minutes later, Amber walked into the diner. She looked terrified, clutching her designer purse to her chest, constantly glancing over her shoulder. She slid into the booth across from me. Daniel sat silently beside me, radiating an aura of quiet intimidation.

I didn't waste time on pleasantries. I pulled the manila folder from my bag and slid the documents across the sticky diner table.

"Read them," I commanded.

Amber’s eyes scanned the forged second mortgage, lingering on her own unauthorized notary stamp. Then, she read the life insurance policy.

As she reached the drafted transfer agreement routing the payout from her LLC back to Robert, all the color drained from her face. Her hands began to shake so violently she dropped the papers.

"He told me the LLC was for a boutique clothing line he was funding for me," Amber choked out, tears of sheer panic welling in her eyes. "He said the notary stamp was just a formality for a business loan. I didn't know he was stealing your house. I swear to God, Marianne, I didn't know."

"Ignorance isn't a defense in federal court, Amber," Daniel interjected coldly.

"He’s setting me up," Amber realized, the horror fully dawning on her. "He’s going to kill you, and the police are going to find my name on all the money."

She buried her face in her hands, sobbing quietly. The arrogant girl was gone. In her place was a victim realizing she was trapped in a cage with a monster.

"I can protect you," I said softly.

Amber looked up, wiping her mascara-stained cheeks. "How?"

"By helping us catch him in the act," I explained, leaning forward. "We go to the FBI. You agree to cooperate. But before they arrest him, we need him to confess to the premeditation on tape."

Amber swallowed hard, nodding frantically. "I’ll do whatever you want. Please, just don't let me go to prison."

My burner phone suddenly buzzed on the table.

It was a text message. From Robert.

Marianne. I know you’re upset. I want to make things right. Come back to the house tonight. Let’s have dinner. Just the two of us. We need to talk.

I stared at the screen, a cold chill running down my spine.

Suddenly, Amber’s phone buzzed in her purse. She pulled it out, reading the text message she had just received.

Her eyes widened in absolute terror as she looked at me.

"Marianne," Amber whispered, her voice trembling. "Robert just texted me. He said you’ve been extremely agitated lately. He asked me to pick up your 'new anxiety medication' from the pharmacy and bring it to the house before dinner."

May you like

She turned the screen toward me.

"He told me to make sure you drink it in your tea tonight."

Related Stories

Other posts