Plot twist

Chapter 4 - The Leather Ledger

I stared at the leather-bound book, the elegant handwriting blurring before my eyes.

He's been stealing from the firm for three years.

The air left my lungs. Nathan wasn't just a cheating husband experiencing a midlife crisis. He was an embezzler. He had been quietly draining his family's legacy while coming home to me every night, complaining about the stress of managing the commercial division.

Answer One, Open Two. Eleanor had used me and the party as a distraction to smuggle the evidence of Nathan's crimes out of the house. But if the federal auditors were arriving on Tuesday, why didn't Eleanor just hand the ledger directly to them? And what was the strange, rhythmic tapping sound coming from my bedroom window?

I quickly shoved the ledger under the mattress of the guest bed, smoothing the duvet over it. My hands were shaking. I had thought the worst part of this night was the humiliation of the party. Now, I was holding the evidence that could send my husband to federal prison.

The tapping sound came again.

Tap. Tap. Tap.

It wasn't the wind.

I walked cautiously to the window and pulled back the heavy curtain.

Standing on the roof of the back patio, illuminated by the security light, was Olivia. Madison's older sister.

She looked frantic, gesturing wildly for me to open the window.

I hesitated, then undid the latch and pushed the sash up. The cool night air rushed in.

"Are you insane?" I whispered harshly. "What are you doing on my roof?"

"I couldn't use the front door," Olivia hissed, climbing awkwardly over the sill and tumbling into the guest room. She smelled of stale champagne and anxiety. "Nathan is still downstairs crying, and Madison is screaming at him about the firm."

"And you decided to break into my bedroom?" I asked, backing away from her.

"I need your help," Olivia pleaded, standing up and brushing off her knees. "You have to tell me what Eleanor said to him. Why is he getting fired?"

"That's between Nathan and his mother," I said coldly. "And it's none of your business."

"It is my business!" Olivia snapped, losing her composure. She stepped closer, her eyes wide with panic. "Nathan promised to pay off my business loans next month! He said once Madison moved in and you were out of the picture, he was going to invest in my catering company!"

I stared at her in sheer disbelief. The sisters weren't just close; they were a coordinated grift. Madison secured the relationship, and Olivia secured the funding.

"He promised you an investment," I repeated, the sick realization settling in. "That's why you were helping her decorate. You were getting paid for this."

Olivia had the grace to look slightly ashamed, but her desperation quickly overrode it.

"I'm drowning, Caroline," Olivia confessed, her voice cracking. "I owe eighty thousand dollars to a private lender. If Nathan loses his job, I lose everything."

"Then you should have picked a better mark," I replied, feeling no pity for the woman who had happily planned my erasure for a paycheck.

"Please," Olivia begged, grabbing my arm. "Does he have any other accounts? Any secret funds? You were married to him for twenty-four years. You must know where he keeps his emergency money."

I yanked my arm away. I thought of the leather ledger hidden under the mattress just feet away from us. Millions of dollars in stolen, untraceable offshore funds.

"I don't know anything about his money, Olivia," I lied smoothly. "Get out of my room."

"He told Madison he had a safety net!" Olivia argued, growing frantic. "He said he had a safety deposit box at the downtown branch of First National!"

My heart skipped a beat. A safety deposit box.

"I don't have the key," I said truthfully.

"I do," Olivia whispered, reaching into her pocket. She pulled out a small, ornate brass key. "I took it from his desk drawer while he was fighting with his mother. But the bank requires dual signature authorization. The account is still in your name, Caroline. He hasn't removed you yet."

Answer One, Open Two. Olivia had stolen the key to Nathan's secret safety deposit box and needed my signature to access it. But if the account held his emergency funds, why would Nathan leave me on the authorization list? And what was Madison doing creeping down the hallway toward my closed door?

"You want me to commit bank fraud to pay off your catering loans?" I asked, staring at the brass key.

"I want us both to get paid," Olivia countered, her eyes gleaming with desperate greed. "We open the box tomorrow morning. We split whatever is inside. You get fifty percent, I get my debts paid, and we leave Nathan to burn."

Before I could process the sheer audacity of her proposal, the doorknob to the guest room rattled violently.

"Caroline!" Madison's voice screeched from the hallway. "Open this door! I know you're in there!"

Olivia panicked, shoving the brass key into my hand. "Hide it! If she knows I took it, she'll tell him!"

"Tell him what?" Madison demanded, slamming her fists against the wood. "Open the door!"

I shoved the key into my pocket alongside the silver pocket watch. I walked over and unlocked the door.

Madison burst in, her face flushed with fury, her perfect red dress slightly wrinkled. She stopped dead when she saw her sister standing in my room.

"Olivia?" Madison frowned, confusion replacing her anger. "What are you doing in here?"

"I... I was just checking on her," Olivia lied poorly, avoiding her sister's gaze. "To see if she was okay."

"She's fine," Madison snapped, turning her furious attention back to me. "You ruined my night. You ruined my life! Because of your stupid little stunt with Eleanor, Nathan is broke!"

"Nathan ruined his own life, Madison," I said calmly. "I just provided the audience."

"He was going to buy me a house in the Hamptons!" Madison shrieked, stomping her foot like a petulant toddler. "He promised me!"

"Well," I smiled thinly, "I hear the guest room is available. Rent is due on the first."

Madison let out a sound of pure frustration, raising her hand as if to slap me.

I didn't flinch. I just stared her down. She lowered her hand, intimidated by the absolute lack of fear in my eyes.

"You're going to pay for this, Caroline," Madison hissed. She turned on her heel and stormed out of the room, dragging a bewildered Olivia behind her.

I locked the door again.

I sat on the edge of the bed, pulling the brass key from my pocket and staring at it.

I had the ledger detailing the embezzlement, and the key to the safety deposit box that likely held the stolen cash or the documents proving it.

I was holding Nathan's entire life in the palm of my hand.

I reached under the mattress and pulled out the leather book.

I opened it to the first page.

Account: First National. Box 402. Authorization: Nathan Sterling / Caroline Sterling.

He hadn't removed me from the account because he couldn't. The account was likely opened years ago, before the affair, when he still needed my clean credit to secure the box.

I closed the ledger.

I wasn't going to split the contents with Olivia. I wasn't going to hand it over to the federal auditors on Tuesday, either.

May you like

I was going to the bank tomorrow morning.

And I was going to take everything.

Related Stories

Other posts