Plot twist

Chapter 3 - The Silver Medal in the Ashes

The words hit me harder than a physical blow.

Maria sold him out.

The sweet, quiet girl who always helped me sweep the floors. The girl Frank used to slip extra cash to because she was sending money back home to her mother.

“You’re lying,” I breathed.

“Why do you think she climbed out the window before the smoke even reached the kitchen?” Adrian taunted, keeping the gun leveled at Raymond but keeping his eyes on me. “She unlocked the back door for us. Frank caught her. That’s why he didn't make it out.”

My mind raced back to that horrific night. Frank running back into the blazing restaurant, shouting that he had to find Maria. He hadn't gone back to save her. He had gone back because he realized she had betrayed him.

Suddenly, a heavy crystal wine decanter smashed against the side of Adrian’s head.

Luca had moved with terrifying speed.

Adrian crumpled to the floor, the gun sliding across the polished hardwood. Luca didn't hesitate. He kicked the weapon under a heavy mahogany cabinet and slammed his foot down on Adrian’s chest, pinning him to the ground.

“Dante!” Luca roared.

The heavy dining room doors burst open. Four of Luca’s security men flooded the room in black suits.

“Clear the guests,” Luca ordered. “And detain Mr. Vale and my fiancée.”

Vanessa shrieked as a guard grabbed her arm. “Luca! You can't do this! I love you! My father was just protecting our families!”

“Get her out of my sight,” Luca snarled.

The room emptied rapidly until only Luca, his father Vincent, Raymond, the guards, and I remained.

I ignored the chaos. I walked straight to the table and picked up the scorched recipe box. My hands shook as I ran my thumbs over the blackened tin.

“Mrs. Bennett,” Luca said softly, stepping away from the groaning Adrian. “I am so sorry. I didn't know.”

I opened the box. I ignored the index cards with the shipping codes. I knew Frank. If he had hidden something truly important, he wouldn't leave it on top.

I pressed my thumbs against the bottom corners of the tin. Frank had soldered this box himself. He always told me it was sturdy enough to survive a bomb.

There was a faint click. A false bottom popped loose.

I pulled it up.

Resting beneath the false bottom wasn't more blackmail material. It wasn't money.

It was a tarnished silver St. Jude medal.

I stared at it, my blood running entirely cold.

“I know that medal,” I whispered.

Vincent Moretti stood up from the table. For the first time all evening, the arrogant mob boss looked genuinely terrified.

“Where did you get that?” Vincent demanded, taking a step toward me.

Luca intercepted him, putting a hand firmly on his father’s chest. “Stay back, Dad.”

I looked up at Vincent. My vision blurred with tears, but my voice was sharp as broken glass.

“This was Maria’s medal,” I said. “She never took it off. She told me it belonged to her grandmother.”

I turned the medal over. Engraved on the back were three letters. V. M.

Vincent Moretti.

“Answer one question for me, Vincent,” I said, throwing his own words back at him. “If Maria climbed out the window to escape, why was her necklace hidden in the false bottom of my husband’s recipe box?”

Vincent swallowed hard. He looked at the guards, measuring his chances of fighting his way out of his own son’s dining room.

“She didn't escape, did she?” I pressed, walking toward him. “Frank didn't go back into the fire to catch a traitor. He went back to save a girl you were trying to kill.”

Raymond, the night watchman, cleared his throat from the corner. He was clutching his chest, pale but resolute.

“Nora’s right,” Raymond said quietly. “When I heard the screaming that night... it wasn't Frank. Not at first. It was a woman. She was screaming for help from the alley.”

Luca looked at his father, his gray eyes filled with absolute disgust. “You didn't burn the restaurant to stop Frank from blackmailing you. You burned it to cover up a murder.”

“She was pregnant!” Vincent suddenly shouted, his composure shattering. “She was a twenty-year-old dishwasher, and she was carrying my child! If my wife found out, she would have stripped me of my shares in the family business! I couldn't let her ruin me!”

The absolute depravity of it washed over me. Frank hadn't been blackmailing them. He had figured out Vincent’s secret, and he was trying to protect a terrified young girl.

And they had burned him alive for it.

“Where is her body, Dad?” Luca asked, his voice dead of all emotion.

“It’s gone,” Vanessa’s voice echoed from the hallway.

She had broken away from the guard, standing in the doorway with her makeup smeared and her elegant dress torn.

“My father’s construction company poured the foundation for the new bank over the ashes of the restaurant the very next week,” Vanessa sneered, spitting the words with venomous spite. “Maria is buried under fifty tons of concrete. You have no proof. You have nothing.”

I looked at the silver medal in my hand.

“You're wrong, Vanessa,” I said softly.

I squeezed the St. Jude medal. The side of the silver charm gave way under my thumb. It wasn't a solid medal. It was a locket.

I pried it open.

May you like

Inside was a tiny, folded piece of paper. And wrapped inside the paper was a small, rusted brass key.

“Frank didn't just hide her necklace,” I said, looking directly at Luca. “He hid her leverage.”

Related Stories

Other posts