Chapter 4 - The Lockbox at St. Jude's

The dining room felt like a tomb.
Luca stared at the rusted brass key in my palm. The symbol of a cross was faintly engraved on its bow.
“Do you know what that goes to?” Luca asked me, his voice a low, urgent murmur.
I traced the cross with my thumb. Thirteen years ago, before the fire, Frank used to make weekly deliveries of leftover bread and soup to the Catholic parish three blocks from our restaurant. St. Jude’s.
“Yes,” I said, my heart beginning to hammer anew. “I know exactly where it goes.”
“Luca, listen to me,” Vincent pleaded, taking another step toward his son. “You’re the head of this family now. If you drag this out into the light, it doesn't just destroy me. It destroys our name. The feds will seize everything. The shipping lanes, the properties, the accounts. You will lose your empire.”
Luca didn't even blink. He looked at the father who had taught him how to be ruthless, how to command a room, how to rule through fear.
“You burned a good man alive to hide your own cowardice,” Luca said coldly. “My empire is already built on ashes.”
Luca turned to Dante. “Lock my father and Adrian in the wine cellar. Keep Vanessa in the drawing room. If any of them try to leave, break their legs.”
“Luca!” Vincent roared as Dante’s men grabbed him. “You are destroying your own blood!”
“You stopped being my blood thirteen years ago,” Luca replied.
He turned to me. The dangerous mob boss was entirely focused. “Get your coat, Nora. We’re going to church.”
The night air was freezing, the Chicago wind biting through my wool coat as Luca’s armored SUV pulled up to the imposing stone steps of St. Jude’s parish.
It was past midnight. The massive wooden doors were locked, the stained-glass windows dark.
Luca didn't knock. He signaled to one of his men, who produced a heavy steel pry bar from the trunk.
“Wait,” I said, placing a hand on Luca’s arm. “Don't break it. Let me.”
I walked up the stone steps. I reached beneath the heavy iron planter box sitting to the right of the doors. My fingers brushed cold dirt until they found a small, magnetic hide-a-key. Father Thomas had shown Frank where he kept it twenty years ago for the late-night food deliveries.
It was still there.
I unlocked the heavy oak door, and we stepped into the cavernous, silent sanctuary. The smell of incense and old wax hung heavy in the air.
“Where to?” Luca whispered, his flashlight beam cutting through the darkness.
“The rectory basement,” I said, leading the way down the narrow stone stairs behind the altar. “They have a wall of old donation lockboxes. People used to leave anonymous offerings for the poor.”
We reached the basement. The flashlight beam swept across a wall of rusted, numbered metal boxes built directly into the brick.
I held up the brass key. It had the number 42 stamped faintly on the side.
My hands shook as I approached box 42. I slid the key into the slot. It stuck for a moment, resisting after thirteen years of neglect. I forced it. The lock clicked.
I pulled the small metal drawer open.
Inside was a thick, sealed manila envelope.
Luca held the flashlight steady as I pulled it out. Written on the front in Frank’s handwriting were two words: For Nora.
Tears blurred my vision. I hadn't seen his handwriting in over a decade. I carefully tore the seal and pulled out the contents.
It wasn't a confession from Maria. It wasn't photos of Vincent.
It was a stack of birth certificates, medical records, and adoption papers.
I stared at the documents, my mind struggling to process what I was reading.
“What is it?” Luca asked gently.
“Maria didn't die in the fire,” I whispered, reading the medical file. “She was pregnant... but the baby wasn't due in a few months. She had already given birth.”
Luca’s brow furrowed. “To my father’s child?”
“Yes,” I said, my voice cracking. “But Vincent didn't want the baby dead. He wanted it hidden. He hired Adrian Vale to take the baby and place it in a private, closed adoption. Maria found out. She threatened to go to the police.”
I pulled out the final document. It was an adoption certificate, heavily redacted, but the seal of the state was undeniable.
“Frank didn't go back into the fire to save Maria,” I realized, the horrific truth finally settling into place. “He knew Maria was already dead. He went back to the restaurant to get this envelope. To protect the child's identity.”
Luca looked at the papers. “He died to make sure my father could never find his illegitimate child and silence them too.”
“Answer one, open two,” I murmured, a chill running down my spine. We knew why the fire started. But now we had a ghost to find.
I looked at the adoption certificate again. The adoptive parents' names were blacked out, but the date of birth and the child's given name were legible.
Born: October 14, 2013.Name: Leo.
I froze.
I looked up at Luca. The color had completely drained from his face.
“Luca,” I breathed. “Your father’s middle name is Leo.”
Luca took a step back, hitting the brick wall behind him. His chest heaved as if he couldn't catch his breath.
“My father didn't adopt the baby out to strangers,” Luca whispered, the horror creeping into his eyes. “He gave the baby to Vanessa’s family. The Bellinis.”
Suddenly, the heavy wooden doors at the top of the basement stairs slammed shut.
A voice echoed down the stone stairwell.
“You always were too smart for your own good, Luca.”
May you like
It was Adrian Vale.
And he wasn't locked in the wine cellar anymore.