Chapter 3 - The Key to Thursday Nights

The brass key sat on the pristine white tablecloth, mocking me.
“Don't listen to her, Dorothy,” Samuel said, stepping up beside me. “She’s just trying to cause pain because she’s been caught.”
I stared at the key. Frank and I shared everything. We shared a bank account, we shared a car, we shared our fears and our dreams. He didn't have secrets. He was a simple, honest man.
But Catherine’s smile was too confident.
“What is that key, Catherine?” Luca demanded, his voice hardening again.
“It’s the key to a box at the First City Bank downtown,” Catherine said, smoothing her dress as if she hadn't just confessed to grand larceny. “Raymond found it in Frank’s locker at the docks after he died. He held onto it, thinking it might be useful leverage.”
“Leverage against what?” I asked, my voice trembling.
“Against the fact that your saint of a husband was blackmailing us,” Catherine spat.
The ballroom erupted in murmurs again.
“That’s a lie!” Samuel roared, stepping toward Catherine. One of Luca’s guards placed a firm hand on the old man’s chest, stopping him.
“Frank Bennett wasn't a blackmailer,” Luca said firmly. “He was a loyal worker.”
“He was a thief!” Catherine retorted. “He found out about the shadow ledger three years ago. But instead of coming to you, Luca, he came to Raymond. He demanded monthly payouts to keep quiet.”
“No,” I whispered, taking a step back. “Frank wouldn't do that. He wouldn't take dirty money.”
“Then how do you think you paid off your mortgage so fast, Dorothy?” Catherine asked, her eyes narrowing. “Frank’s salary didn't cover those extra payments you were making three years ago.”
My breath hitched. Three years ago, Frank had suddenly started bringing home extra cash. He told me he was taking extra shifts at a different dock on Thursday nights. He said the overtime pay was incredible. It was the only reason we had managed to pay off the house before he retired.
“Thursday nights,” I murmured, the memory of him coming home late, exhausted but smiling, hitting me like a physical blow.
“He didn't work Thursday nights,” Catherine smirked. “He came to Raymond’s office every Thursday to collect his hush money. And whatever is in that safety deposit box is the insurance he kept to make sure Raymond kept paying.”
I looked at Luca. He was staring at the key, a complex array of emotions warring on his face. He wanted to believe me, to believe in Frank’s loyalty. But he also knew his sister, as cruel as she was, rarely bluffed when backed into a corner.
“I don't believe you,” I said, finding my voice. I reached out and snatched the brass key off the table. “Frank was a good man. If he took money from Raymond, it was because Raymond owed it to the workers.”
“Then go to the bank tomorrow, Dorothy,” Catherine challenged. “See for yourself what kind of man you were married to.”
Luca signaled to his remaining guards. “Escort my sister to her room. She doesn't leave this house until I decide what to do with her.”
Catherine glared at Luca, but she allowed the guards to lead her away. The ballroom was silent, the festive atmosphere completely shattered.
Luca turned to the guests. “This celebration is over. Please, go home.”
As the wealthy guests hurried out, whispering and casting sidelong glances at me and the retired workers, Luca walked over to me.
“Dorothy,” Luca said gently, offering me his arm. “Come to my office. Let’s figure this out.”
I nodded, clutching the brass key tightly in my fist. Samuel and the others waited in the foyer, promising to stand by me.
Luca’s office was a sanctuary of dark wood and leather. He poured two glasses of scotch, handing one to me. I took a sip, the burn steadying my nerves.
“Do you think Catherine is telling the truth?” Luca asked quietly, sitting across from me.
“I don't know,” I admitted, a tear finally escaping. “Frank lied to me about working Thursdays. That much I know now. But blackmail? It doesn't sound like him.”
“Raymond is a snake,” Luca said, his jaw tightening. “He could have manipulated Frank. But we need to know what’s in that box.”
“I’m going to the bank first thing tomorrow,” I said firmly.
Luca nodded. “I’ll send Dante, my head of security, with you. To make sure you’re safe.”
The next morning, I stood in the sterile, quiet vault of the First City Bank downtown. Dante, a silent, imposing man in a dark suit, stood respectfully by the door.
The bank manager unlocked the master lock on box 412, then stepped back.
My hand shook as I inserted the tarnished brass key. It turned with a heavy click.
I pulled the long metal box out and set it on the viewing table.
I expected stacks of cash. I expected ledgers proving Frank had been extorting Raymond.
I opened the lid.
There was no money. There were no ledgers.
There was only a single, faded manila folder. And resting on top of it was a small, dried bunch of grocery-store carnations.
I choked back a sob, reaching out to touch the brittle petals. Frank had left them for me. He knew I would be the one to find this.
I moved the flowers aside and opened the folder.
Inside were dozens of photographs. Grainy, covert photos taken at the docks at night. But they weren't photos of Raymond stealing money.
They were photos of men loading long, heavy wooden crates onto unmarked cargo ships. The crates were stenciled with a symbol I didn't recognize.
May you like
But tucked behind the photos was a handwritten letter from Frank.
Dorothy, if you are reading this, it means Raymond finally realized I know the truth. They aren't just stealing our pensions. They are using the waterfront to traffic something much worse. And Luca Moretti is helping them.