Plot twist

Chapter 5 - The Sister’s Syndicate

Catherine stepped fully into the cramped living room, looking around with an expression of profound disgust, as if the very air in Samuel’s house was contaminating her.

“Catherine,” I gasped, stepping instinctively in front of Samuel. “How did you get out? Luca locked you in your room.”

“Luca is a sentimental fool who thinks locking a door stops a woman with half a million dollars in walking-around money,” Catherine laughed sharply. “A guard’s loyalty is only as strong as his bank account, Dorothy. Remember that.”

She looked at the photographs spread across the coffee table, then at the forged letter in Samuel’s hand.

“Ah,” Catherine smiled, a terrifyingly cold expression. “I see you found my little breadcrumb.”

“You forged Frank’s letter,” I said, the horrific truth finally snapping into place. “You put it in his safety deposit box.”

“Frank found the photographs years ago, yes,” Catherine admitted casually, running a gloved finger over the dusty mantlepiece. “He brought them to Raymond, threatening to go to the police. Raymond panicked. He wanted to kill him. But I told Raymond that dead men create investigations. Broke, desperate men just work harder.”

My blood ran cold. “You stopped his pension.”

“It was the perfect distraction,” Catherine shrugged. “Frank spent the last eighteen months of his life so stressed about paying your mortgage that he completely forgot about the weapons. And when his heart finally gave out... well, that was just a happy coincidence.”

Samuel growled, a deep, angry sound, and took a step toward her. “You evil bitch.”

The two armed men instantly raised their pistols, aiming directly at Samuel’s head.

“Ah-ah, Samuel,” Catherine warned. “Don't be a hero. You’re too old for it.”

“Why forge the letter framing Luca?” I demanded, keeping my eyes locked on her. “If Frank was dead, your secret was safe.”

Catherine sighed, looking at me as if I were a particularly slow child.

“Because my idiot brother is trying to legitimize the family business,” Catherine spat, her composure cracking for a moment. “Luca has been shutting down the illegal operations for five years. He doesn't understand that power doesn't come from clean shipping manifests. It comes from fear. And the weapons trade buys a lot of fear.”

She walked closer, stopping just out of arm's reach.

“Raymond and I have been running the guns behind Luca’s back,” Catherine explained. “But Luca is getting suspicious. He’s been auditing the accounts. It was only a matter of time before he found the missing pension funds and traced them to the weapons.”

“So you needed a scapegoat,” I realized.

“I needed Luca out of the way,” Catherine smiled. “I knew you were asking questions about the pensions, Dorothy. So, a month ago, I broke into Frank’s safety deposit box, planted the forged letter framing Luca, and waited for you to find it. The plan was simple: you find the letter, you take it to the FBI, and they arrest Luca for the weapons trafficking.”

“And with Luca in federal prison, you take over the family,” Samuel finished, disgust dripping from every word.

“Exactly,” Catherine beamed. “But you had to ruin it by causing a scene at the anniversary dinner. You forced my hand prematurely.”

She turned to her guards. “Kill them both. Make it look like a robbery gone wrong. Burn the photos.”

The men raised their weapons.

I didn't think. I reacted with the instincts of a woman who had spent thirty-seven years married to a man who built things with his hands.

I grabbed the heavy, cast-iron lamp resting on the end table beside me and hurled it directly at the nearest guard’s face.

The heavy base struck him squarely in the nose with a sickening crunch. He staggered backward, his gun discharging wildly into the ceiling. Plaster rained down on us.

“Samuel, move!” I screamed.

Samuel grabbed the small wooden coffee table and flipped it upward, shoving it into the second guard’s knees. The man stumbled, cursing loudly.

I grabbed Samuel’s arm, and we bolted toward the narrow hallway leading to the back kitchen.

“Don't let them get away!” Catherine shrieked from the living room.

We burst into the small kitchen. Samuel slammed the wooden door shut, throwing the flimsy deadbolt. It wouldn't hold them for more than a few seconds.

“The back window,” Samuel wheezed, pointing to the small window above the sink. His face was pale, his breath coming in ragged gasps. He wasn't a young man, and the adrenaline was taking its toll.

“I’m not leaving you!” I yelled, pulling a heavy cast-iron skillet from the drying rack.

“Dorothy, go!” Samuel pushed me toward the sink. “I’m seventy-two years old. I’ve got nothing left to lose. You have the truth! You have to tell Luca!”

The kitchen door splintered as one of the guards kicked it violently from the other side. The wood groaned in protest.

“Tell him Catherine is the rat!” Samuel ordered, grabbing a large carving knife from the block on the counter. He turned toward the breaking door, his jaw set with a fierce, unbreakable resolve.

Tears blurred my vision. I nodded, scrambling up onto the counter and forcing the small window open.

I squeezed through the narrow frame, scraping my sides, and tumbled out into the muddy, overgrown alley behind the rowhouses.

As my feet hit the ground, the kitchen door shattered completely.

I heard a shout, a scuffle, and then a single, deafening gunshot.

Then, silence.

“Samuel!” I screamed, hitting the brick wall of the house.

“She’s in the alley!” Catherine’s voice echoed from the kitchen window.

I didn't wait. I turned and ran. I ran faster than I had in twenty years, my lungs burning in the cold Chicago air. I didn't look back. I ran through the maze of back alleys, hiding behind dumpsters and broken fences, listening to the heavy boots of Catherine’s men searching for me.

I ran until my legs gave out, collapsing behind a rusted, abandoned car two blocks away.

I sat in the freezing mud, clutching the manila envelope against my chest. Samuel was gone. Frank was gone. Catherine had an army of corrupt guards, and I was a sixty-one-year-old widow with flour still on my uniform.

I pulled out my cell phone. My hands were shaking so badly I could barely unlock the screen.

I only had one number to call. The man Catherine had tried to frame. The man whose empire was being stolen from right under his nose.

I dialed Luca Moretti’s private cell.

He answered on the first ring.

“Dorothy?” Luca’s voice was tense, urgent. “Dante said you ran from the estate. Where are you?”

“Luca,” I gasped, tears finally spilling over my cheeks. “They killed Samuel. Catherine killed him.”

A heavy, terrifying silence fell over the line.

“Where are you, Dorothy?” Luca asked, his voice dropping to a deadly, icy calm.

“I’m in the alley behind 4th and Elm,” I cried. “She forged the letter, Luca. She’s running the weapons with Raymond. She tried to frame you.”

“I’m coming to get you,” Luca said. “Do not move. Do not trust anyone else.”

“Luca, she bought off your guards,” I warned, panic rising again. “How do I know I can trust you?”

“Because,” Luca said softly, “if I wanted you dead, Dorothy, you never would have made it out of my ballroom alive.”

He hung up.

I sat in the mud, waiting for the mafia boss to save me from his own sister.

And as I waited, I looked down at the envelope in my hands. The photographs of the weapons crates were still there.

But as I pulled them out to double-check, I noticed something I hadn't seen in the chaotic lighting of Samuel’s living room.

I looked closely at the stenciled symbol on the side of the illegal wooden crates.

May you like

It wasn't a cartel symbol.

It was the official insignia of the Chicago Police Department.

Related Stories

Other posts