Chapter 2 - The Key with the Apple Handle

The silence on the terrace was absolute, broken only by the sound of the evening breeze rustling the leaves of the old apple tree.
Madison’s red satin dress suddenly looked less like a weapon and more like a costume she was failing to pull off. She stared at the tiny silver bracelet in my hand, her perfectly manicured fingers trembling.
“Your mother?” I repeated, my voice dropping to a whisper.
I looked from the bracelet engraved with ELIZABETH to the brass key with the apple handle resting in my other palm. My mother’s name. My mother’s key.
“My mother was Elizabeth,” I said, the words feeling heavy on my tongue. I took a step toward Madison. “My mother buried this. Under our tree. At our house in the suburbs before Nicholas moved it here.”
Madison backed up until her heels hit the edge of a marble planter. “No. My mother’s name was Elizabeth. She gave me up when I was two years old. She told my adoptive parents she left a bracelet buried under an apple tree as proof of who I was.”
I felt a cold knot tighten in my stomach. I was twenty-five. Madison was twenty-three. If my mother, Elizabeth, had given a child away two years after I was born…
Answer One, Open Two. Madison was my half-sister. But if my mother had another child, why did she keep it a secret? And why did Madison end up as the mistress to my husband?
“You’re lying,” I said, shaking my head. “My mother would never abandon a child. She loved me. She loved our family.”
“She loved you,” Madison spat, her momentary panic turning into a venomous, defensive anger. “She clearly didn't want me.”
Nicholas finally broke his stunned silence. He stepped between us, his massive frame blocking my view of Madison. “Enough. Both of you. This is some kind of mistake. Sarah, go inside. I’ll handle this.”
“Handle it?” I scoffed, a bitter laugh escaping my throat. I looked at the man who had promised to protect me. “Like you handled your vows? I’m not going anywhere, Nicholas. Especially not into a house where I’m treated like a nuisance.”
I gripped the brass key tightly in my fist. I remembered my mother’s kitchen in our old suburban house. The key had hung on a hook shaped like a sunflower, right above the heavy oak cellar door. A door my father had permanently bolted shut when I was ten years old, claiming the foundation was unsafe.
But my father was a carpenter. He didn't bolt doors; he fixed them.
“Sarah,” Nicholas warned, his voice taking on that low, dangerous rumble that commanded obedience from the criminal elements he controlled. “Give me the key.”
“Why?” I challenged, meeting his hard gaze. “Are you afraid of what my mother hid?”
“I’m afraid of you stressing the baby,” he said, gesturing to my eight-month belly.
“You didn't care about my stress when you moved your mistress into my bedroom,” I fired back.
Madison stepped out from behind him, her eyes fixed on the key. “I want that key, Sarah. It’s mine. It proves who I am.”
“It proves nothing yet,” I said, backing away from both of them toward the old apple tree. “And you aren't getting it.”
Before Nicholas could grab me, the oldest gardener—the one who had handed me the box—stepped into his path. He didn't say a word. He just stood there, holding a heavy steel shovel.
Nicholas stopped. He wasn't a man who fought his own battles if he didn't have to. He glared at the gardener. “You’re fired.”
“I work for the landscaping company, Mr. Ferraro,” the older man replied calmly. “Not you. And Mrs. Ferraro asked you to stop.”
I didn't wait to see what happened next. I turned and walked quickly across the manicured lawn, my hand resting protectively over my stomach. I didn't head for the mansion. I headed for the heavy iron gates at the edge of the property.
“Sarah!” Nicholas shouted from the terrace. “Where are you going?”
“To open a door,” I called back, never breaking my stride.
I hailed a taxi at the end of the street. I gave the driver the address of my childhood home in the suburbs. We had sold it after my father died, but I knew the current owners were vacationing in Europe for the month.
The ride took forty-five minutes. Forty-five minutes of staring at the brass apple key in the dim light of the cab.
If Madison was my sister, my entire life was a lie. The perfect, loving parents I remembered had harbored a devastating secret.
The taxi pulled up to the modest, two-story house. The front yard looked different—the new owners had planted rose bushes where my mother’s hydrangeas used to be, and there was a gaping hole in the backyard where my apple tree used to stand.
I paid the driver and walked around to the back of the house. The motion sensor lights flicked on, illuminating the old, slanted wooden storm doors leading down to the cellar.
My heart hammered against my ribs. I knelt down awkwardly, my pregnant belly making the movement difficult.
The heavy iron padlock my father had installed fifteen years ago was still there, rusted and covered in cobwebs.
I slid the brass key with the apple handle into the lock. It was a perfect fit.
I turned it. With a sharp, metallic clack, the padlock sprang open.
I pulled the heavy wooden doors open, revealing a steep set of concrete stairs descending into absolute darkness.
I pulled out my phone, turning on the flashlight, and carefully stepped down. The air smelled of damp earth and old wood.
At the bottom of the stairs was a heavy steel door. It wasn't locked.
I pushed it open, shining my light into the small, windowless room.
It wasn't a storage cellar.
It was a perfectly preserved nursery.
Pink wallpaper. A white crib. A rocking chair. And sitting in the center of the crib was a plush, worn teddy bear holding a small envelope.
I walked over, my hands shaking violently. I picked up the envelope. It was addressed to Sarah, in my mother’s neat, cursive handwriting.
I tore it open and pulled out a single sheet of paper.
My dearest Sarah,
If you are reading this, I am gone, and the tree has given up its secret. I never wanted to lie to you. But your father and I had no choice. Madison is not your sister.
May you like
I stopped reading, my breath catching in my throat. I read the next line.
Madison is Nicholas’s daughter.