Chapter 3 - The Faded Birth Certificate

The flashlight beam trembled in my hand, illuminating the impossible words written in my mother's familiar cursive.
Madison is Nicholas’s daughter.
I sank into the dusty rocking chair in the corner of the hidden nursery, the wood creaking loudly in the silent cellar. My hands instinctively wrapped around my pregnant belly, shielding my unborn child from the devastating truth echoing in the cold room.
My husband, thirty-nine-year-old Nicholas Ferraro, wasn't just having an affair with a twenty-three-year-old woman. He was sleeping with his own child.
Bile rose in my throat. I forced myself to keep reading the letter, my eyes blurring with hot tears.
Twenty-four years ago, Nicholas was a violent, reckless teenager working for his father's syndicate. He got a local girl pregnant. The girl was terrified of his family, so she came to your father and me for help. We hid her in this cellar until she gave birth. We planned to raise the baby as our own. But Nicholas’s father found out. He sent men to take the child.
We managed to smuggle the baby out to a safe family out of state before they arrived. We buried the silver bracelet under the apple tree as a marker, a promise that we would remember her.
I flipped the page, my heart hammering a frantic rhythm against my ribs.
Nicholas never knew the baby was a girl. His father told him the child died. But Nicholas never stopped looking for the family that helped her. Sarah, if Nicholas ever finds out who you are, if he ever connects you to us... he will destroy you. Trust no one. Especially not him.
I dropped the letter into my lap, gasping for air in the dusty room.
Nicholas hadn't married me because he loved me. He hadn't moved the apple tree because it was sentimental.
He married me to keep me close, waiting for the tree to give up the secret of what my parents had done. He had been hunting for his lost child, and he had used my love as a cage to trap me until he found the answers.
And Madison... Madison thought my mother had abandoned her. She didn't know the monster she was sleeping with was her own father.
Answer One, Open Two. Nicholas didn't know Madison was his daughter, and Madison didn't know Nicholas was her father. But if Nicholas thought the child died, why was he digging up my tree? And how did Madison end up in his bed in the first place?
Suddenly, a heavy footstep sounded on the concrete stairs behind me.
I froze, killing the flashlight instantly.
"Sarah."
The voice was deep, echoing in the dark cellar. Nicholas.
"I know you're down here," he called out, his voice unnervingly calm. "My security team tracked the GPS in your phone."
I sat perfectly still in the rocking chair, praying the darkness would hide me. But the beam of a heavy tactical flashlight swept across the room, illuminating the white crib, the pink wallpaper, and finally, my yellow maternity dress.
Nicholas stepped into the room. The expensive suit was gone, replaced by a dark sweater that highlighted the violent tattoos creeping up his neck.
He didn't look angry. He looked victorious.
"I always knew your parents were hiding something," Nicholas murmured, walking slowly toward me. "When I saw that brass key tonight, I remembered your father wearing it on a chain around his neck twenty years ago. I knew it opened the one door he never let anyone near."
I stood up, gripping the letter tightly in my fist behind my back. "You used me."
"I married you," he corrected smoothly, stopping a few feet away. "It was a strategic decision. Your parents humiliated my family by stealing what belonged to us. I needed to know where they hid the child."
"You thought the child was dead," I challenged, keeping my voice remarkably steady despite the terror shaking my bones.
Nicholas offered a cold, humorless smile. "My father told me it died. But my father was a liar. He didn't want a bastard heir complicating his empire. I knew it survived. I just needed to know where."
He held out his hand. "What did you find, Sarah? Where is my son?"
He still thought it was a boy.
I looked at the man I had shared a bed with. The man who had kissed my stomach and promised me a family. He was a monster who viewed human lives as property to be claimed or discarded.
If I told him Madison was his daughter, the psychological horror would destroy her, and he would never let either of us walk away alive. He would erase the mistake to protect his empire.
I had to protect my daughter. And I had to protect Madison from the truth, no matter how cruel she had been to me.
"I didn't find anything," I lied, looking him dead in the eye. "The room is empty."
Nicholas’s eyes narrowed. He stepped closer, crowding my space, his sheer size intimidating. "You're a terrible liar, Sarah."
He reached out and snatched my arm, twisting me roughly. The letter fluttered from my hand, landing on the dusty floorboards.
Nicholas picked it up.
I closed my eyes, bracing for the explosion.
He read the first page. His face went entirely blank.
He read the second page.
The flashlight trembled in his hand. He looked up at me, all the color draining from his face. The ruthless mob boss looked suddenly, violently ill.
"Madison," Nicholas whispered, the name catching in his throat like broken glass. "She's..."
Before he could finish the sentence, a loud, sharp voice echoed from the top of the stairs.
"Vince? Are you down there?"
It was Madison. She had followed him.
Nicholas spun around, panic flaring in his dark eyes for the first time since I'd known him. He looked at the letter in his hand, then at the stairs.
"Don't come down here!" Nicholas roared, his voice cracking with a desperate, sickening horror.
But high heels were already clicking down the concrete steps. Madison appeared in the doorway, her red satin dress glowing in the beam of Nicholas’s dropped flashlight.
She looked at the pink nursery. She looked at Nicholas, who looked like he was about to vomit.
Then she looked at the letter in his trembling hand.
"What is that?" Madison asked, her eyes narrowing suspiciously. She stepped into the room, holding a small, silver handgun she must have taken from Nicholas's study. "Did she find the proof of who my mother gave me to?"
"Madison, stop," Nicholas pleaded, backing away from her. "Put the gun down."
"Give me the letter, Vince," Madison demanded, aiming the weapon at his chest. "I want to know why my mother abandoned me."
Nicholas looked at me, a silent, desperate plea in his eyes. The man who controlled Chicago's underworld was begging a pregnant woman for help.
I took a deep breath. I had to choose.
I stepped between them, facing Madison.
"The letter says your mother didn't abandon you, Madison," I said firmly. "She gave you away to protect you."
Madison scoffed, her grip tightening on the gun. "Protect me from what?"
May you like
I looked at Nicholas over my shoulder. Then I looked back at Madison.
"From your father."