Plot twist

Chapter 3 - THE SECOND WATCH THAT NEVER EXISTED

"Who signed it?"

Adrian turned the inventory toward me.

At the bottom, beneath the list of belongings supposedly recovered from James's wrecked car, was a name.

Owen Mercer.

I recognized it immediately.

Owen was Adrian's head of security.

He was a broad-shouldered man in his forties who inspected the estate's gates, supervised the armed guards, and decided which visitors were allowed past the front entrance.

For three years, I'd watched him move through the mansion with quiet authority.

He rarely smiled.

He was careful around Nora.

And he never seemed surprised when Adrian made a decision.

Now I was staring at his signature on a document that contained something impossible.

"He knew this watch wasn't in the car," I said.

Adrian didn't answer immediately.

He was examining the scratched silver case.

Finally, he said, "Perhaps the inventory was prepared from an expected list of James's belongings."

"Then why does it say recovered?"

"That's what I intend to ask."

I looked toward the windows.

Nora was drawing a purple dog.

She'd already forgotten the adults' frightening conversation.

I envied her.

"Adrian, I don't want Nora involved in any of this."

He followed my gaze.

"Neither do I."

"You can't promise something and then order your men to handle it."

His expression tightened.

"Clara—"

"Please listen."

I swallowed.

"I have spent three years making decisions based on keeping her safe. She doesn't know about the rumors. She doesn't know what people say about your family."

Adrian was quiet.

Then he said, "I won't question her about James. I won't use her to settle whatever happened to him."

I looked at him.

"And I won't take her away from you," he added.

For the first time that morning, I felt able to breathe.

But I still didn't entirely trust him.

Trust wasn't something his words could create in five minutes.

Adrian asked Mrs. Holloway to supervise Nora while we examined the inventory.

He didn't send her elsewhere.

He didn't insist that I surrender my daughter.

That mattered.

I explained that James had carried the pocket watch in a small brown leather pouch.

The pouch was still in my dresser.

Adrian asked whether I would be willing to show it to him.

I hesitated.

It was one of the few things I'd kept from the life James and I shared.

But the false inventory frightened me more than exposing another memory.

"Yes," I said.

We went upstairs.

Adrian stopped at the entrance to my small room in the staff wing.

He looked around.

The narrow bed.

The secondhand dresser.

Nora's toys arranged in a basket.

Two coats hanging behind the door.

For a moment, he seemed uncomfortable.

"Have you and Nora lived here the entire time?"

"Since I started working."

"Mrs. Holloway told me you were in staff accommodation."

"Yes."

He looked at the little folding bed beside mine.

It was too short for Nora now.

I'd been saving to replace it.

Adrian noticed.

But he didn't comment.

I opened the dresser.

Beneath old scarves lay the brown leather pouch.

Inside was a photograph of James and me outside a Boston coffee shop.

I handed it to Adrian.

He stared at his brother's face.

James wore a navy coat.

He was laughing.

His arm rested around my shoulders.

I'd forgotten how young we looked.

"That was the day he proposed a trip to Vermont," I said.

Adrian looked up.

"James hated Vermont."

I almost smiled.

"He said he wanted to learn to ski."

"James couldn't keep his balance on ice."

"He told me that too."

For one brief moment, Adrian laughed softly.

Then his expression changed.

He looked at the photograph again.

"Clara, I didn't know he was happy."

The admission startled me.

I looked at him.

"He was."

Adrian swallowed.

"For the last year of his life, he barely spoke to me unless it was business."

I remembered James sometimes growing quiet after calls from his brother.

I'd assumed it was ordinary family tension.

Now I wondered whether it had been something worse.

Adrian returned the photograph.

Then examined the pouch.

Inside was an old repair receipt from a Boston watchmaker.

James had taken the watch there several months before his death.

The receipt listed the serial number and a distinctive repair to the winding mechanism.

Adrian photographed it.

"This gives us something to compare against the property records," he said.

"Will Owen know you're checking?"

"He'll know questions are being asked."

I didn't like the sound of that.

"Is he dangerous?"

Adrian looked at me.

"He's been loyal to my family for fifteen years."

"That's not what I asked."

He paused.

Then answered.

"He's capable of being dangerous."

My stomach tightened.

Adrian looked toward the hallway.

"Which is why we won't let him near Nora while this is reviewed."

Later that afternoon, Owen was asked to explain the inventory.

He appeared surprised by the question.

Then said the list had been assembled from belongings James was known to carry.

"The actual evidence was damaged," he explained.

"Then why certify it as recovered?" Adrian asked.

Owen glanced at the watch.

His expression changed.

"Where did you find that?"

"Answer the question."

Owen exhaled.

"It was a chaotic investigation. The insurer wanted a complete list."

Adrian studied him.

"And you supplied one whether the items were found or not?"

"Some entries were based on family descriptions."

That explanation might account for a careless document.

But it didn't explain why the list had later been presented as evidence that James carried the watch when he died.

Adrian dismissed him and requested an independent review of the original crash materials.

After Owen left, I looked at Adrian.

"Do you believe him?"

"I believe he's leaving something out."

I nodded.

Then I noticed a photograph protruding from the folder Owen had left behind.

It showed James's damaged car beside a tow truck.

The image was grainy.

Rain streaked the roadway.

A second vehicle stood beyond the police barrier.

A dark SUV.

I leaned closer.

The driver-side door was open.

Beside it stood a man in a dark coat.

His face wasn't clear.

But I recognized the distinctive white stripe on the vehicle's rear door.

I'd seen that marking on Cole security vehicles for years.

I pointed toward it.

"Is that one of your cars?"

Adrian leaned forward.

His expression changed.

"That's an older security vehicle."

"Was Owen there?"

Adrian didn't answer.

He enlarged the photograph.

The man near the SUV wore a jacket with the Cole security insignia.

The same insignia Owen's senior officers still wore.

Adrian stared at the timestamp.

Then looked at the original accident report.

Owen had stated that he arrived after police secured the scene.

But the photograph was taken earlier.

Nearly twenty minutes before the first official report listed his arrival.

I felt cold.

"Why would he lie about that?"

Adrian's jaw tightened.

Then he pointed to something near the edge of the image.

Another man was standing beside James's car.

Not a police officer.

Not a firefighter.

A man wearing a gray raincoat.

Adrian whispered, "I know him."

I looked up.

"Who?"

He stared at the photograph.

May you like

Then slowly turned toward me.

"That's Dominic Shaw. And he told me he was in New York when James died."

Related Stories

Other posts