Chapter 10 - THE THREE MEN EVERYONE THOUGHT WERE DEAD

"One of those men is still alive?"
Adrian stared at Rachel.
She nodded.
"His name is Raymond Carver. He was involved with the shipping contractor that operated the gray truck."
I looked toward the photograph of James's wrecked car.
For nearly four years, I'd lived in fear of the stories surrounding those three men.
People said Adrian had made them disappear after his brother's funeral.
I'd imagined terrible things.
And now one of them was apparently living in Maine.
"Where are the others?" Adrian asked.
"One is believed to be living outside the country. The third hasn't been located."
"Why did they leave?"
"That's what Carver has agreed to discuss."
Rachel explained that Raymond had legal representation and was willing to provide information through investigators.
He wasn't offering to speak because he suddenly felt generous.
He was facing questions about old financial transactions, and he wanted his account considered alongside the evidence.
I appreciated the distinction.
A man involved in a dangerous business arrangement might tell the truth for reasons that had nothing to do with becoming a better person.
That didn't make his information useless.
But it meant it needed verification.
The interview took place several days later.
Adrian and I weren't permitted to conduct it ourselves.
Rachel attended as part of the independent review, and she later explained the findings to us.
Raymond confirmed that his company had supplied a gray delivery truck on the night James died.
He said Dominic Shaw had arranged the assignment.
The stated purpose was to stop James from reaching an outside compliance reviewer.
According to Raymond, the men were told James carried documents that could destroy several businesses.
"What were they supposed to do?" Adrian asked when Rachel summarized the account.
"Block his route and force him to turn back."
I felt sick.
"On a rain-slick highway?"
Rachel nodded.
"The assignment was dangerous from the beginning."
"Did Dominic tell them to kill him?" I asked.
"Carver denies receiving an explicit instruction to kill. But the distinction between intending an interception and recklessly creating a fatal collision is something investigators are examining."
Adrian looked away.
For years, he'd imagined rival criminals seeking revenge against the Cole family.
Now the evidence suggested a different truth.
The men he'd blamed had been hired by someone inside his own organization.
And James had been their target because he was trying to expose financial misconduct.
Rachel continued.
"Carver says the truck moved across James's lane near an exit ramp. James swerved. He lost control."
I covered my mouth.
I could almost see the scene.
Rain.
Headlights.
A truck moving unexpectedly.
James trying to avoid it.
Then the road disappearing beneath him.
"Did they help him?" I whispered.
Rachel's expression was grave.
"Carver says he stopped farther down the road. He didn't approach the wreck."
I closed my eyes.
James had been alone.
At least until other people arrived.
I thought about the ordinary life we'd been planning.
The house.
The garden.
The children we'd talked about someday.
He'd been trying to come home.
And someone had decided his questions were too dangerous.
Adrian stared at the table.
"Why did the three men disappear?"
Rachel took a breath.
"Carver says Dominic arranged their departure after the crash. They were told the Cole family would hold them responsible if they stayed."
I looked at Adrian.
He looked devastated.
"Dominic used me," he whispered.
Rachel nodded.
"He may have used your reputation as part of the effort to keep them silent."
Adrian stood and walked toward the window.
For several minutes, he didn't speak.
Then he said, "I spent four years hating men who were paid to do Dominic's work."
I looked at him.
"They still helped cause the crash."
"I know."
His voice broke.
"But Dominic made sure I never looked beyond them."
The revelation changed something fundamental.
The fear surrounding Adrian hadn't merely protected his reputation.
It had helped conceal wrongdoing inside his own organization.
People believed he'd retaliated.
Others were too afraid to ask questions.
And Dominic had been able to continue managing business as usual.
That evening, Adrian asked whether I would join him for dinner.
I hesitated.
Not because I disliked him.
But because I'd spent three years keeping a careful distance between my life and his.
Then Nora ran toward him holding a plastic dinosaur.
"Uncle Adrian! Hungry?"
He looked at her.
"Very."
She nodded.
"Dinosaur too."
I laughed.
Adrian smiled.
"Then we should feed him."
We ate in the smaller family dining room.
Not the enormous formal dining room where business associates gathered.
Mrs. Holloway brought soup and roast chicken.
Nora insisted that her dinosaur sit on a chair.
Adrian accepted the arrangement without argument.
For a little while, we were simply people eating dinner.
No security reports.
No financial documents.
No photographs of wrecked cars.
Then Nora pointed at a framed photograph of James on the mantel.
"Daddy."
Adrian looked toward it.
"Yes."
She studied his face.
"You miss him?"
His expression changed.
"Very much."
Nora climbed down from her chair.
She walked to Adrian and placed one small hand on his knee.
"Mommy misses him too."
I felt tears rise.
Adrian looked at me.
For the first time, there was no suspicion in his expression.
Only understanding.
He lifted Nora gently onto the chair beside him.
"Then maybe we can miss him together."
She nodded.
"Okay."
Later, after Nora fell asleep, Adrian and I sat in the study.
He asked whether I would help choose a photograph of James for a family memorial.
I agreed.
But I told him something important.
"Nora isn't going to grow up with people describing her father only as a victim."
Adrian looked at me.
"Of course not."
"She needs to know he was funny. That he was kind. That he used to burn pancakes and make ridiculous jokes."
He smiled sadly.
"James also sang terribly."
I laughed through tears.
"He did."
"Especially in the car."
"Every song."
Adrian nodded.
"Then we'll tell her all of it."
The following morning, Rachel brought another finding.
Raymond Carver had provided a photograph taken shortly after the crash.
It showed the roadside from a different angle than the original police images.
A gray delivery truck stood farther down the highway.
The damaged Cole security SUV was visible.
And near James's car stood Dominic Shaw.
He was holding something.
A narrow blue envelope.
I leaned closer.
The envelope had been partially protected by a dark leather document case.
On the front, in James's handwriting, was a name.
Clara.
My hands began shaking.
"That's the envelope."
Adrian looked toward me.
I could barely speak.
"James left it for me."
Rachel nodded.
"It appears consistent with Mrs. Holloway's description."
I stared at Dominic's hand.
He'd possessed that envelope after the accident.
And somehow, he'd later received the same envelope from the mansion's household records.
That meant he'd had two opportunities to destroy it.
Or perhaps he'd never destroyed it at all.
Rachel looked at Adrian.
"There's something else."
She pointed toward the bottom of the photograph.
A small portion of the envelope was visible beneath Dominic's thumb.
It bore a handwritten date.
The day James died.
But below the date was a short instruction.
I leaned closer.
The words were partially obscured.
May you like
Only the final line was readable.
"If Clara is ever found, do not let Dominic decide what she knows."