Plot twist

Chapter 5 - THE GHOST OF THE MAILMAN

The rain battered the muddy alleyway, but the only sound I heard was the blood roaring in my ears.

Anthony Varano stared at the gold pocket watch sitting in the dirt. He didn't reach for it. He looked at it as if it were a bomb waiting to detonate.

“Anthony?” I asked softly, shivering in my soaked uniform. “You gave Charlie Kincaid that watch?”

Anthony slowly nodded. He didn't look away from the gold casing.

“Thirty years ago,” Anthony said, his voice hollow. “I was a young man. Stupid. Reckless. I got ambushed by a rival crew three blocks from here. I took a bullet in the shoulder. I dragged myself into an alley and passed out, bleeding to death.”

He looked up at the yellow house.

“Charlie found me on his mail route early the next morning,” Anthony continued. “He didn't call the cops. He knew who I was. He hauled me into his kitchen, patched me up, and kept me hidden for three days until I was strong enough to leave. He saved my life.”

I stared at the mafia boss. The most powerful man in Chicago owed his entire empire to a mail carrier who liked extra butter on his potatoes.

“I gave him that watch when I took over the family,” Anthony whispered. “It was a promise. As long as he held it, the Kincaid family was under my absolute protection. Charlie wore it every single day.”

“Bess told me Charlie died in his sleep,” I said, confusion twisting my stomach into knots. “She said his heart just gave out. Why would Wade Mercer have his watch?”

Anthony finally reached down and picked up the watch. He wiped the mud away with his thumb.

“Because Wade didn't just hide his own ledgers in this bag, Marlowe,” Anthony said grimly. “He hides his leverage. Things he can use to control people.”

Anthony unzipped the duffel bag completely. He ignored the leather-bound ledgers and dug deeper into the canvas.

He pulled out a manila envelope sealed with red tape.

He tore it open.

Inside was a single, typed document. An official medical examiner’s report.

Anthony read it by the beam of his flashlight. The muscles in his jaw tightened so fiercely I thought his teeth might shatter.

“Charlie didn't die of a heart attack,” Anthony said, his voice dropping to a terrifying, lethal register.

“What?” I gasped.

“The coroner’s report was falsified,” Anthony said, handing the paper to me. “He was poisoned. Digitalis. It mimics a heart attack in elderly men. Someone murdered him, paid the coroner to cover it up, and stole the watch to prove the job was done.”

My knees gave out. I stumbled back against the wooden stairs of Bess’s porch.

Charlie Kincaid. The man who welcomed widows and strays to his dinner table. Someone had murdered him in his own home.

“Wade?” I asked, tears springing to my eyes. “Did Wade kill him?”

“Wade is an accountant, not a hitter,” Anthony growled, shoving the report back into the envelope. “He orchestrated it. And kept the watch and the real autopsy report as insurance against whoever actually slipped the poison.”

Anthony turned toward the street, where his men were loading a struggling Wade Mercer into the trunk of a black SUV.

Anthony walked toward the car with purposeful, terrifying strides. I ran after him, terrified of what he was about to do.

He reached the SUV just as the guards were about to slam the trunk shut.

“Wait,” Anthony ordered.

The guards stepped back. Anthony stared down at Wade, who was bound and gagged in the trunk.

Anthony didn't yell. He pulled the gold pocket watch from his coat and held it dangling by its chain inches from Wade’s terrified face.

Wade’s eyes widened in sheer panic. He began thrashing wildly against his zip-ties, screaming muffled pleas through the gag. He knew exactly what Anthony had found.

“Take the gag out,” Anthony said coldly.

A guard ripped the tape from Wade’s mouth.

“Anthony, please!” Wade shrieked, gasping for air. “I didn't do it! I swear to God, I didn't want him dead! I was just holding the evidence!”

“Who killed him, Wade?” Anthony asked, his voice deathly quiet.

“I can't tell you!” Wade sobbed. “If I tell you, they’ll kill me!”

“If you don't tell me,” Anthony promised, his eyes burning with absolute, uncompromising fury, “I will make you beg for death before the sun comes up.”

Wade stared at the mafia boss. He saw that there was no negotiation. There was no amount of money that could buy his way out of a broken promise.

Wade swallowed hard, shaking violently in the trunk.

“It was about the waterfront expansion,” Wade whimpered. “Four years ago. Your rivals, the Moretti family. They wanted to buy up this entire neighborhood to build a massive smuggling port. But Charlie wouldn't sell. He rallied the neighbors. He convinced them to hold out. The Morettis were losing millions in delays.”

“So they poisoned him,” Anthony realized.

“Yes,” Wade cried. “The Morettis paid someone to slip the digitalis into his coffee at his own dinner table. They paid me to cover it up with the coroner.”

My mind raced. Sunday supper. Someone had sat at Bess’s table, eaten her roast, and poisoned her husband.

“Who?” Anthony demanded, pressing the barrel of his pistol hard against Wade’s forehead. “Give me a name, Wade.”

Wade closed his eyes, fresh tears streaming down his face.

“It wasn't a Moretti soldier, Anthony,” Wade whispered. “They needed someone who had access to the house. Someone Charlie trusted implicitly.”

“Who?” Anthony roared.

May you like

Wade looked past Anthony, locking eyes with me standing in the rain.

“It was Sylvia,” Wade wept. “It was my wife.”

Related Stories

Other posts