Chapter 6 - THE POISON IN THE GRAVY

The rain suddenly felt freezing, turning my blood to ice.
“Sylvia?” I gasped, stepping back from the car. “That’s impossible. She’s the victim! You beat her!”
“I hit her because I found out she was going back to that house!” Wade screamed from the trunk, panic completely eroding his composure. “I spent four years trying to keep her away from the Kincaids so she wouldn't feel guilty and confess! I didn't want my own wife going to prison for murder!”
Anthony stared down at the weeping, pathetic man. The mafia boss didn't look shocked; he looked like a predator analyzing its prey.
“Sylvia didn't even know the Kincaids four years ago,” Anthony stated coldly.
“Yes, she did,” Wade sobbed. “She didn't start going to Sunday supper six months ago, Anthony. She was there four years ago, under a fake name. She used to volunteer at the church bake sales with Bess. Charlie trusted her. The Morettis paid her two million dollars to slip the powder into his coffee mug. She wanted the money so she could finally leave me and start a new life.”
My stomach churned. The elegant woman crying in Anthony’s study. The woman Bess had just embraced and comforted.
She was a murderer.
“She took the money,” Wade wept. “But she never left me. The guilt broke her. She started going back to Sunday supper recently because she’s obsessed with the old woman. She’s trying to make amends without confessing.”
Anthony pulled his gun back from Wade’s forehead.
“Slam the trunk,” Anthony ordered his guards.
The heavy lid crashed down, plunging Wade into darkness.
Anthony turned to me. His face was a mask of terrifying, lethal calm.
“Get in the car, Marlowe,” Anthony said. “We are going back to my house.”
“Anthony, wait,” I pleaded, grabbing his wet sleeve. “Bess is alone in the study with her. If Sylvia realizes we know...”
“She won't realize anything,” Anthony said, opening the SUV door. “Not until I look her in the eye and show her the watch.”
We tore through the rainy streets, the siren of Anthony’s SUV wailing into the night. I sat in the passenger seat, my mind replaying every interaction I had ever witnessed between Bess and Sylvia.
The way Sylvia always insisted on pouring the coffee after dinner. The way she always looked at the empty chair beside Bess with a profound, almost paralyzing sadness.
It wasn't empathy. It was guilt.
Ten minutes later, we screeched to a halt in front of the Varano mansion. We didn't wait for the guards to open the doors. Anthony and I sprinted up the grand marble staircase and burst into the foyer.
The house was eerily quiet. The auction guests had long since departed, leaving only a few staff members cleaning up the ballroom.
We ran down the carpeted hallway toward Anthony’s private study.
Anthony grabbed the brass door handle and shoved the heavy oak doors open.
“Sylvia—” Anthony began, his voice booming.
He stopped dead in his tracks.
The study was empty.
The two teacups sat abandoned on the coffee table. The fireplace crackled quietly. But Bess and Sylvia were gone.
“Where are they?” I panicked, running to the desk.
“Luca!” Anthony roared, his voice echoing down the hallway.
The massive security chief ran into the study, out of breath.
“Boss, I’m sorry,” Luca panted. “Mrs. Mercer insisted on leaving. She said she needed air. She took Mrs. Kincaid with her.”
“You let my wife’s murderer walk out the front door with an elderly woman?” Anthony snarled, grabbing Luca by the lapels of his suit.
“She’s not your wife, Boss,” Luca stammered, confused. “And she said they were just going to the gardens. I had two men follow them.”
“Where did they go?” Anthony demanded, releasing his grip.
“They took a car,” Luca said, checking his earpiece. “My men are trailing them now. They’re heading south. Toward the Moretti territory.”
My blood ran cold. Sylvia wasn't just taking a drive. She was running. And she had taken her victim’s widow as a hostage.
“Get the cars,” Anthony ordered, his dark eyes flashing with absolute, unbridled fury. “If she hurts one hair on Bess’s head, I’ll burn her alive.”
We raced back outside, piling into a fresh SUV. Anthony drove this time, his hands gripping the steering wheel so tightly his knuckles were white. He merged onto the highway, tires screaming on the wet pavement.
“Where is she taking her?” I asked, staring out the window at the blurry city lights.
“She’s going to the Morettis for protection,” Anthony said grimly. “She knows Wade is finished. She knows if he talks, she’s dead. She’s bringing Bess as leverage to guarantee safe passage out of the city.”
“We have to stop her before she reaches their compound,” I said, panic gripping my throat. “If they get inside the Moretti gates, we can't touch them without starting a full-scale mafia war.”
“I don't care about a war,” Anthony said coldly. “I care about the promise I made to Charlie.”
The radio crackled to life.
“Boss, it’s Marco,” the voice of the tailing guard reported. “The target vehicle just pulled off the main highway. They aren't heading to the Moretti compound.”
Anthony frowned, hitting the speaker button. “Where are they?”
“They parked at the old South Shore Marina,” Marco replied. “It’s abandoned this time of year. Looks like they’re walking toward the docks.”
“Set a perimeter. Do not engage until I arrive,” Anthony commanded.
He slammed his foot on the accelerator.
Ten minutes later, we skidded into the gravel parking lot of the desolate, freezing marina. The wind howled off Lake Michigan, whipping the rain sideways. Rows of empty boat slips bobbed in the dark water.
Anthony drew his pistol, clicking the safety off.
“Stay behind me, Marlowe,” Anthony whispered, stepping out into the storm.
We crept silently down the wooden docks, the rain masking the sound of our footsteps. At the very end of Pier 4, illuminated by a single flickering security light, were two figures.
Sylvia stood near the edge of the dock, her silver gown plastered to her body by the rain.
Bess stood a few feet away from her, wrapped in her simple blue cardigan, looking remarkably calm for a woman being held at gunpoint.
Sylvia held a small, silver pearl-handled revolver aimed directly at Bess’s chest.
“I’m sorry, Bess,” Sylvia wept, the wind carrying her voice. “I didn't want it to be you. I didn't want any of this. I just wanted to be free.”
“You are free, Sylvia,” Bess said softly, her voice steady and gentle, completely devoid of fear. “Anthony took care of Wade. You don't have to run.”
“You don't understand!” Sylvia shrieked, her hand shaking violently. “Wade knows what I did! He knows about Charlie! If he talks to Anthony, Anthony will kill me!”
Anthony stepped out from the shadows, stepping directly into the pool of light under the flickering bulb.
“Wade already talked, Sylvia,” Anthony said, his voice cutting through the storm like a blade.
Sylvia gasped, spinning around to aim the gun at Anthony.
Anthony didn't flinch. He raised his pistol, aiming squarely at her head.
“Let her go,” Anthony ordered softly. “Or you die right here.”
Sylvia let out a broken, hopeless sob. She lowered her gun slightly, looking between Anthony and the dark, freezing water of the lake.
“I had to do it,” Sylvia cried, desperate for justification. “Wade was destroying me. I needed the money from the Morettis to disappear. Charlie wouldn't sell his house. He was holding up the deal. It was just business!”
Bess closed her eyes. The revelation that the woman standing in front of her had murdered her husband finally struck home.
But Bess didn't scream. She didn't rage.
She opened her eyes and looked at Sylvia with profound, shattering pity.
“Charlie always said you can't buy freedom with stolen money, sweetheart,” Bess whispered.
Sylvia stared at the elderly woman, completely broken by the sheer lack of hatred in Bess’s voice.
Sylvia slowly lowered her gun completely.
“I’m so sorry,” Sylvia wept, turning toward the edge of the dock.
She was going to jump. She was going to plunge into the freezing lake rather than face Anthony’s wrath.
Before she could take a step, a heavy, deafening gunshot echoed across the marina.
Sylvia gasped. She dropped the silver pistol and collapsed onto the wooden planks, clutching her shoulder as blood rapidly bloomed across her silver dress.
I screamed, instinctively dropping to the wet wood.
Anthony spun around, aiming his weapon into the darkness behind us.
May you like
Stepping out from behind a rusted boat hoist, holding a smoking, long-barreled revolver, was not a Moretti soldier.
It was the auctioneer from the charity dinner.