Chapter 2 - THE COFFEE HABIT

I barely slept.
The morning light filtering through the blinds felt harsh, an unwelcome intrusion into a reality I wasn't ready to face. The man beside me—my husband, but which one?—was still asleep. His chest rose and fell in a steady rhythm. The blanket had slipped down, exposing his left shoulder and the edge of his back.
I stared at him, my heart hammering a frantic beat against my ribs.
I needed to know. I couldn't spend the rest of my life jumping at shadows, second-guessing every word, every gesture. If this man was Santiago, the implications were staggering. It meant he had faked his own death. It meant he had let me grieve him, let our daughter grow up believing her father was ash in an urn, and then returned wearing his brother's identity.
But why?
And if this was Santiago, then whose body was in that urn?
I slipped out of bed as quietly as I could, grabbing my robe from the chair. I needed coffee. I needed a clear head.
The kitchen in our new house—a house Sebastian and I had bought together a month before the wedding—was pristine. It still smelled like fresh paint and unpacked cardboard.
I went through the motions of making coffee, my mind racing.
Santiago had been a coffee snob. He liked it black, strong enough to strip paint, and he always, always added a tiny pinch of salt to the grounds before brewing. He swore it cut the bitterness.
Sebastian, on the other hand, was a tea drinker. When he did drink coffee, it was heavily diluted with cream and sugar.
I watched the dark liquid drip into the carafe.
I heard footsteps on the stairs.
"Morning," a voice called out, groggy and rough with sleep.
I turned. He was standing in the doorway, wearing a pair of sweatpants, his hair mussed. He looked so much like the man I had buried that my breath caught in my throat.
"Morning," I managed, forcing a small smile. "How's your head?"
"Better," he said, rubbing his temples. "Must have been the champagne."
He walked over to the counter and reached for a mug.
I watched him like a hawk.
He didn't reach for the sugar bowl. He didn't open the fridge for the cream.
He poured the black coffee directly into the mug, lifted it to his lips, and took a long sip.
He didn't flinch.
"Perfect," he sighed, leaning against the counter.
My stomach plummeted.
Sebastian wouldn't drink black coffee. He couldn't stand the taste.
I gripped the edge of the counter, my knuckles turning white. I needed to say something. I needed to push, just a little, to see what would break.
"You know," I said, keeping my voice light, "I was thinking about Camila this morning. She's going to be so excited when she gets home from your parents' house."
He smiled, a soft, genuine expression that melted my heart even as it terrified me. "Yeah, I missed my little ladybug."
There it was again. The nickname.
"I was thinking," I continued, my voice trembling slightly, "we should take her to that park she loves this weekend. The one with the big wooden fort. Remember when she fell and scraped her knee on the slide last summer?"
He frowned slightly, his dark eyes meeting mine. "The wooden fort? You mean Zilker Park? She scraped her knee there last summer?"
He looked genuinely confused.
"Yes," I lied smoothly. "Don't you remember? You carried her all the way to the car."
He hesitated. "Right. Yeah, of course. The wooden fort."
I felt a cold sweat break out on the back of my neck.
Camila hadn't scraped her knee at Zilker Park last summer. She had scraped it three years ago, just a month before the accident.
Santiago had carried her to the car.
Sebastian hadn't even been in the state; he'd been in Chicago for a work conference.
The man standing in my kitchen had just "remembered" an event he wasn't present for, because he thought it had happened recently.
He wasn't Sebastian.
He was Santiago.
My dead husband was drinking coffee in my kitchen.
Before I could say another word, the doorbell rang.
We both jumped.
"Who could that be?" he asked, setting his mug down. "It's barely eight o'clock."
"I'll get it," I said, rushing out of the kitchen before he could follow.
I needed a second away from him. I needed to breathe.
I unlocked the front door and pulled it open.
Standing on the porch was Teresa. My mother-in-law.
She looked pale, her eyes wide and frightened. She was holding a small, worn leather box tightly against her chest.
"Mariana," she whispered, looking past me into the house. "Is he awake?"
"Yes," I said, my voice barely audible. "Teresa, what's wrong?"
She stepped inside, closing the door firmly behind her. She looked at me, her eyes brimming with tears.
"I couldn't sleep," she said, her voice trembling. "I kept thinking about the wedding. About him."
She held the leather box out to me.
"I found this in Sebastian's old room," she whispered. "I was packing up some of his things, getting ready to sell the house."
I took the box. It was heavy.
"Open it," she urged.
I flipped the brass latch and opened the lid.
Inside, resting on a bed of faded red velvet, was a tarnished silver watch. The glass face was cracked, and the hands were frozen at 11:42.
It was Santiago's watch. The one he had been wearing the night he died.
"The police gave that to me after the accident," Teresa said, a tear escaping down her cheek. "I put it in a box and hid it away. It was too painful to look at."
I stared at the watch. "But... you just said you found this in Sebastian's room."
Teresa nodded, her face contorting with grief and terror.
"I did," she whispered. "I found it hidden under a loose floorboard in his closet. Along with a plane ticket to Mexico, dated two days after the accident. A ticket in Sebastian's name."
May you like
She grabbed my arm, her grip surprisingly strong.
"Mariana," she breathed, her voice filled with a horrifying certainty. "I think the man you married last night killed my other son."