Plot twist

Chapter 3 - THE POLICE REPORT

Teresa’s words hung in the air, heavy and suffocating.

Killed my other son.

I stared at the tarnished silver watch in the leather box. Santiago's watch. Found hidden in Sebastian's room, alongside a plane ticket.

If the man in my kitchen was Santiago—and the scar, the coffee, the nickname all screamed that he was—then why would he have hidden his own watch in his brother's room? Why would he have a plane ticket in his brother's name?

None of it made sense. Unless Teresa was right. Unless this wasn't a miraculous return from the dead, but a calculated, cold-blooded murder.

"Teresa," I whispered, pulling her into the living room, away from the kitchen hallway. "You have to keep your voice down."

"He killed him," she sobbed quietly, clinging to my arm. "Santiago killed Sebastian, took his identity, and let me bury an empty urn!"

"We don't know that for sure," I argued, though my own mind was rapidly assembling the horrifying puzzle pieces.

If Santiago had wanted to disappear, faking his death would be the perfect way. But a body had been found in the burned wreckage of his car. A body that had been identified by dental records and the survivor’s testimony.

"The dental records," I said aloud, the realization hitting me like a physical blow. "Teresa, how were the bodies identified?"

Teresa wiped her eyes, looking confused. "The police told us. They said Santiago's dental records matched the remains in the driver's seat."

"But Sebastian survived," I pressed. "He told the police he was thrown from the passenger side."

"Yes," Teresa nodded. "He had a broken arm and a concussion, but he survived."

I closed my eyes. The pieces were shifting, forming a new, terrifying picture.

If the man who survived was actually Santiago, he could have easily swapped their wallets, their clothes, even their dental records if he had planned this carefully. They were identical twins. To a medical examiner dealing with a badly burned body, the differences would be negligible, especially if the surviving brother was confirming the identity.

Santiago had survived. Sebastian had died in the fire.

And Santiago had lived the last three years as his dead brother.

But why? Why go to such extreme lengths? Why abandon his life, his wife, his daughter, only to return to us under a false name?

"Teresa, listen to me," I said, gripping her shoulders. "You cannot say a word about this to him. You have to pretend everything is normal."

"Normal?" she gasped. "How can I pretend when my son is a murderer?"

"Because if he did this, if he's capable of this, we don't know what he'll do if he finds out we know," I warned her. "We need proof. We need to know exactly what happened the night of the accident."

Teresa swallowed hard, nodding slowly. "What do we do?"

"You go home," I said, handing her back the leather box. "Put this back exactly where you found it. Act like you just came over to check on us after the wedding. I'm going to look into the accident report. There has to be something we missed."

I walked Teresa to the door, forcing a smile as I opened it.

"Everything okay?" a voice asked.

I turned. Santiago—Sebastian, I had to remember to call him Sebastian—was standing in the hallway, holding his empty coffee mug.

"Yes," I lied smoothly. "Teresa just wanted to drop off a gift she forgot to give us yesterday."

Teresa managed a weak smile, holding up a decorative gift bag she had brought as a cover. "Just a little something for the new house. I'll let you two get back to your morning."

She practically fled down the driveway.

I closed the door, my heart pounding.

"She seemed nervous," he observed, his dark eyes studying me intently.

"Just overwhelmed, I think," I replied, walking past him toward the bedroom. "The wedding was a lot for her."

"Yeah, probably," he agreed, following me. "Hey, about yesterday... I'm sorry if I rushed things. I know this is a big adjustment."

He reached out and touched my arm. His hand was warm, familiar. The same hand that had held mine during Camila's birth. The same hand that had supposedly been severely burned three years ago.

I looked down at his wrist. There was no scar from a metal plate surgery.

"I'm fine," I said, pulling away gently. "I just need a shower. I'll be out in a minute."

I locked myself in the bathroom for the second time in twelve hours.

I turned the shower on full blast to mask the sound, then pulled my phone from my robe pocket. I needed the police report from the accident.

I navigated to the county records website, my fingers trembling as I typed in Santiago's name and the date of the crash.

The report was public record, heavily redacted, but the details were there.

Two-vehicle collision. A drunk driver had crossed the median, striking Santiago's car head-on. The other driver had died on impact. Santiago's car had caught fire.

The surviving passenger—identified as Sebastian Morales—had been found wandering near the wreckage, dazed and suffering from smoke inhalation and a broken arm.

I scrolled down to the witness statements. There was only one. A passing truck driver who had pulled over to help.

Witness stated he saw a man pull himself from the passenger side window as the flames erupted. The man tried to reach back into the driver's side, but the fire was too intense.

I read the line again.

The man tried to reach back into the driver's side.

If Santiago had planned this, if he had murdered his brother to fake his own death, why would he try to save him from the fire?

The narrative didn't fit. A cold-blooded killer wouldn't risk his own life to pull his victim from a burning car.

Unless he hadn't planned it.

Unless the accident was genuine, and the decision to swap identities had happened after the crash.

But why?

I turned off the shower, my mind reeling. I needed more information. I needed to speak to someone who had been there.

I looked at the witness's name on the report.

Marcus Thorne.

I quickly searched his name online. He was a local mechanic, owning a small auto repair shop on the outskirts of town.

I dried off, dressed quickly, and walked back into the bedroom.

He was sitting on the edge of the bed, looking at his phone.

"I have to run some errands," I said, grabbing my purse. "Just a few things we forgot for the house."

He looked up, surprised. "Now? I thought we were going to spend the morning together."

"I won't be long," I promised, feeling a stab of guilt at the lie. "I'll pick up some breakfast tacos on the way back."

"Okay," he agreed, though he looked disappointed. "Be careful."

I practically ran to my car.

I drove to Marcus Thorne's auto shop. It was a dusty, cluttered garage, filled with the smell of motor oil and exhaust.

Marcus was a burly man in his fifties, wiping grease from his hands as I approached.

"Help you, ma'am?" he asked.

"My name is Mariana Lopez," I said, my voice remarkably steady. "Three years ago, you witnessed a car accident on Highway 71. A fatal crash involving two brothers."

Marcus’s expression darkened. He stopped wiping his hands. "I remember. Terrible night."

"I need to ask you about what you saw," I pleaded. "The police report said you saw a man pull himself from the passenger side window."

"That's right," Marcus nodded slowly. "He was badly burned on his arms and face. He kept screaming for his brother."

"Did you see the driver?" I asked, my heart hammering.

Marcus hesitated, looking around the empty garage.

"The police asked me the same thing," he said quietly. "And I told them what I saw. The driver was trapped. The steering column had collapsed on his legs."

He looked me dead in the eye.

"But here's the thing, lady. The man who climbed out of the passenger window... he didn't have a broken arm. He was using both hands to try and pry the driver's door open. He only stopped when the gas tank blew."

I felt the blood drain from my face.

Sebastian's primary injury in the police report had been a broken left arm.

"Are you sure?" I whispered.

"I'm positive," Marcus said firmly. "The guy who got out wasn't the one with the broken arm. He was the one trying to save his brother."

I stumbled back, my mind spinning out of control.

If the survivor didn't have a broken arm, then the survivor wasn't Sebastian. The survivor was Santiago.

And Santiago had tried to save Sebastian.

But if Santiago hadn't murdered his brother... if he had tried to save him... why had he taken his identity? Why had he let me believe he was dead?

I thanked Marcus and practically ran back to my car.

As I sat in the driver's seat, my phone buzzed.

May you like

It was a text from an unknown number.

Stop asking questions, Mariana. If you dig any deeper, they will kill us both.

Related Stories

Other posts