Chapter 4 - THE SAFETY DEPOSIT BOX

I stared at the screen, the words blurring together.
Stop asking questions, Mariana. If you dig any deeper, they will kill us both.
My hands shook so violently I nearly dropped the phone.
Who sent this? How did they know I was asking questions? I had only just spoken to Marcus Thorne. Had someone been watching the garage?
I looked around the dusty parking lot, my heart pounding a frantic rhythm against my ribs. A battered pickup truck idled near the entrance, but the driver was hidden by the glare on the windshield. A woman walked a dog across the street. Everything looked terrifyingly ordinary.
I locked the car doors and started the engine. I needed to get away from here, but going home—going back to the man who was either a victim or a monster—felt equally dangerous.
They will kill us both.
The message implied a shared threat. It meant whoever sent it believed I was in danger, and that my husband—whichever twin he truly was—was also a target.
If Santiago had taken his brother's identity not out of malice, but out of fear... what was he running from?
I pulled out of the parking lot, my mind racing. I needed leverage. I needed something tangible, something real, before I confronted him.
The tarnished silver watch and the plane ticket Teresa had found.
Teresa had said she found them in a loose floorboard in Sebastian’s closet. But why would Santiago hide his own watch there?
Unless it wasn't a hiding place. Unless it was a message.
I thought back to the few times I had visited Sebastian's apartment before he moved in with his mother after the accident. He was a creature of habit. He kept his important documents in a small, fireproof safe in his bedroom closet.
I didn't have access to his old apartment, but he had moved all his belongings into our new house a month ago. The safe had to be there.
I drove back to our neighborhood, parking two blocks away. I didn't want him to hear my car pull up.
I walked the rest of the way, feeling like a trespasser in my own life.
I unlocked the front door as quietly as possible. The house was silent.
"Sebastian?" I called out, hating the taste of the name in my mouth.
No answer.
I crept upstairs to the master bedroom. His side of the closet was neatly organized, his shoes lined up with military precision. I pushed aside the hanging clothes and felt along the back wall.
Nothing.
I checked under the bed, behind the dresser. Nothing.
Then, I remembered the garage. He had spent most of yesterday afternoon organizing boxes out there.
I slipped downstairs and opened the door to the garage. It was dimly lit, smelling of cardboard and dust. In the far corner, hidden behind a stack of moving boxes, was a small, grey metal safe.
I knelt in front of it. It had a digital keypad.
I tried his birthday. Error. I tried my birthday. Error. I tried Camila's birthday. Error.
I stared at the keypad, frustration gnawing at me. What number would he use? If he was Santiago, what number meant the most to him?
I thought back to our life before the accident. Our anniversary? The day we bought our first house?
Then, I remembered the watch. The one Teresa had found. The hands were frozen at 11:42.
I punched the numbers in. 1-1-4-2.
A soft click echoed in the quiet garage. The safe popped open.
My breath caught in my throat. I pulled the heavy metal door wide.
Inside were three items.
A stack of hundred-dollar bills, thick enough to choke a horse.
A passport, issued five years ago, bearing Santiago's face and the name Elias Thorne.
And a small, black ledger.
I pulled the ledger out, my hands trembling. I flipped it open.
The pages were filled with names, dates, and massive sums of money. Some of the names I recognized—prominent businessmen in Austin, local politicians. Beside each name was a list of properties, offshore accounts, and wire transfer numbers.
It wasn't a diary. It was a blackmail ledger.
And the handwriting, neat and precise, belonged unmistakably to Sebastian.
I stared at the pages, the horrifying truth settling over me like a suffocating blanket.
Sebastian hadn't been the quiet, dependable brother I thought he was. He was running an extortion ring. He was blackmailing some of the most powerful people in the state.
And Santiago had found out.
I closed the ledger, the pieces of the puzzle finally snapping together with sickening clarity.
The accident wasn't an accident. Someone from that ledger had tried to kill Sebastian. The drunk driver who crossed the median hadn't been drunk; it had been a hit.
Santiago had survived the crash and tried to save his brother. But when Sebastian died in the fire, Santiago realized the people who wanted Sebastian dead would come after him next. They were identical twins. To a hitman, they were interchangeable targets.
So Santiago had taken his brother's identity. He became the quiet, unassuming survivor. He let his own name die in the fire to protect himself, and to protect us.
If you dig any deeper, they will kill us both.
He was trying to keep us safe by pretending to be the man they wanted dead, hoping they would believe the threat had died with him.
Suddenly, the garage door leading to the house creaked open.
I froze, the ledger still in my hand.
He stood in the doorway, silhouetted by the kitchen light.
He wasn't wearing his usual soft sweater and jeans. He was dressed in dark clothes, a heavy jacket zipped up to his chin. And in his right hand, pointing directly at the floor, was a black, suppressed handgun.
"You shouldn't have opened that safe, Mariana," he said, his voice flat, dead, devoid of any warmth.
I scrambled backward, pressing myself against the stack of moving boxes.
"Santiago?" I whispered, my voice breaking.
He took a step into the garage, raising the gun slightly.
"Santiago is dead," he said coldly. "He died in that fire three years ago."
I stared at him, my mind unable to process the words. If he wasn't Santiago... if Santiago was dead...
"But the scar," I stammered. "The scar on your hip. I saw it. Santiago got that scar when the shower door broke."
He let out a harsh, humorless laugh.
"You're right about the scar," he said, stepping closer. "Santiago did get it when the shower door broke."
He tilted his head, his dark eyes boring into mine.
"But he wasn't protecting you, Mariana. He was protecting me. Because we were fighting. I pushed him. And when he fell into the glass, I realized how easily I could take his place."
May you like
He raised the gun, pointing it directly at my chest.
"I'm Sebastian," he smiled. "And I think it's time you joined your husband."